4 ms·

HK used to flourish because it was the access point between China and the West. If they completely severed ties with China there is no value proposition anymore

by bllguo 7y ago

HK used to flourish because it was the access point between China and the West. If they completely severed ties with China there is no value proposition anymore... what "higher highs" are you anticipating, exactly?

filoleg 7y ago
>If they completely severed ties with China there is no value proposition anymore Becoming independent from China != completely severing ties with China. Also, I think these days a better served purpose of HK is as the access point to the whole Asian/SEA region, rather than the access point to China alone. Also, HK seems to be (from an outsider perspective) one of the most (if not the most) "westernized" cities in the region, with the proliferation of English language and all, so I can totally see it becoming the central hub in the Asian/SEA region for a lot of companies from the west.
- pishpash 7y ago
  What is it about post-colonial westerners that makes them not able to grok that the world, but especially Asia, no longer exists to serve westerners? Should there be a most "easternized" city in the heart of Europe that should have a prolific Mandarin speaker base?
  - deleted 7y ago
    [deleted]
  - dang 7y ago
    You've been repeatedly crossing into flamewar on these topics. We've asked you many times before not to do that, and even told you we'd ban you if you did it again. Would you please stop doing this on HN? It's abusive, no matter how wrong and ignorant others' comments are or you feel they are. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- bllguo 7y ago
  Hm. I guess I just don't see China allowing that kind of relationship with an independent HK. HK is also so incredibly close to China geographically, economically, and even culturally that it's hard to wrap my mind around the concept of HK independence. HK as an Asia/SEA hub is a reasonable point, but Singapore already serves that role and is much less reliant on China.

by bllguo 7y ago

filoleg 7y ago

>If they completely severed ties with China there is no value proposition anymore Becoming independent from China != completely severing ties with China. Also, I think these days a better served purpose of HK is as the access point to the whole Asian/SEA region, rather than the access point to China alone. Also, HK seems to be (from an outsider perspective) one of the most (if not the most) "westernized" cities in the region, with the proliferation of English language and all, so I can totally see it becoming the central hub in the Asian/SEA region for a lot of companies from the west.

pishpash 7y ago
What is it about post-colonial westerners that makes them not able to grok that the world, but especially Asia, no longer exists to serve westerners? Should there be a most "easternized" city in the heart of Europe that should have a prolific Mandarin speaker base?
- deleted 7y ago
  [deleted]
- dang 7y ago
  You've been repeatedly crossing into flamewar on these topics. We've asked you many times before not to do that, and even told you we'd ban you if you did it again. Would you please stop doing this on HN? It's abusive, no matter how wrong and ignorant others' comments are or you feel they are. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
bllguo 7y ago
Hm. I guess I just don't see China allowing that kind of relationship with an independent HK. HK is also so incredibly close to China geographically, economically, and even culturally that it's hard to wrap my mind around the concept of HK independence. HK as an Asia/SEA hub is a reasonable point, but Singapore already serves that role and is much less reliant on China.