3 ms·
> How big is your hard drive? 512 GB > How about on your phone? 256 GB > I guess there's also the problem of how to let a new joiner view previous messages.
by vbezhenar 7y ago
> How big is your hard drive?
512 GB
> How about on your phone?
256 GB
> I guess there's also the problem of how to let a new joiner view previous messages. Can that be done with e2e encryption?
Of course. Share the key with a new joiner. Probably should be an option for admin, whether he wants to share (share the key) or does not want to share (generate new key and use it since that moment, old clients still remember old keys and can decrypt things).
- madeofpalk 7y agoA single, shared key? Granted, I don't know much about encryption, end-to-end messaging, or otherwise, but it seems like a Very Hard Problem to solve for something like Slack.
- vbezhenar 7y ago> A single, shared key? Yes, shared among participants. > it seems like a Very Hard Problem to solve for something like Slack. There are plenty of messengers with E2E encryption and group chats with working search. Sure, it's not a straightforward task and server-side handling of search and other functions makes everything much easier, but I don't think that it's impossible task. Though I'm not sure if demand is big enough. I would think that just self-hosting slack would be preferable for many organizations.
- madeofpalk 7y ago> Yes, shared among participants. Honest question - how does this work across thousands of employees, some of which are almost guaranteed to be bad-actors at one point? Or is that just not a problem that's trying to be solved? What are the impacts if someone leaks that? > There are plenty of messengers with E2E encryption and group chats with working search. I don't know - are they on the (user) scale of Slack? How many people can you add to a group in WhatsApp or iMessage? (I honestly don't know, but I would suspect Slack lets you have more people in a 'group' than them). Again, I have only a very cursory knowledge of how iMessage does E2E encryption. Obviously Slack would need to choose a different approach, but I wouldn't look at other messaging apps for examples.