5 ms·
> We are far beyond any reasonable carrying capacity. i fail to understand why any mention of reining in population growth creates such a knee jerk reaction of
by vkou 7y ago
> We are far beyond any reasonable carrying capacity. i fail to understand why any mention of reining in population growth creates such a knee jerk reaction of rejection.
Two reasons.
1. The last time eugenics, and population control was a mainstream ideology, it culminated in things like WWII, and the Holocaust. For various reasons, that's not a road people are particularly interested in going down again.
2. The wasteful habits and tastes of rich nations are are the reason we are in this mess. It is unreasonable to expect poor nations to to sacrifice to fix the problem we have created. Especially when the richest 25% of the world (Which, for odd reasons, is never the target of people talking about population control) currently consumes 50-70% of the world's resources.
- jelliclesfarm 7y ago1. but trying to rein in population to save habitat has nothing to do with eugenics or hatred.if we dont stop procreating at this rate, all of us will perish. 2. i disagree. the wasteful rich will never create as big a carbon foot print as the countries with the billion+ population: india and china. our carrying capacity is anywhere between 500 million-2 billion. in 1600s, we were 500 million. that would be a start. if everyone had 1/2 surviving child quota, we can get to that number in about 150-200 years.
- jogjayr 7y ago> the wasteful rich will never create as big a carbon foot print as the countries with the billion+ population: india and china. They have done exactly that for all but the past 10 years or so. On a per-capita basis, they still emit way more carbon.
- devoply 7y agohttps://www.ucsusa.org/sites/default/files/images/2017/11/gw-graphic-pie-chart-co2-emissions-by-country-2015.png https://www.ucsusa.org/sites/default/files/images/2017/11/gw... 2.5 x India.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoConsider this...how much of the world’ resources are used by the various countries to export to the rest of the world. China supplies most of the manufacturing muscle to the whole world including India. Also consider this...the foot print of India is much less because the resources are all used up. The older the country, the less natural renewables remains.. I am from India myself and I realize that their carbon foot print is certainly less than America even with what I said above..but 1+ billion people is simply not sustainable in a land which is water and power and resources availability is challenged. The entire world should adopt the 1/2 surviving child/person quota that is non transferable so we can maintain diversity in the gene pool and across cultural/socio-economic/religious segments. Population grows exponentially. That’s what the OP meant(I assume) with the comparison of human population to bacteria. The geometric progression will eventually explode within a constrained environment. And if resources aren’t available to continue, the die off will likely begin(I am not a microbiologist tho).. Does it matter which country one is from...species extinction is species extinction. We can arrest the speed and/retard the progression and explosion and die off sequence with strict population control quota across the board. Starting with 1/2 surviving child/person. We are all going to live longer or we can..but we can’t if we insist on living like it’s 1900.
- jogjayr 7y agoIndia's fertility rate is at the global average, has been dropping for decades, and that trend is expected to continue.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoIn 1981, it was 4.5. In 2016, it is 2.2. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_states_and_union_territories_of_India_by_fertility_rate https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_states_and_union_ter... In 1981, population was 700 million vs 1.3 billion in 2016. World population in 1981: 4.4 billion. World population in 2016: 7.4 billion. 2.2 replacement rate is still too high for India. China stats are at a more slower rate due to the one child policy. It wasn’t perfect and that’s why we need to incentivize rather than act punitively. If the US or China or even Europe or Africa has the accepted 2.1 replacement rate, they can manage due to land mass and resources..India is tiny and we are already bursting at the seams. While the US can claim to reduce population because it’s a ‘problem’..it’s a full blown crisis in India. The future generations will suffer. I can’t see the rationale. When one compares the quality of life benefits to low density living, it is baffling that current generations want their descendants to suffer and perish.
- devoply 7y ago> The wasteful habits and tastes of rich nations are are the reason we are in this mess. All the poor nations of the world would be as bad or worse given the opportunity to do so. There is no enlightenment in poverty. There is no moral high ground there either considering the amount of environmental damage that happens in poor countries like India at the hands of 1+ billion people.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoAlso: our current mode of procreation without saving our genetic material is not recommended as a planetary threat or mass extinction event can leave us severely compromised. For sure..a cataclysm or mass extinction event will..by definition..wipe out most if not all of the world’s living organisms..but we should be focusing on diverting our existing resources to living better to find solutions to save humanity and species survival rather than scraping by and hanging by a thread..hoping that mutations and sheer numbers will keep us going.