6 ms·
I recently took a train from Seattle to Portland with my family. One difference compared to flying that it took me a while to realize was how amazingly quiet it
by munificent 7y ago
I recently took a train from Seattle to Portland with my family. One difference compared to flying that it took me a while to realize was how amazingly quiet it is.
On a plane, the engines are right there out on the wing screaming and conducting that sound directly into the airframe next to you. With a train, the engine is way up front, hundreds of yards a way, separated by several linkages.
The end result is that a train car is as quiet as a coffee shop. I love it.
- legitster 7y agoLove that route. Also, on a train the ride is so much smoother - no starts or stop or dealing with traffic. The pricing is nuts, though. A one way train ticket for that route is $36. The same trip via car takes about the same amount of time and $20 in gas. The train is a nice luxury for one person, but for the whole family it becomes very expensive. Passenger rail in the US is absurd.
- rebuilder 7y agoUnfortunately, compared to Finland at least, that pricing seems pretty normal, maybe even on the cheap side. (It's apparently a roughly 5.5 h drive?) Long-distance rail travel seems to be fairly expensive. Is that kind of trip cheaper somewhere comparable?
- erikpukinskis 7y agoThe thing in the US is that almost everyone already owns a car (so that’s considered sunk cost) and the cost of fuel is heavily subsidized. So that’s the comparison I guess. It’s not fair, but it’s also sort of reasonable, given car ownership here.
- moneytalks 7y agoFuel in the US is subsidized? I thought it was heavily taxed (not compared to European countries but compared to other consumer goods).
- erikpukinskis 7y agoThere’s very little federal tax, its mostly state tax (which varies). I add the cost of “development” financing/spying/regime change as part of the cost of oil, and the U.S. pays for all of that, which is a de facto subsidy.
- Reason077 7y agoThe US spends more subsidizing fossil fuels than on defense, according to a report from the International Monetary Fund: https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/fossil-fuel-subsidies-pentagon-spending-imf-report-833035/ https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/fossil-f...
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoThe "subsidy" is not straight-up tax dollars being given to Exxon & co, but computed against "prices fully reflected supply costs plus the taxes needed to reflect environmental costs and other damage, including premature deaths from air pollution".
- Reason077 7y agoThe total includes direct subsidies, such as tax incentives that reward fossil fuel investment, exploration, and extraction in addition to indirect ones you describe. In the US, like many countries, these are very substantial: https://www.investopedia.com/articles/07/oil-tax-break.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/07/oil-tax-break.asp
- mehrzad 7y agoIt's this pricing model that makes west coast passenger rail so uncommon, none of my friends had heard of it until I looked it up (I live in LA).
- ghaff 7y agoI guess I wouldn’t have thought that expensive for intercity travel. Certainly doesn’t strike me as such relative to shorter haul European trains I’ve taken. And in the US, I’m a decent fraction of that ($13) just to take the commuter rail into the city one way.
- jermaustin1 7y agoSame here, I've taken the London to Edinburgh on LNER and Virgin East Coast multiple times and it runs about £40 each way. And my 30 mile train into Manhattan is $14 $36 one way for a 5 hour train seems pretty cheap.
- vkou 7y agoThe problem is that the train has to compete with 3 hours by car... And then the ability to actually use a car at your destination. The transit systems in either Seattle, or Portland, are nowhere near as good as they are in New York.
- sologoub 7y agoIf you factor in wear and tear, parking, etc. It’s probably still cheap. You can also rent a car when you get there for something like the same amount for the day and not worry about the wear and tear part.
- vkou 7y agoMuch of my car's wear and tear is from age, so I can discount some amount of that that. Free parking is plentiful in 95% of both cities. Driving 1 person is already close to the price of a train ticket. Driving 2 people is ~50% discounted. Driving 2 people, and then not having to rent a car/taxi, is something like a ~75% discount. With a real carbon tax, these numbers would look a lot closer to eachother.
- reddog 7y ago
- ceejayoz 7y ago> A one way train ticket for that route is $36. The same trip via car takes about the same amount of time and $20 in gas. Don't forget wear and tear on the car, though. The IRS sets mileage at 58 cents/mile. That's $100 for Seattle to Portland.
- legitster 7y agoThat's fair. I do my own maintenance and drive cheap cars. YMMV. Still, even at the full rate, two people back and forth, it's still cheaper to drive.
- ghaff 7y agoWhich is pretty normal most places in the US and at least Western Europe unless maybe parking is especially expensive at the destination. Even so, if two of us go from the Boston area to NYC it’s almost certainly cheaper to drive although I almost always take the train because it’s a lot more pleasant. With a family the train would be a relatively expensive alternative.
- bluGill 7y agoMost of the costs of a car are fixed once you own it. Wear and tears per mile is actually small. Insurance is the same for a car driven 7000 miles a year as one driven 30,000. there is a small discount for less than 7000 miles/year, but it is still fixed. Likewise the car payment doesn't change at all. The IRS has to come up with a fair number that translates all those fixed costs into per/mile. It is a good financial number, but worthless for this discussion.
- novok 7y agoBut then I don’t have to focus on driving for several hours and can do my own thing.
- gingabriska 7y agoIn India you can go north to south and east to west for that much money in AC train.
- puranjay 7y agoYeah but you better hope your constipation kicks in because I'm never going to a bathroom on any Indian train
- donarb 7y agoAmtrak offers 25% off fares on Cascades if you book more than 14 days in advance. Children are also discounted at 50%, infants are free.
- banku_brougham 7y agoi’ll pay that cost, not to drive.
- echelon 7y agoNo, this is awesome. All of that time is yours without having to worry about the road. I wish we'd install more rail corridors. Especially outfitted with business and luxury amenities. I'd travel by train everywhere I could to avoid planes and long distance driving.
- wallace_f 7y agoHe's saying trains are awesome, but the implementation in America is insane.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DocTomoe 7y agoDistance Seattle Portland is about 280 km. That's similar to the Distance of Munich to Würzburg in Germany. The Deutsche Bahn takes 75 Euros, about 85 USD from you in economy class. The problem with the US is not that rail travel is expensive (it is not), but that gas is waaaaayyyyy too cheap. (In Germany you pay around 6.20 USD/gallon)
- llamathrowaway 7y agoOn a train the motors may also be right under your feet: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_unit https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_unit And it’s still not annoying, at all. It’s very quiet, and I personally find the sound of electric motors much more tolerable than anything involving combustion.
- nathankunicki 7y agoWorth noting that trains with a locomotive up front are quite rare these days (although most common in the US - Amtrak Acela notwithstanding). Most of the rest of the world has gone down the "multiple unit" route, where there are smaller motors in each car, under your feet, and there are no dedicated locomotives. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_unit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_unit
- ant6n 7y agoFor long distances and even regional trains there still exist plenty of locomotives. And BTW, even many high speed trains, including tgv duplex and the acela u nention are effectively locomotive hauled trains.
- princekolt 7y agoYes but the TGV is all based on 70s technology. The more modern trains (such as Siemens Velaro, Alstom AGV, Bomardier ETR 1000) are all multiple-units. One notable exception is the Bombardier/Talgo 350 (known in Spain as "the Duck" for obvious reasons).
- ant6n 7y agoThe TGV Duplex was developed in the 90s, and continues to be developed, the new version (avelia horizon) coming out in a couple of years. There's a reason it uses a locomotive ("powercar") concept, it relates to it being a double-decker (which all the other trains you mentioned aren't. I believe the Acela replacement (avelia liberty) uses powercars as well.
- Theodores 7y agoThe UK sleeper trains were refurbished recently. They go out of London up to Scotland and down to the South West of England. They are not multiple units or likely to be if they were refurbished tomorrow. The reason being that the stock is not in 24/7 use. It does the one long night journey then gets parked all day. The train out of London gets split to serve different bits of Scotland, so you do get some shunting around going on when they do things to the train. It doesn't go that quickly as a train because there is no need. Being in Euston at 5 a.m. is no fun, might as well be there at 6 a.m. with some sleep had. So the loco that pulls the train can be any old freight thing. Although now it is likely to be a Class 73 diesel electric that can use electrified track as well as diesel. Note that there i no electric track all the way out to Scotland.