5 ms·
Japan PM Abe: See no need to raise sales tax beyond 10% for decade
- lclarkmichalek 7y agoSales taxes are regressive - people who don't have a lot of money have to spend more of it to stay alive, and therefore pay more sales tax :/ I'd rather have a higher income tax and no sales tax. Income taxes are much more visible, but don't suffer from penalizing people who can't save.
- andrenth 7y agoWhat's your opinion on a sales tax but simultaneously making food and medicine tax-free?
- skrebbel 7y agoI don't understand why this is on HN. It looks to be a generic "politician makes non-promise" story.
- person_of_color 7y agoProbably to incite discussion on the state of the Japanese economy.
- chrisco255 7y agoI agree. It's offtopic.
- MacroAffairs 7y agoIt is not a "politician makes non-promise" story. It is actually a very credible claim because the Japanese government doesn't even need more tax income as they can lend freely. The government can lend as much Yen as they want. The tax hike is something that can help them get inflation, which has been too low for very long.
- LIV2 7y agoEven if it is not an empty promise I still don't understand how this is on topic for HN
- skrebbel 7y agoI called it a non-promise because, like every second time a politician says something, he appears to have carefully worded it such that he still change his mind later. Not because I don't believe him, I have no opinion on and no idea about Japanese internal economic policy. My argument is that the tl;dr here is "a politician said a thing", which is not usually notable enough for HN.
- Causality1 7y ago>earlier this year suggested Japan’s sales tax needed to rise to as much as 26% to pay for bulging social security costs Wouldn't that absolutely crater consumer spending? I know if I had to pay 26% sales tax suddenly everything I buy would be from China and ship labeled "personal gift".
- FDSGSG 7y agoWhy would the customs not collect sales tax on gifts? They certainly do in the EU.
- timwaagh 7y agoA lot of economists consider sales tax to be the best way to tax. The reason is it doesn't hinder savings and investments
- Radle 7y ago"The reason is it doesn't hinder savings and investments" -Said no low income earner ever. Sales taxes are regressive taxes. It's stealing out of the pockets of people who are too poor to find time for politics or who are too uneducated to understand that they are being mugged. If I was an economist with a college degree, I would also support sales tax.
- mikemotherwell 7y agoTax is undeniably complicated, and I have no firm opinion what is better, and I'm often shocked when people do. The regressive nature of a sales tax is bad, but then, income tax is so easy to avoid. We all need things, making sales tax almost unavoidable, and what's the point of being rich if you can't spend it? The problem with income tax is that it encourages the richest to run scams where the ROI is "cost of accountant + tax saved < expected tax = do it". If your income exceeds $100,000, it is almost guaranteed to be worth it to hire expensive lawyers. Then there are the terrible scams like the one I read (which I can't confirm) where startup founders with public companies receive a minimal income, like $1 per year, and instead borrow their yearly requirements against the value of their shares. That could be $10M tax free - it is borrowing so it isn't income - and a sales tax starts to look like a pretty good idea! That'd be $1M in tax on a sales tax of 10%, vs $0. Anyway, like I said, tax is complicated!
- baybal2 7y agoJapanese economy is a mystery to me. I think the state tried just every possible thing to reverse currency trends and ease fiscal restraints, but just all failed including an enormous quantitative easing (money printing basically)
- wtdata 7y agoJapan is the country with the biggest government deficit in the world, which is now at 253% of their GDP and increasing. I don't know exactly how the government proposes to even start reducing this (much less bring it towards 0%) without raising taxes.