8 ms·
There are some comments about infrastructure deficiencies here. Reality: Sprawl is more of a burden on municipal jurisdictions because infrastructure, including
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
There are some comments about infrastructure deficiencies here. Reality: Sprawl is more of a burden on municipal jurisdictions because infrastructure, including roads, has to be extended to it and it's not dense enough to adequately cover the cost involved.
If you play SimCity, you can kind of model this by creating a new city from scratch and creating an urban core. Place a fire department and police department at the center and build out to roughly the perimeter of their coverage.
Keep improving development within that footprint until you have an economically viable city, then add a satellite suburb following a similar pattern.
Not everything needs to be in that footprint. You can have farms outside of it, for example, and you can have some industry with only fire coverage, no police.
But if you build a sprawling low-density city, you will find it is impossible to provide adequate services. You can't afford to pay for them. You wind up with high rates of poverty and crime.
Missing Middle housing also helps get an area to residential densities that help make public transit make sense. It also helps improve walkability.
A lot of the problems we have currently are because America sprawls. These problems likely won't be made worse by gently increasing densities. Increasing density in a good way should start to remedy a lot of these issues.
- meddlepal 7y agoEh... Don't buy it. At least in SC4 I've found the west coast urban planning style or suburban styles produce highly profitable and $$ or $$$ res/comm/industrial cities that don't fail. SimCity is a fun game but it's really broken for modelling real world stuff.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoSC4 is broken. Try it in SimCity 3000 or 2000. SC4 intentionally made it stupidly easy to make the city work financially and also killed what I thought of as "the game god." It's all ooh, shiny and can be fun in a largely superficial manner. But I don't think it works well as an actual city simulation anymore. (SC4 followed the company acquisition. It has a more polished, corporate feel and it's cool that it has things like recycling centers. But I am not really a fan.) I cannot find an article about it, but one city uploaded it's data to SimCity and got surprisingly solid city modeling results. This was before the joke that is SC4. Edit: Geez, can we not downvote the comment I'm replying to? I left out the fact that I primarily play SimCity 3000. It's a perfectly reasonable reply that prompted me to fill in missing details that I hadn't thought to include in my original comment.
- edejong 7y agoWrt downvoting: I’ve seen some really trigger happy downvoting on other comments as well, even though the argument was cogent. It would be nice to reserve downvoting for clearly stupid comments.
- samsolomon 7y agoIt's a reasonable comment, but I think it's being downvoted because many believe SC4 was the most difficult game in the franchise. It's been a long time since I've played any of those games, but I recall a good bit of backlash about the new SimCity being too easy compared to previous games.
- givehimagun 7y agoWait - I thought downvoting was for the quality of the comment and not the content? Is downvoting for when people disagree? Wouldn't that hide dissension?
- Retra 7y agoYou can down-vote for whatever reason you like. You are trusted to justify it only to yourself.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThis has been widely hashed out over the years. You can use downvotes to express disagreement. I have no problem with that generally because I would rather see downvotes than see every single person who disagrees feel compelled to pile on with petty BS. But in this case, the comment called attention to a defect in my earlier comment -- my failure to specify which SimCity -- and allowed me to add the missing information. Since my reply with the additional info has substantial upvotes, I think it's wrong to punish the comment that elicited that reply from me. It has too much of that "you win an argument by making the other guy lose" vibe. I hesitate to say this explicitly, because past experience suggests it will result in a temporary pile-on of everyone and their brother nitpicking the hell out of my comments, but I really don't want to discourage good faith comments that nudge me to address defects or omissions in my comments. I don't think that improves discussion here. I think it makes things worse. "Don't shoot the messenger."
- jfoster 7y agoCould you please present a logical argument to back your claim? For example, logically, if someone is in a high density area and can walk to their workplace which is nearby (since it's a high density area), there is less of an infrastructure burden as they do not need to commute each day. That means they won't be contributing to a traffic jam or packed train. What's the argument for sprawl leading to less infrastructure burden?
- icebraining 7y agoWhat meddlepal is saying is that it works in SimCity (4), not that it works in the real world.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoCost - when I worked in Central London I could not afford to buy a former council flat (Red Lion Square) near work, My Boss , a Director and My Bosses Boss the MD could not afford it either
- sprafa 7y agoLondon has hugely inflated house prices, particularly in Central but now all over the city due to foreign investment. It's obvious - virtually no one who actually lives in the city can afford it anymore.
- user5994461 7y agoNot entirely true. The various CXO, MD, expensive contractors and middle managers in large companies can afford in some parts of the city. They could afford almost everywhere a couple years ago. There is a lot of money in London, people just can't fathom how much. An income of £100k a year only gets you around the top 10% of workers. Needless to say. The closest you get to the center, the more you are competing against the very top percentile, which is filthy rich.
- sprafa 7y ago
- CalRobert 7y agoSim City lies, too. Real American "cities" (to use the term generously) are basically a parking lot with a mayor. https://humantransit.org/2013/05/how-sim-city-greenwashes-parking.html https://humantransit.org/2013/05/how-sim-city-greenwashes-pa...
- scarejunba 7y agoWhat a weird tone for that article! Acts like the game developers were out to cheat people out of understanding reality.
- CalRobert 7y agoWell, I wouldn't say it's evil or anything (it's just a game) but it is a bit frustrating in a game calling itself a simulation. Also, it's humantransit, which specifically promotes walking, cycling, etc. so they're going to be understandably annoyed when the cited inspiration for plenty of city planners understates the negative impact of car dependence.
- Nasrudith 7y agoPersonally I wouldn't call it understating car dependence so much as underestimating the alternatives. Which reminds me of Cities Skylines and how they did the opposite for what was probably an amusing oversight. Foot paths are very good for traffic without congestion which makes perfect sense. What doesn't make sense is the complete lack of time or distance limit meaning the population will happily walk a massive pedestrian walkway the length of an entire sector. A somewhat more realistic way is to use subways to link your high density residences with no highway access to places like work and retail while leaving the roads for mostly delivery trucks and emergency services. Apparently Japanese developments were practically planned this way - adding to where a new subway loop and putting housing on top for synergy.
- nicoburns 7y ago> What doesn't make sense is the complete lack of time or distance limit meaning the population will happily walk a massive pedestrian walkway the length of an entire sector. How far is sector? What would you consider reasonable walking distances? Something like 30mins regularly, 60-90mins occasionally?
- paulie_a 7y agoThe city planner had my city recreated in SimCity. The ongoing joke was he'd test out things there. Obviously more thought went into decisions but we have yet to have Godzilla attack.
- michelpp 7y agoOregon cities are constrained by an Urban Growth Boundary. https://www.oregonmetro.gov/urban-growth-boundary https://www.oregonmetro.gov/urban-growth-boundary I agree with your sprawl argument in general, but specifically for this article it does not apply.
- mixologic 7y agoThe portland metro area is constrained by the UGB, and that constraint has yet to materialize in any sort of land shortages. And there is plenty of ways to sprawl within that boundary.
- joelhoffman 7y agoThe Portland region has loads of underused land, and nearly all the other cities in Oregon are FAR from running into the UGB. And they just vote to extend it anyway whenever they want to grow into a specific place that's on the other side. (I'm looking at you, Bend!) It's nice that it's there, but it's mostly symbolic.
- donarb 7y agoBack in 1980, Kirkpatrick Sale wrote a great book called "Human Scale" about how things (government, business, infrastructure) in society are built beyond what humans can comprehend and manage. He pointed to studies that found that if we were to start over and build small 50,000 people towns 15-20 miles apart, each of these towns would have enough people and trades to support those towns. Scholars such as Plato and thinkers like da Vinci also believed that smaller towns of that size contributed to the overall well-being of citizens.