4 ms·
That another country is also evil doesn't make what Japan is doing any better. They both need to stop. There is increasing evidence that whales have a huge ro
by sandworm101 7y ago
That another country is also evil doesn't make what Japan is doing any better. They both need to stop.
There is increasing evidence that whales have a huge role in climate change. Their poop feeds plankton which in turn absorbs carbon. And their physical bodies when they die sink, moving significant amounts of carbon to the bottom where is stays in that ecosystem far away from the atmosphere.
If the Japanese and Norwegians don't care about killing such magnificent animals for food, perhaps they can be taught to value them as ecological partners in the fight against climate change.
- pathseeker 7y ago> That another country is also evil doesn't make what Japan is doing any better. They both need to stop. While true, it looks bad for people who are on the fence and/or are ambivalent. If the people expressing the outrage aren't outraged about the whaling in the Faroe islands, it looks like they don't really care about stopping whaling but instead just want to protest for the sake of it (or they're racists against the Japanese, etc).
- sandworm101 7y agoIt is true that I am probably not angry enough about the Faroe whale slaughter, but they are much further away from me than Japan. I live on Canada's west coast, where Greenpeace began. There are far more flights between Vancouver and Tokyo than Vancouver and the Faroe Islands, and many more business and government connections. So it should be no surprise that I am more angry at Japan. I am also no fan of the Canadian arctic whale harvest. That it is classified as "aboriginal whaling", and is much smaller, makes no difference to me. Dead whales are dead whales regardless who is killing them.
- mtnGoat 7y agoI believe there are still occasional whale hunts in the strait of juan de fuca, by the Makah Trube from Neah Bay.
- sithadmin 7y agoThat other countries exceed Japan in whale killing certainly doesn't absolve Japan of any moral responsibility. But that the other (white, European) nations receive so little public shaming or backlash for their whale killing relative to Japan seems to suggest there is some sort of pervasive bias influencing media coverage.
- YUMad 7y agoSo just kill the whales and let them sink to help the climate then?
- JadeNB 7y ago> That another country is also evil doesn't make what Japan is doing any better. For ease of reference, the non-Latinate name for this flavour of the tu quoque fallacy seems to be 'whataboutism' (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism).
- JadeNB 7y agoI don't mean to complain about downvoting, but, in case the downvotes are based on misinterpretation rather than disagreement: I was not accusing sandworm101 (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20327379 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20327379) of engaging in a fallacy; rather, I meant to point out that the argument sandworm101 was correctly rebutting corresponded to a named fallacy.