3 ms·
Since when is not encrypting what could be sensitive communication ""isn't a problem here"?
by duxup 7y ago
Since when is not encrypting what could be sensitive communication ""isn't a problem here"?
- sanderjd 7y agoSo, I think this is a problem and that encryption and data security policies and audits would be a good thing. But your parent's point also resonated with me. This isn't a shocking expose of some giant new problem. Protecting proprietary communication has been a problem for as long as organizations have existed. It was a problem when the solution at Los Alamos was safes in offices, it was a problem with memos, it was a problem with faxes, then emails, and now, yes, Slack chats. It's a problem, people should work on it, but it's not news.
- duxup 7y agoWhat qualifies as news? Does it have to be " a shocking expose"? All the things you mentioned about communication seem to apply to this article.
- sanderjd 7y agoI mean, this is a good philosophical question, and I think the answer tends to just be "whatever a news organization decides to write about", so clearly this counts. But I think what makes for interesting news are things that are new and non-obvious. The point of the thread starter (which resonated with me) is that this is neither. What rubs me wrong about the article is that it lacks context. From just this article, this sounds like a novel threat. But it's ludicrously far from that. You could write the same article about every communication system used by every business ever. For instance, tons of important stuff is still required to be done by fax, which is far less privacy-preserving than Slack. Email remains pretty much universally unencrypted. The article doesn't try to grapple with this context at all, which makes it read oddly to me.
- ltbarcly3 7y agoEdit: I should have pointed out that the article doesn't say they don't encrypt the data, it just says they don't end-to-end encrypt it, which by definition would require it to be impossible for Slack or anyone else to read the messages (other than the users who sent them or were in the channel at the time they were sent). Only a handful or recent apps like Signal and Telegram even attempt to do this. Any form of communication (or really any form of information storage) could be sensitive, that's my point exactly. There's literally no reason to mention Slack other than it's hot and the author could glom onto a trendy brand name to get people to read an article that is basically devoid of any novel content. If a new sport which merges football, basketball, and chess become popular, we would see a bunch of articles 'People Who Play Chessketball are Getting Injured'. 'Chessketball has an Injury Problem'. 'Things you Need to Know before you Let Your Children Play Chessketball' Yes, people are more likely to be injured whenever they participate in any physical activity. Also when they ride a bike or go for a jog. Also, it turns out, if they don't do any physical activity at all they will suffer from heart disease.
- duxup 7y agoI think the fact that Slack communication isn't encrypted is a valid news article. I don't think that because the topic is "hot" that makes talking about it "no reason other than". I feel like there is a surprising volume of "oh man why did the author bring this up" type posts on HN, I don't get it. The topic seems valid.
- codesushi42 7y agoExactly, there is no good reason why Slack doesn't at least provide the option to end to end encrypt conversations. I hope that stories like this continue so that e2e encryption is supported by any messaging platform that wants to be taken seriously.