4 ms·
> "The government is too incompetent to manage such a system" which are cop-outs, imo. It's reality. Wishes aren't horses. UHC advocates claim that the US wo
by anamax 18y ago
> "The government is too incompetent to manage such a system" which are cop-outs, imo.
It's reality. Wishes aren't horses.
UHC advocates claim that the US would spend 10% with UHC. Let's see what that would mean.
The US spends about 15% of GDP on healthcare. Of that 15%, about half is spent by govt while the other half is private. Curiously enough, the govt covers about the same number of people as private spending.
For argument's sake, let's say that the govt currently spends 7% of gdp on health care. If govt is only going to spend 10% to cover just the people who currently have health care, that means that it will only spend 3% to cover the folks that are currently in the private system. (Yes, I'm ignoring the uninsured, but they just make the numbers worse.)
I'll repeat that - UHC folk are promising that the govt will cover the people it doesn't cover now for less than half what it pays to cover the people it covers today.
If you want to argue that UNC can do health care for 10% of gdp, start by fixing govt health care so it only spends 5% of gdp to cover the people it covers today.
You can kill private health care by simply opening up govt health care at cost if it's actually cheaper and better. However, as long as it isn't.....
Until govt health care is actually cheaper than private, it's absurd to argue that it will be. Govt health care isn't cheaper or more effective than private in the US.