3 ms·
America should follow the example of progressive countries. Point 1. Residential highrises should become the main housing option Point 2. Stop subsidising sub
by baybal2 7y ago
America should follow the example of progressive countries.
Point 1. Residential highrises should become the main housing option
Point 2. Stop subsidising suburban lifestyle for the rich
Point 3. Massive public investments into infrastructure
Point 4. Replace zoning regulations with something less extremely specific or go for sanitary code type regulation
Point 5. Stop requiring people without cars to buy unneeded parking space on their own plot
- tcbawo 7y agoThere is a book that examined this over a century ago, Progress and Poverty (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progress_and_Poverty https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progress_and_Poverty), which was hugely influential in it's day. It seems as though it could have been written today. Yet, it's interesting that the solution proposed is nearly the exact opposite of what was enacted in California.
- scarface74 7y agoPoint 2. Stop subsidising suburban lifestyle for the rich The average price of a house is $226500. (https://www.zillow.com/home-values/ https://www.zillow.com/home-values/). Almost anyone can get an FHA mortgage with 3.5% down. The thought that only rich people can afford a home is not true for most of the country.
- efa 7y agoYup. You can buy brand new houses where I live (San Antonio) for $150k (even less).
- sampleinajar 7y agoTrue, but "rich" is fairly subjective. I also don't think that point was implying that only rich people could afford homes, but that the suburban "lifestyle" and the associated costs of infrastructure were being "subsidized". For the most part, cities subsidize less urban areas.
- scarface74 7y agoSubsidized by who? Suburban areas are often separate municipalities with separate budgets and I would think that most infrastructure would be paid by property taxes and local sales taxes. In fact here in Atlanta there is a trend toward upper class neighborhoods separating from Atlanta and creating separate cities - no this isn’t a good thing.
- sampleinajar 7y agoIt's not exactly true that all services in a local municipality are funded solely by local funds. For example, in your state of Georgia the state pays a share of public education. Most states' largest sources of revenue come from sales taxes which it should be clear comes disproportionately from cities as cities are disproportionately populated. Any state funded and especially state run service is going to be largely funded by city dollars. It's admittedly complex and varies state by state in degree, but overall it stands true that cities pay more taxes to their state in dollar amount by virtue of there being more people; therefore it seems fair to say that any state funds used for any area outside the cities is subsidized by the cities. I'm not saying this is a bad thing, just a valid observation.
- efa 7y agoPoint 3. They've done these types of things and often they are unsuccessful (light rails systems for example). The suburban lifestyle is very strong in the US culture. Just because you build something doesn't mean it will get used.