4 ms·
I live by the following hierarchy: - Anything written down and transmitted digitally will be available to anyone who wants it eventually. Besides my copy, the
by jedberg 7y ago
I live by the following hierarchy:
- Anything written down and transmitted digitally will be available to anyone who wants it eventually. Besides my copy, the recipient has a copy, as do any number of intermediaries. Encrypted or not, that encryption will almost certainly be broken in my lifetime.
- Anything written down on physical medium or stored digitally (but not transmitted) will be freely available to anyone that wants it eventually. It's slightly more secure than a digital copy, because I have physical control over the only copy and would most likely know if that physical control was compromised (so my NAS is considered transmitted since it is possibly accessible).
- Anything I say to someone in person is pretty safe, depending on how much I trust them not to record what is said (otherwise it becomes classified as digitally transmitted). Of course now a copy remains in their mind's eye, which is in some cases worse since it can be modified and they don't even know it.
- Any thought I have that I have never expressed outside my body is almost completely safe, baring successful administration of truth serum (or until someone invents adversarial brain scans).
How does this affect me in real life? I don't write down things I wouldn't want other people to know, and I am pretty careful about saying things I don't want other people to know. I use encryption whenever I can because it will at least slow down the attackers, but I never assume something that is encrypted is safe.
- weinzierl 7y ago> - Anything written down [..] > - Anything I say to someone [..] In my hierarchy these two points are swapped. At least I think there is a real chance to keep written material secret as long as you are not a target of a state level adversary. I can write in a room where I am sure there are no cameras watching and I can put my copy in a safe where I would know if it was compromised. On the other hand I can almost never be sure not be audio recorded - be it deliberately or accidentally by any of the microphones that are almost everywhere nowadays.
- penagwin 7y agoI had a similar comment. We're increasingly surrounded by microphones/cameras, some of which are embedded in IOT or other appliances. Given the NSA's track record, the risk of devices getting hacked, etc. I've become rather conscious of potential implications they could have.
- jedberg 7y agoIt's true, those two may soon swap, as my trust in not being recorded goes down.
- penagwin 7y agoI have a very similar list to yours. I'm also a datahoarder though, so I also have the reverse characteristics, i.e. if I don't have a copy then assume there are no copies left for me to ever access (assume adversaries have a backup though). > - Anything written down and transmitted digitally will be available to anyone who wants it eventually. Besides my copy, the recipient has a copy, as do any number of intermediaries. Encrypted or not, that encryption will almost certainly be broken in my lifetime. I completely agree. So we're now assuming that the information will exist indefinitely for adversaries (NSA warehouse), however if I don't have a copy then it's effectively gone (for me only). > - Anything I say to someone in person is pretty safe, depending on how much I trust them not to record what is said. I'm not quite there yet, but I've become leary of all the phones, laptops, cameras, personal assistants, etc. While I'm from the US (so mass spying is supposed to be illegal), and most companies like Amazon/Apple have been shown to be "mostly telling the truth" in terms of how they only transmit data after a trigger phrase, it's a lot of microphones. Let's assume the person I'm talking to is 100% trusted, all it takes is a hacked Alexa to leak the conversation. Likely or practical? Not really. Do I do anything specific such that I'd consider myself a potential NSA target? Not really. But I consider privacy a human right so it's always something I'm thinking about.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ForHackernews 7y ago> or until someone invents adversarial brain scans These are coming sooner than many people will be comfortable with: https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=15744871 https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=157448...