5 ms·
That these skewed measures favouring women exist, does not mean that discrimination and sexual harassment towards women doesn't also exist. Sexism is still depr
by mcv 7y ago
That these skewed measures favouring women exist, does not mean that discrimination and sexual harassment towards women doesn't also exist. Sexism is still depressingly common. These measures seem like a very heavy-handed way to even the scales, but it tries to fight a symptom rather than the cause, and it's probably not very effective at that.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoIt's basically throwing money at a problem and hoping it solves it. But money or funding isn't the problem.
- abdullahkhalids 7y agoIt absolutely is. All other things equal, a graduate program with 20% women phd students vs one with 40-60% women phd students will have a lot more misogyny. Forcefully raising the number of women in a program insures that there are enough of them that they can work together and speak up when harassment and discrimination happens.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wvh 7y agoBut the primary goal of a graduate program isn't avoiding harassment and discrimination at all costs. It's to provide the best candidates for the relevant field. To "forcefully" throw in some extra "support pets" feels like a really silly solution to tackle that problem.
- abdullahkhalids 7y agoI don't agree at all. I think the primary goal of every government funded institution is to promote social welfare - not economic growth. As a physics PhD, I am totally happy if the progress in my field slows down by even 50%, if it means that 50% of the population, who currently are and feel discriminated against, aren't and don't feel that way any more. I will always vote for the political candidate who supports one over the other. In most (but not all) fields of human intellectual endeavor, we have made progress far beyond needed, that with the right politics and social commitment, every human on this planet can have all their needs and basic wants fulfilled. There is no need to constantly fuel the GDP, only the craft a world in which people can be happy.
- wvh 7y agoWe agree to disagree then, though my point isn't the GDP. As a not entirely neurotypical human being, I not unsurprisingly believe that mono-focus causes progress in technology and science; progress which has the potential to improve conditions in the world. I don't think the relative equality in today's (at least North/West European) society would have been possible without this progress beyond a society based on brute force. To me, scientific progress and understanding enables social welfare. At some point – and you can adapt this example to other fields – you want build a bridge that doesn't collapse, and niceness is not going to get you there. The engineer can be female, from an ethnic minority, disabled or a kid with rich parents, but you want to rely on them being a good engineer and not someone who got a free pass and cuddle treatment. This is why the primary goal should be skill and not some rather subjective sense of social justice. I feel you promote equality of outcome and not just equality of opportunity. This needs not be a black and white comparison, but consistently choosing politicians that prefer cuddle over hard results could very well lead to a society where there is no money for the weak, unprivileged, disadvantaged minorities, education, social welfare, medical care, etc; a society that – perhaps out of necessity – will squeeze out some of those people you'd want to support.
- yumyai 7y agoYes, but the concern of the parent is that maybe these measures might hurt women in the long run. I am more or less neutral at this. I never experience those extreme by myself.... except in some job-ad "For the same qualification, we will hire female candidate".
- ashelmire 7y agoI think a perception problem occurs if less-qualified women get more funding than men. That means that the male scientists who get funded will actually just be better at their jobs, which is going to have the effect of perpetuating the perception that men make better scientists (which I think is obviously untrue, but this has always been a problem with affirmative action policies). I don't really see a way to solve this at the grant funding level.
- SolaceQuantum 7y agoThis perception problem is in fact a problem, but this also ignores another explaination (speculatively) that less-qualified men are getting more funding over more-qualified women due to unconscious biases of the reviewers. Which at least has studies that say this might be the case. I don't know if we have studies that indicate evidence that less-qualified women are getting more funding than more-qualified men. For example this comment chain is mostly anecdata, which makes it difficult, as it relies on how good-faith we wish to take the anecdote and how that anecdote either enforces one's existing biases or can just be dismissed as anecdotal and not genuine studies. But even the "genuine" studies are in a field where we have a replication crisis. So, what I'm saying is: I don't know, and I don't think anyone else knows, the whole truth and breakdown of the matter. And I'd be suspicious of anyone claiming they are under a broadsale impression of anything regarding the quality of women in STEM.
- mafribe 7y agounconscious biases of the reviewers This can of course also be turned the other way around: "less-qualified women are getting more funding over more qualified men due to unconscious biases of the reviewers" studies that say this might be the case. Those 'studies' generally suffer from various forms of bias, in particular social desirability bias [1], and never reflect upon their social desirability bias. Often the authors of such studies also have a direct financial in the claimed outcome of the 'studies': To paraphase Upton Sinclair "It is difficult to get a woman to understand something, when her salary depends upon his not understanding it!". I challenge you to show me studie along the lines of what you suggest that even mention social desirability bias and financial interest as threats to validity. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_desirability_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_desirability_bias
- bitL 7y agoTry to be an attractive male and you'll soon see there are many unwanted advances in your direction from women as well. Nothing is black and white.
- mcv 7y agoI've tried, but I haven't seen many unwanted advances in my direction from women.
- wvh 7y agoI see it happen, though there's obviously less of a threat to female advances due to physiological reasons. Then again, most sexual activity isn't driven by physical power and violence, and situations can turn pretty awkward also when women take things too far.
- dwaltrip 7y agoGenerally speaking, a man doesn't need to fear that the woman giving unwanted attention may try to physically overpower them. So while we shouldn't ignore any difficulties faced by men, the situation isn't the same. Obviously, this only applies to heterosexual situations.
- bitL 7y agoI'll give you an example - a female boss asked me to "come to her hotel room" during a weekend on her visit to my city, making it clear with her body language what she wanted. I declined. Half a year later my earned/promised promotion didn't happen. Another situation - a former female colleague, a married wife with children, during a business trip suggested I go to her "beautiful" rented apartment she wanted to show me and that I could sleep there; "pajamas not needed", "marriage is just marriage, it's not important". I declined; she went cold in subsequent mutual interactions, and as she was a close friend of my boss (I don't want to explore how close), boss started to be cold towards me as well. So no, there is no threat of physical violence, but there is a significant threat of unjust manipulation that for some reason is not on our society's radar at all. Shitty behavior comes in all genders, but only one is called out for it.