5 ms·
Hot Startups Lack Female Employees (even as applicants)
- jdp23 16y ago"I just scanned through all the applicants we have received for advertised 'making' positions. To date, we have yet to receive a single female applicant" When I see statements like this, I wonder what they've been doing to reach out to women. Usually the answer is "nothing" or "well, we asked our friends" ... in other words, they're not investing any significant effort. EDIT: downvoted. I know you're shocked.
- thedz 16y agoWhat kind of outreach do you expect a new startup to do? They don't exactly have an excess of free time or resources to invest significant effort. And perhaps more fundamentally, are the job descriptions looking for applicants biased towards males in such a way that it warrants an explicit female-oriented recruiting outreach?
- jdp23 16y agoThere's a bunch of suggestions on the Geek Feminism Wiki at http://geekfeminism.wikia.com/wiki/Hiring_discrimination#Solutions http://geekfeminism.wikia.com/wiki/Hiring_discrimination#Sol... Yes, most job descriptions give the appearance of being biased towards males. The best thing to do is get feedback on it from a couple of women with the skills you're trhing to attract and a diversity/recruiting expert. We did that at my previous startup and it made a huge difference. If a company sees diversity as important, it doesn't really take that much time or money to reach out.
- btipling 16y ago'If a company sees diversity as important' Maybe they seek success as important. How does a focus on diversity help a company succeed?
- Mz 16y agoI work for a large company. They think it's important. The framing is along the lines of "How can we sell to everyone if we don't hire everyone?" If you are dominated by white males, you may be making wording choices and other decisions which subtly exclude women, blacks, hispanics, etc and you probably have no idea you are doing it. (Subtle does not necessarily mean the effect is small either.)
- jdp23 16y agoExactly. Also, diverse teams outperform -- Scott Page's book The Difference presents the underlying cognitive diversity model for why, and there's been some great recent empirical work as well. Conversely a lot of white guys don't believe that diversity leads to success -- and many of them talk primarily to other white guys who reinforce their views (or to women and people of color who agree with them). So, companies they run wind up with mostly male and mostly white development teams, building products optimized for white guys. It's a crowded market space ...
- Mz 16y agoAnecdotally, my recollection is that the most successful organized crime group ever was successful in part because they would work with anyone, so long as they had the necessary skills. Prior to that, the Irish stuck with the Irish, the Italians stuck with the Italians, etc. Inclusiveness of people = not excluding skills/talent based on some arbitrary, irrelevant detail (like skin color, gender, etc).
- johngalt 16y agoOk so men looking for work have to network, send 100s of resumes out, research, and train. Women looking for work should blame companies for not "reaching out" to them. Sounds equal.
- p01nd3xt3r 16y agoI am really sick of these articles; why cant we just focus on talent. Put the best people in the best positions. It should not matter if they are male, female black or white.
- chrisbroadfoot 16y agoBecause diversity is important and hugely valuable. You shouldn't have to compromise on talent in order to achieve diversity. Why aren't there more talented female developers? And if they're out there, why aren't they applying for these jobs?
- hugh3 16y agoIs that proven? Is it intuitively clear? What makes us think that a mixed team of programmers is better than a homogeneous one? Maybe it is in some cases, and isn't in others.
- SpikeGronim 16y agoSeveral studies have reproduced a correlation between diversity and organizational success. I don't know of such a study for programmers specifically. I also haven't seen proof of causality - do better organizations have diverse hiring practices, or vice versa? But I've never seen a study that said that lack of diversity was a good thing. So far the evidence weighs towards diversity being better for your organization, though I wouldn't call it "proven".
- makmanalp 16y agoI think if you're making a claim like this, you should point people to the studies.
- SpikeGronim 16y agoYou're right and I would prefer to link. It comes up in The Economist from time to time. I can't find the links right now.
- jerf 16y agoAt some point, "accommodating women" turns into "telling women what they want". If they aren't even applying, isn't this at the very least perilously close to the latter? Regardless of what you are going for, you have to at least show up. Consider what is really being asked for here; startups are now "supposed" to go seek women out who aren't even indicating they are searching for a job and hire them? That's not a sensible demand; translated into real action that borders on harassment.
- chrisbroadfoot 16y agoIn some circles, this is considered headhunting :)
- Dylanlacey 16y agoIs headhunting someone based on their gender (or race, or religion) really something companies should be pursuing, rather then simply looking for merit?
- spitfire 16y agoSometimes gender is merit. I wouldn't buy an issue of playboy if it had a dude on the cover.
- jdp23 16y agoBecause there are fewer women then men in the technology space, they're a scarce resource. Startups who want diverse teams need to compete for them. Also, parts of the YC universe have a bit of a reputation for being uncomfortable with women. Reaching out sends a clear signal that you're not like that -- you're the kind of company that wants women to work there enough that you're willing to take the initiative.
- thedz 16y agoYou're asking for startups to compete for a scarce resource (women) in an already scarce subset of engineers (good ones). That's a pretty tall order for startups. And an almost impossible one if you expect them to take time out of (likely) much more pressing matters to expressly reach out (in some as yet undefined "woman-friendly" way) to females just to that they'll apply. Not hire females. Just to get them to apply.
- nostrademons 16y agoI wonder how much of this is because of the company and how much is because of the company's stage in its lifecycle. Google today is known as a pretty female-friendly employer, at least among tech companies. The gender balance in the cafes seems about 60/40 male, and engineering is about 10% female (which sounds terrible but is actually better than many undergrad CS departments). Several top executives are women. But Google's first female hire was Marissa, who was something like employee #20. Which means that when Google was the size of FourSquare or Tumblr or Kickstarter, it was even more male-dominated than they are. It could just be that women have no desire to pad their egos by working at a successful startup. If you don't care about the cash and cachet of that, there's no reason to put yourself through the risk and uncertainty of it.
- jth213 16y agoPlease explain what "female-friendly" means. I run a technical user group that was approached recently by an organization for women in the same technology area. We were encouraged by this group to make our meetings more "female-friendly". I asked what they meant by this and they couldn't provide me with a coherent answer. What are we in tech doing that is so female-UNfriendly?
- reso 16y agoMM was actually Google's first female engineer, not their first female hire.
- aamar 16y agoNo, Lori Park holds that distinction.
- guelo 16y agoI don't know why we should focus on startups when this is a much more global issue. If you look at your typical college's CS, Engineering, or Math departments you'll find similar ratios of females as you find in the tech workforce. I have no idea why that is but it's not caused by who startups are hiring. If you look at a typical college's marketing department you'll see a lot more women, how is it surprising that there are more women in marketing positions?
- chrisbroadfoot 16y agoAgreed. I think the issue is exacerbated in startups because they inherently have fewer employees.
- Alex3917 16y agoSo I run a conference, Swagapalooza, which involves companies launching new consumer products to bloggers. The products are mostly food, fashion, tech, books, music, clothes, parenting stuff, etc. While I do get a decent number of applications from women who want to present their products, most of them are for Etsy-like stuff, which generally doesn't work as we are only looking for products that we have the potential to help tip. The percentage of women-run consumer product companies whose products are interesting[1] and mass produceable are probably just as low as the percentage of women-run tech companies. [1] Genuinely novel. Not just a company that silkscreens t-shirts with their own designs.
- chailatte 16y agoBecause most women are not good at programming. Because their brain lacks the wiring [1]. Otherwise they would've already jumped at a chance to secure $150k/year jobs. Stop writing superficial articles that don't address the fundamentals. [1] http://scienceblogs.com/cognitivedaily/2007/09/why_arent_more_women_in_scienc.php http://scienceblogs.com/cognitivedaily/2007/09/why_arent_mor... "Mental rotation tasks (see this CogDaily post), which require working with a three-dimensional representation of an object, have been found to have very large sex differences favoring males"
- btipling 16y agoYeah ok please show me a YC startup (still in startup mode) playing $150K for any position. There's a lot of risk in working at a startup, I think that plays a factor too although I have no data to back this up, just a vague recollection of college courses and reading.
- palish 16y agoI recently saw that a "Walgreens Pharmacist" is typically paid around ~$120k/yr. If I set my mind to it, I am fairly certain I could become a Walgreens Pharmacist. However I have no interest whatsoever in that. So regardless of the pay, I would not pursue it. Do you see the problem here? This issue is deeper than you give it credit for. For example, if women are different in some fundamental way, what is the difference? It seems just as likely that it results in them not being interested rather than lacking ability.
- chailatte 16y ago"So regardless of the pay, I would not pursue it." The current unemployment rate for college grad worldwide is ~30%. So you're not the norm.
- palish 16y agoThis is true. That's another interesting question I think about sometimes... What would I do, if programming did not exist? Architecture, maybe...
- shawnee_ 16y agoThere are a lot of things working against us. In my experience, it basically boils down to not being given a chance.
- ig1 16y agoI don't know the figures for the US, but in the UK roughly 10% of developers are female. So it's not surprising that a startup with 9 developers might have no female developers. There might be an issue due to hiring methods (i.e. recruiting through venues that are male dominated, adverts being tailored to males, etc.), but the overwhelming reason is likely to be the lack of female devs across the industry.
- rue 16y agoWhat about the more tepid startups?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- vietor 16y agoIt's important to highlight and actively try to fix this because it's a bootstrapping problem. Tech is male dominated, so it is a less comfortable work environment for many women, so few women go into tech, so tech is male dominated. (There are of course many other factors in play, but this is one which can be nicely isolated and is important on it's own) The principal problem with objections centered about "but why can't we just focus on talent" is that they are short sighted greedy optimizations which are actively trapping the tech industry in a local talent maximum.
- tjarratt 16y agoI've often heard companies saying they would love to hire more women, but they lack the applicants. Can anyone that handles hiring for a company speak out on even the perceived ratio of applicants? For what it's worth, I recently recommended my old boss at an unnamed large company in Silicon Valley hire a female colleague for a technical position I used to hold. If they won't apply, recommending a job to a woman you know is the next best step.
- auxbuss 16y agoWhen I started out, about 30 years ago, the male/female ratio in IT was about 60:40. But I presume that men were also a larger percentage of the total workforce at that time, at least in "professional" roles. The first time I really noticed the change was at Sun around 1998/99 when my group, containing about 100 engineers, only had two women in it.
- auxbuss 16y agoBad form to reply to myself, but I just went and read the Tracy Chou post mentioned elsewhere here http://www.quora.com/Tracy-Chou/Women-in-Software-Engineering-Part-I http://www.quora.com/Tracy-Chou/Women-in-Software-Engineerin... I have to say that I recognise everything she says. For the record, I am male. On reflection, the IT world has become a place where a huge amount of male posturing and faux competitiveness goes on. It wears me down. I know a lot of guys behave this way, but the IT world is best powered by cooperation and collaboration, not by a lot of willy waving. It's interesting that she mentions her mum being in IT 25 years ago and gave it up 10 years ago, as I know a lot of women who did just that. A lot.
- Mz 16y agoA lot of the comments here seem to focus on sexual harassment as The Issue. I wonder, though, about the issue of how close-knit and intimate start-up culture tends to be. There was a (flagged, dead) thread not terribly long ago where some married man had gotten his female co-founder pregnant and was looking for suggestions on how best to handle this big mess. Long hours, late nights and possibly no one else around in a close-knit, small social unit (aka a startup) is probably also a concern for some women, even if the men are all perfect gentlemen. They might not fess up to this angle but I think any concerns about this which one might normally have for work generally would be magnified by the type of intimate environment of a startup. An affair at work can lead to being fired (and sometimes other ugliness). So if someone has a brain and considers this to be a potential issue, it seems to me the wisest thing to do is not go there to begin with.
- sn 16y agoSo the wife wasn't the co-founder?
- Mz 16y agoApparently not.
- jdp23 16y agoIt's a great point. Women often have a lot more to lose in situations like this so may be extra wary. And the long hours late nights can be much more of an issue for single moms or moms in families where both parents are working. So it's challenging all around.