5 ms·
Would Apple fire Ive over a MacBook issue? That's not where the money is by any means, is it? As long as the iPhone is doing well, business is good at Apple.
by ocdtrekkie 7y ago
Would Apple fire Ive over a MacBook issue? That's not where the money is by any means, is it? As long as the iPhone is doing well, business is good at Apple.
- mantap 7y agoIt's his job to supervise the design of all major products. If he can screw up the MacBook then he is not doing his job effectively and he could potentially screw up the iPhone too.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI don’t blame Ive/Apple too much for the butterfly keyboard issues, at least not per se. It’s hard to predict how a design will hold up after multiple years of use, and the failure rate isn't at world-on-fire levels. However, I absolutely fault Apple for sticking with this keyboard after so many years. I know hardware designs are planned well in advance, but the 12-inch Macbook came out in early 2015. How did they look at the failure rate of that model and decide “yep, we should definitely release a Macbook Pro with this type of keyboard.” And then, why have they stuck with that design for four years and counting? If Apple didn't or doesn't have anything else ready... well, first of all, why did they not have an alternative design ready, especially when they also ran into this problem with the Macbook Pro? But, secondly, Apple could just update the guts of the 2015 MBP, which is what everyone wants them to do anyway. I realize it's misguided to assign feelings to entire corporations, but... Apple just strikes me as so needlessly stubborn sometimes. As if we consumers are small children, and Apple can't go back to the old keyboard lest we be rewarded for whining.
- sangnoir 7y ago> It’s really hard to predict how a design will hold up after multiple years of use It's really not - predicting lifetime expectancy and failure rates is a discipline of industrial engineering. That is why it's possible to estimate the number of open/close cycles of hinges is possible to estimate with a great degree of accuracy. A company has to master art this for selfish reasons - so that they can minimize repair costs during the warranty period
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoSure, but how do you know if your tests match real-world use? I'm not an engineer, so you may well know much more about this, but it seems reasonable to me that real-world people, or some percentage of real-world people, aren't going to hit your keys in the exact way you tested for. If the effects don't appear for years out, what type of user test can you design to account for that?
- mschaef 7y ago> Sure, but how do you know if your tests match real-world use? As a product category, laptops have existed for close to 40 years, and Apple has been a successful and high end participant in that category for close to thirty. If they can't produce a reasonable keyboard reliability test or lack the willingness to do so, then they have other problems that are vastly more concerning than anything about a couple specific computer models.
- ScottBurson 7y agoBut aren't the problems being caused by dirt particles? That's not the same kind of thing as cycle life. I can imagine them originally overlooking the need to test for, and indeed design for, dirt rejection. And now I think the extreme thinness of the keyboard has left them no room to fix the problem.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoSomeone claiming to be an ex-AASP technician made a detailed reddit post arguing against dust as the source of the breakage. I as a layperson found their argument very convincing. https://www.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/bjtyaw/macbook_pro_keyboard_failures_why_apples_dust/ https://www.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/bjtyaw/macbook_pro_k...
- mantap 7y agoThey first introduced this keyboard in April 2015 on the new 12" and first added it to the MacBook Pro in October 2016. So they had 18 months to notice and resolve the issues.
- nextos 7y agoThey also have to be blamed for making products so difficult to repair. If they are truly concerned with environment issues, they should compromise thinness a tiny bit for better repair-ability. One of my last MacBooks, the first aluminium unibody one, had a beautiful latch that gave access to the battery and disk without any tools. The rest of the machine was easy to get access to via 3 screws. Everything was neatly arranged. Whereas these days, it's a glued mess.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoVery real environmental issues aside, I'd question how many consumers ever actually repair their laptops. If it's not many, then you're making everyone's computer thicker to benefit a few. The environmental angle, then, just comes down to whether Apple can recycle parts in as eco-friendly a way as they claim. I'm personally willing to give up repairability for a thin laptop. I'm far less willing to give up actual usability—I want a good keyboard, and I want compatibility with the most common types of thumb drives in active use today.
- noonespecial 7y ago>Very real environmental issues aside, I'd question how many consumers ever actually repair their laptops. Actual consumers? Very few. But a repairable machine retains much greater tradein/resale value reducing the chances it heads straight for the landfill. Witness the mighty 2012—2015 MacBook Pro and the resale value it commands to this day.
- darkpuma 7y agoAt the least it used to be very common for consumers to replace their own battery, an option that now has an unreasonable process for most consumers.
- nextos 7y agoIt's quite typical to replace batteries. And this machine solved that problem really well. Or it made it trivial to run on A/C, without battery. Furthermore, having easy access to components means the effective lifetime of hardware is much longer. You can repair things when it is no longer economical to do so at an Apple Store. I wish some laws were passed forcing manufacturers to display a repairability score, similar to the one that already exists for energy usage.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> Especially when they also ran into this problem with the Macbook Pro *Mac Pro, not Macbook Pro. Sorry.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- fauigerzigerk 7y agoBut how well the iPhone does depends a lot on Apple's premium brand image. They better not jeopardize that by selling any kind of rotten fruit under the same brand. In my view, leaving that keyboard issue unresolved for years has been a terrible mistake.
- _ph_ 7y ago"Fire" might be the wrong word with someone as Ive, but it might have pushed a decision which was long in the coming, according to the article. If Ive had been already unhappy, any disputes about the keyboard and possibly returning to the previous designs might cause him to finally cut the ties into Apple. Or, it might have made Tim Cook to demand a level of involvement of Ive, what Ive is no longer willing to have.