6 ms·
You're not taxed on sales, you're taxed on profits and according to the opening paragraph of this article Apple’s pre-tax profits totalled up to £33.7m for whic
by taylodl 7y ago
You're not taxed on sales, you're taxed on profits and according to the opening paragraph of this article Apple’s pre-tax profits totalled up to £33.7m for which Apple paid £3.8m in tax - which is over 10%.
Now the article does mention Apple paid a £13m dividend to its parent in Ireland, which presumably is the money Apple is sheltering from taxes but even then that would only be roughly £1.3m in additional taxes, which admittedly would be a roughly 30% increase but still seems like a small issue.
Am I missing something here?
- reallydontask 7y agoDo you think that a profit margin for Apple of 0.0275% is reasonable? Nobody questions the right amount of tax is being paid on the declared profits. People question that the declared profits are actually the actual profits that the Apple operation generates in the UK without any sort of financial shenanigans, e.g. transfer pricing, etc ...
- qaq 7y agoYou do realize it works this way for all goods and the only reason people single out Apple is because they have lots of $.
- b_tterc_p 7y agoAnd thus Apple is a good public target for this common problem because laypeople can better understand their financials than, say, Kraft foods.
- ebg13 7y agoI believe that that is what we call "low hanging fruit" or "bang per buck". Is there more to your position?
- qaq 7y agoThere is no position thats how world economy works Google is shifting profits to it's home office and HSBC is doing same thing. You start taxing Google on UK revenue US will start taxing UK companies on their US revenue.
- reallydontask 7y agoI'm pretty sure that Starbucks, Google, Microsoft, Amazon and, I might be mistaken here, Facebook, have all been pulled up on this type of financial engineering in the UK before. If you want to believe that these companies genuinely generate these kind of profit levels for their UK operations that's up to you, but I don't think that belief is based on evidence.
- qaq 7y agoAll companies shift profits to home office do you think Land Rover USA is showing profits? Or UK banks in other countries show huge local profits?
- ptah 7y agosmall companies simply cannot pull the kinds of tricks the big corporates that have dedicated staff at HMRC can. EDIT: the big ones are not being singled out, they are the only ones doing this shady stuff
- raverbashing 7y agoWhere are you getting this % from?
- pjc50 7y agoApple's "gross margin" is 38%, so there's definitely a gap somewhere. https://finbox.com/AAPL/explorer/gross_profit_margin https://finbox.com/AAPL/explorer/gross_profit_margin
- Lazare 7y agoThere is a law in the UK that defines exactly how transfer pricing works, in order to prevent abuses. Is your argument that Apple is breaking this law, or that the UK law is simply poorly drafted? If the latter, have you contacted your MP? I understand your concern about their profit margin, what I'm curious about is why you think any answers lie with Apple and not some branch of the UK government.
- reallydontask 7y agoAs it happens, I have written to my (labour) MP, hard to see anything coming out of it since they've not been in power since 2010? To be fair, my position varies between blaming the companies for the financial shenanigans and blaming the politicians for the messy tax code, not that I said anything about this in my previous post.
- chimprich 7y ago> I'm curious about is why you think any answers lie with Apple and not some branch of the UK government. It appears that it's very tough for governments to stay ahead of the tax shenanigans of enormous multinational corporations with immense resources at their disposal. The UK tax laws could certainly do with improvement, but in my opinion this is deeply unethical behaviour by Apple, even if it's difficult to establish whether it's actually illegal.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThe problem isn't that the law is poorly drafted, it's that the underlying premise is flawed. For example, suppose the UK operation needs money to buy inventory. One possibility is to sell its own shares. Then it has "free" money, zero borrowing cost, so it makes profits. Another possibility is to go to a lender and borrow the money at interest. Then the interest payments eat its profits. That difference in treatment is intended. The idea behind the distinction is that loan interest doesn't depend on the success of the business. If the business does poorly the investors make less profit but a lender isn't owed less interest. If the business does well the investors make more profit but a lender isn't owed more interest. That's the difference between profit and interest. But in this context the retail operation has highly predictable costs and revenues, and it's easy to adjust things in real time as sales volume increases or decreases. It's not like R&D where you have to spend for five years before you start making potential returns. So it's easy to borrow exactly the amount of money you need at market interest rates in an arms length transaction, and have the interest eat up your profits. And none of that is "wrong" -- profits come from investment. If nobody made any initial investment into the UK operation and it had to borrow all of its operating capital, it's completely expected in an efficient market that the borrowing costs would eat all its profits. The expected return (profit) on investing no money is no money. The problem isn't transfer pricing. The amount they're paying can be the amount you would pay in an arms length transaction and still have it eat all their profits. A retail operation that has taken no investment will legitimately have minimal profits.
- taylodl 7y agoBut this is Apple's retail operations, not Apple Corp the maker of iGadgets. And the profit margin is 0.275%. Is that reasonable? IDK, but I imagine Apple Retail is paying near list price to Apple Corp along with the overheads of staffing and rent (which includes taxes). In light of that this may not be all that unreasonable. That's why I'm asking if I'm missing something.
- jahewson 7y ago> And the profit margin is 0.275%. Is that reasonable? No, that’s madness.
- taylodl 7y agoDepends on the goal of Apple Retail. I don't think their primary objective is to make money. I think they should rather be viewed as more of the marketing arm of Apple Corp. They don't appear to skimp on their operations so I can see their margins being incredibly thin to the point of non-existent.
- amazingman 7y agoThis is a fantastic point, and will almost certainly be lost in the moralistic uproar. If Apple Retail’s margins were super high, it would indicate that Apple Retail is getting a wildly, probably illegally unfair deal compared to its other retailers (e.g. Target, Best Buy).
- monocasa 7y ago> Now the article does mention Apple paid a £13m dividend to its parent in Ireland, which presumably is the money Apple is sheltering from taxes Lol, no. Most of what they're sheltering takes the form of IP license fees. That's in the hundreds of millions.
- zzleeper 7y agoYou just pay it as transfer pricing. Eg an expense of $100m for "brand licencing fees". You give me the trademark to the subsidiary in the less taxed place, and done.
- pjc50 7y agoThe accounts include an £884mn figure for "cost of sales" which is subtracted from the revenue. Now, how much does Apple Ireland charge Apple UK for iPhones? How about marketing? License fees for use of the Apple logo?
- eptcyka 7y agoWhat about VAT?
- youngtaff 7y agoEffectively companies don't pay VAT, they just collect it on behalf of HMRC
- hartator 7y agoVAT is technically paid by companies. They will love to sell their products for 20% less.
- urbanjunkie 7y agowhich they literally do to any VAT registered company.
- Kurtz79 7y agoBut it is effectively paid by consumers... as you say companies already compensate for VAT in the price.
- benaadams 7y agoCompanies don't pay VAT on their purchases; the consumer pays the VAT. Would they sell their products for 20% less; or would they decide consumers were happy to pay at that price so keep the price the same and keep the extra as profits?
- youngtaff 7y agoVAT is not paid by companies! I run a VAT registered business… I discount all the VAT I pay my suppliers against the VAT I charge my customers, and send the balance to HMRC Every VAT registered company does the same - non VAT registered businesses and individuals pay VAT
- hartator 7y agoYou pay VAT between the difference VAT incomes and VAT expenses. Exactly like tax on profits. It’s just at another accounting level. The distinction is arbitrary.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoIt presumably transfers money to the parent in ways other than dividends, e.g. paying for licenses or inventory. The problem is the same as it has always been -- profit is easy to move around, so it ends up in the jurisdiction with the lowest taxes. Then people get upset that they have billions in sales and are paying minimal taxes, but whose fault is that really? Nobody is preventing you from collecting tax on sales. If you instead only collect tax on profits, and the entity which is actually in your jurisdiction has minimal profits, blame yourself for choosing that tax structure, not the company for responding to it. It's simple enough for a legislature to replace corporate income tax with VAT if they really want to tax based on sales. And if they don't then what are they complaining about? Would the UK really be in a different position if the US had a lower corporate tax rate and Apple reported its profits there instead?
- loxs 7y agoAll tax is ultimately paid by the end user. Do you prefer to have 20% more expensive iPhones, that is the actual question.
- kevcampb 7y agoIf I am another company competing against Apple and paying my share of taxes, then yes.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoMore to the point, if you fold corporate income tax into VAT then maybe you pay more for iPhones, but then you pay less for all domestic products (assuming the total tax revenue remains the same), and so the primary consequence is only removing the relative disadvantage for domestic companies.
- nagisa 7y agoIf it means a sensible social services – yes.
- 7y ago
- wlll 7y agoDoes anyone really believe that Apple only made £33.7m profit? I don't, it's far more likely that they shunt money to other companies in tax light areas like most large companies have been doing for the last many many years.
- mcphage 7y ago> Does anyone really believe that Apple only made £33.7m profit? Apple as a whole? Definitely not. Apple as in the UK division? I don't even know. Which is to say: also definitely not, but I don't even know if "profit" for a division of a company like that is a well-defined term. Profit is money received - money spent, but they don't make the phones in the UK, they don't design the phones in the UK, so how much should they have made?
- grey-area 7y agoAm I missing something here? Yes, stated profits are highly malleable. The figures can be adjusted so that the company runs at a slight profit or slightly loss quite easily, by adjusting how certain things are accounted for, and how much profit is reinvested, distributed to staff, or paid to subsidiaries in tax havens. So just stating the revenue or profit isn't really enough to understand whether this tax is equitable or fair. It's definitely a grey area, and one in which good accountants could easily massage the figures.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoIn the UK corporate tax is payable on profits before dividends, so Apple (UK) paid corporate tax at a rate of 19% on that £13m dividend. That's about £2.5m. The trick is that taxable profit is a quantity that can be 'optimised'. A large international company like Apple is in fact many companies incorporated in many countries and as such they can 'move' profits to low tax jurisdictions by, e.g. having their Irish subsidiary provide services/goods to their subsidiary in the UK. That creates a cost for the UK company, whereby decreasing its profit and creates an income to the Irish company, whereby increasing its profit.