3 ms·
I don't agree with the Cato article either, but this just sounds hopelessly naive: "There is an obvious and simple solution to [players with a special interest
by jessriedel 16y ago
I don't agree with the Cato article either, but this just sounds hopelessly naive:
"There is an obvious and simple solution to [players with a special interest to try to game the system] - transparency and openness in decision making."
Couldn't your argument be applied anytime someone objected to the unnecessary intrusion of government regulation? "Oh, we'll just have the government make decisions in an transparent and open way. Problem solved."
- andreyf 16y agoWhy is that so hard?
- ef4 16y agoBecause "the government" is an abstraction. In reality the decisions have to be made by specific people with specific interests and biases. People with regulatory decision-making power are, by definition, powerful. So they have the interests of powerful people, which are unlikely to match the interests of most of the rest of us.
- FluidDjango 16y agoMore importantly, government is an organization. The foremost motive for an organization (like any organiam) is self-preservation. Transparency is usually perceived as a vulnerability that might allow enemies to attack.
- jonhohle 16y agoAnd when enemies == constituents, it might be time to fold the whole thing up and start over.
- stretchwithme 16y agoBetter yet, let's have politics decide all economic questions. Then there'll be no gaming of anything.
- FluidDjango 16y agoIsn't there enough evidence that this is the status quo?
- stretchwithme 16y agosadly