31 ms·
I'm a friend of the superhuman CEO and have been following this company over the time it's been around, both by talking to him and from interactions with the of
by notsosuperhuman 7y ago
I'm a friend of the superhuman CEO and have been following this company over the time it's been around, both by talking to him and from interactions with the official channels. Here is my $0.02.
SH started out like any other startup, with the best of intentions and a cool idea but it just didn't take. The issue is that they're on the line to deliver and they haven't had the traction they'd like so I've seen it slide, slowly, over an extended period, into a desperate place that leaves them doing ugly things. You should read Rahul's blog on finding product fit, it tells you much.
Personally, I now think they're in a position where they are trying to mooch everything they can off of users in order to try and build a better product coupled with finding ways to be "unique" that will make them money/attractive. This means they end up in sketchy territory i.e. the pixels, forcing people to reveal how they use gmail in order to sign up, tracking every-single-aspect of how users are using their site, hyped up bullshit etc. I don't know if they're harvesting actual user data.
The fact is, they're between a rock and a hard place. They aren't profitable, and there's no real exit. Whatever features make them unique can be copied in months, if not weeks by any other provider. Why would Google buy them? Also, the feature set, as good as it is, only appeals to a tiny subset of users of email. Other aspects like corporate email not being allowed to be accessed by third party clients etc makes a difference too.
I wish them all well, but by God I would not want to be a part of this thing. It stinks.
- newmac 7y agoWith friends like that, Rahul hardly needs any enemies!
- graeme 7y agoThis doesn't read as accurate at all. Nobody has copied Superhuman's features. I'm sure you can't name another app that has. It's substantially faster to use than other email apps. I have strong doubts you're who you claim to be.
- pmart123 7y agoWhile I don’t know about the company traction, or sales tactics, I think it is fair to assume the feature set on email can be fairly easily replicated by the big players if they want to. Gmail added a lot of the Boomerang features as well as suggested autocomplete, etc. pretty quickly IMO.
- graeme 7y ago1. It looks years for gmail to copy boomerang 2. Gmail has no desktop app. It's reasonably fast, but not as fast as Superhuman. 3. Superhuman is a niche app, gmail caters to everyone. They can't reorient gmail around a tiny, high revenue portion of users 4. Gmail's iphone/ios apps lack the vast majority of desktop gmail's customizability features The competitor to Superhuman would be a similar niche app, not gmail itself.
- SibLiant 7y agoSo the company chooses to build email. EMAIL! Ok. What about their engineers or product concept was SOO different that building EMAIL would draw customers? Looking at their first page, the ONLY item that is unique here is "ENSURE YOUR EMAILS ARE READ". This almost seems like a parody sight - like it's not even real. Something is seriously fishy.
- baHaHaHaHaHaaa 7y agoOh, is that all this is? I got an email from some tech bro recruiter, and it had that rinky dink signature "sent with superhuman" and I kind of just shrugged at it. If it's just a retarded little pixel tracker for regular people, that's really funny because I think I'm the only person I know who disables automatic image loading 99% of the time on most of my accounts. Knowing the guy for his personality, I might've guessed it was that kind of an app, and I was careful not to ask because honestly I think he was waiting for me to ask so he could wave his dick in my face and drop the big reveal for all the times he might have "caught" me. Yeah fucking right. Emailing a developer with a pixel? Are you kidding? I have to wonder what he made of all those times I responded quickly, but never popped up on his exclusive super secret email radar weapon...
- twostorytower 7y agoI'm sure glad you're not my friend.
- Liron 7y ago> They end up in sketchy territory i.e. the pixels, forcing people to reveal how they use gmail in order to sign up, tracking every-single-aspect of how users are using their site, hyped up bullshit etc. You're passionately asserting a strong claim, but when you get to the "evidence" part of your comment, it seems you haven't added any supporting evidence beyond what's in the parent discussion.
- manigandham 7y agoIt's a tough business. What email app has ever had a real business model? The opportunity for acquisitions seems to have closed with Accompli being the last big one (bought by Microsoft to turn into Outlook on iOS). Also the founding team is from rapportive and rapleaf which are part of the shady data brokers that HN discusses often. It's best to assume good intentions first but there is precedent here.
- awwstn 7y agoThis anonymous comment is definitely not from a person with knowledge of the company. Here's some evidence to show that they're just making things up: 1. The comment says open tracking was added as a last ditch act of desperation...here's a 2017 article that talks about the feature: https://techcrunch.com/2017/08/18/rapportive-founders-new-startup-superhuman-is-what-gmail-would-be-if-built-today/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/08/18/rapportive-founders-new-st... 2. The comment says the high-touch onboarding was also added out of desperation. here's an old-ish tweet talking about it: https://twitter.com/josephcohen/status/1034189170003070976 https://twitter.com/josephcohen/status/1034189170003070976 3. The comment also claims that the company is floundering and desperate....they literally JUST closed a $33M round from A16Z...obviously they have a ways to go, but the claim that they are lost and helpless is simply absurd...here are pages upon pages of people begging for invites: https://twitter.com/search?f=tweets&vertical=default&q=superhuman%20invite&src=typd https://twitter.com/search?f=tweets&vertical=default&q=super... There's probably a healthy debate to be had about email tracking, but this comment is not contributing to that.
- dang 7y agoPeople often use throwaway accounts to post sensitive information to HN, but that mechanism is easily abused as well. Given the information in the replies you've received, as well as details of and about your comment, I'm leaning to the explanation that you've made this up. I don't know that, of course, but moderation is guesswork. Until we get substantiating information to the contrary, I'm guessing that this is fabricated and am going to moderate accordingly. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20337178 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20337178 and marked it off-topic.