3 ms·
I'm not sure why I'm making this association, but I feel that what's happening to Venice is systematic of larger, "flashy, saccharine surface" societal changes,
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
I'm not sure why I'm making this association, but I feel that what's happening to Venice is systematic of larger, "flashy, saccharine surface" societal changes, fed by the internet and social media.
Venice (and Barcelona, also mentioned in the article) is basically the perfect city for the Instagram age. You can come in, spend less than a couple hours there, and pretty much hit all the major "checkboxes" and photo sites: ride in a gondola, take some pictures in St. Mark's Square, etc. All the incredible history about how the city was actually built, it's role in the Middle Ages, etc. are easy to pass over.
This is pretty random, but it reminds me of this video, https://youtu.be/6abePkXncCM https://youtu.be/6abePkXncCM , by a well known youtube baker who is lamenting that high-quality baking content for recipes that actually work are getting killed by slickly produced videos that are literal eye and ear candy but are useless and aren't even feasible. It's as if we're all looking out for the shortest, quickest "dopamine bump".
It's just really sad to me.
- dmix 7y agoIt said the population peaked in 1500s, then again in the 1970s. This city was mostly a spectacle well before Instagram. If anything there are way more people no longer living in poverty and capable of being foreign-traveling tourists than ever before + population growth. They need to go somewhere so they hit up the same small group of great places that was there before the wealth and population growth.
- 40acres 7y agoIt's less about social media and more about China and India growing their middle class. More and more people now have the disposable income to travel, it's more than likely that they will flock to the most famous sites.
- Deukhoofd 7y agoThere's a graph in the article that show the population shrinking since 1950. I doubt social media has anything to do with it.
- asveikau 7y agoI don't think social media is the primary driver, because I had similar thoughts about travel 10 years ago. I would say a few things are factors for some of what is described: 1. It's relatively cheap and easy to travel. This wasn't as much the case in the past. 2. Population boom of millennials and onwards. I have a boomer mom and a pre-war dad who was born in Europe. They both see international travel as a Major Barrier with a lot of friction. I remember that seeming true in my childhood too. The younger cohorts have grown up with it being relatively cheap and easy. 3. The EU. Go to the touristy part of a touristy town in Europe, I guarantee you will hear the national language and native accent of every EU member state. I can't imagine it being like that several decades ago. It also drives tourism from outside Europe because they can enter in one country and cross over to another without hassle.
- toyg 7y agoIt's just the logical evolution of tourism as a business activity. Capitalist companies must grow, and tourism companies grow by delivering more and more tourists. That's why travelling gets cheaper: economies of scale (block-booking on planes, etc). That's why VISAs and barriers are removed: because there is yet another industry lobbying to remove friction. Tourism companies gotta grow like any other company out there. We just notice them more because their production line is literally on our streets.
- Theodores 7y agoVenice has had too many tourists for the last fifty years. And fifty years ago the tourists were pretty much as you describe, there for St Marks Square. The bigger change in recent times is the decline in industry. Globalisation makes a big difference. If you had a factory in Venice needing new plant and machinery, what would you do? You would sell up and move to Croatia or China. Tourism and an industry can be made to work, for instance London's West End has been the place for television post production for many decades. That is an industry that anchors a wider set of services and then on the periphery of that you get your tourist sites, e.g. Carnaby Street, Regent Street, Oxford Street. There is still this working core that is also served by different cafe's and bars to what the tourists go to, although there is some overlap. Underground trains and buses enable people to commute in and the core industry that is there cannot survive elsewhere. Try opening a post production edit suite in Leeds and see if any broadcasters come your way. Leeds is actually where Channel 4 are relocating to, but the gravitational pull of London's West End makes that difficult, something like 80% of the staff are leaving rather than moving up North. Venice is stuck in that the proper industry, e.g. the metal bashing stuff, just does not need to be there. It can't survive there and the transport links in for commuters are not what you get in most cities. The era of city states and mankind being mostly travelling by sea or river are not coming back. Venice can't monopolise silk, fancy things made of glass, lace or anything else that has to be made. They should have built some services fifty years ago to replace these specialisations with new specialisations. It is a tourist attraction now, that is not going to change. The people able to sell up and move should be lucky there is some AirBnB property tycoon willing to pay top dollar for their property.
- toyg 7y agoLet's not get dramatic. > 80% of [Channel4] staff are leaving rather than moving up North. 80% of staff are threatening to leave, they are not resigning en-masse. This is the same stuff that happened to the BBC a few years ago when they relocated a big chunk of activity to Manchester (or rather Salford, to be precise). Lots of people moaned, some people resigned, others started living on commuter trains, others just moved (and found out there are no White Walkers in the North after all), others were just hired here. Now the sector in Manchester is booming. It could well turn out that Channel 4 made a mistake in choosing Leeds (it's badly connected, much smaller than Manchester, and without a local tradition like the Granada legacy), but it has nothing to do with London being some sort of quintessential centre of all TV activity in the land.