4 ms·
This sounds like a terrible story with no winners. If it is true, it seems like a terrible case of student abuse, as well as fraud and corruption in the ISCA r
by musicale 7y ago
This sounds like a terrible story with no winners.
If it is true, it seems like a terrible case of student abuse, as well as fraud and corruption in the ISCA review process (ISCA presumably still being the ostensible top computer architecture conference), and another highly damning indictment of graduate education and universities ignoring the mental health and safety of their students.
I am also feeling less enthusiastic about the relentless drive to publish at top conferences or (sometimes literally) perish. Conference papers are often rushed to completion and full of mistakes or questionable results, and it's also hard to review them adequately given time constraints and minimal compensation or incentive for high-quality reviews. I think CS and EE may need to de-emphasize conferences and try to improve journals.
It is well-known that the review process (and not just for ISCA) is simply broken and seems to be no better than random, but I had no idea that corruption played a part in it.
- rusticpenn 7y agoThe academia is more about networking than original research. I was lucky that my prof. was focussed more on actual results and journals.
- Athas 7y ago> I think CS and EE may need to de-emphasize conferences and try to improve journals. I agree. Both because it may lead to a more reasonable working pace (we have the Internet for low-latency dissemination anyway), but also because the relentless long-distance travel is not environmentally sustainable.
- wsxcde 7y agoJournal reviews can be stacked with friends just as easily. In fact, most top CS/EE journals ask authors to recommend reviewers. (In theory, the editors will make sure the recommendations are conflict-free and sensible, but given their workloads, I wouldn't be surprised if at least some of them took the authors' suggestions at face value.)
- wsxcde 7y agoI think computer architecture is especially prone to this sort of nonsense. The whole field has a weird insider-bias and most program committee members seem to come from the same schools, have the same advisors, and write the same sort of papers. I find it kinda interesting that Moritz Lipp and Daniel Gruss have revolutionized our understanding of microarchitectural side channels and not a single one of their papers has appeared in ISCA/ASPLOS/MICRO. And yet, obviously flawed nonsense supposedly addressing side channels regularly manages to appear in these conferences.