4 ms·
I also suspect that some of these "oversights" aren't mistakes at all, but rather intentional obfuscation of facts. Take note of how often you hear/read someth
by sokoloff 7y ago
I also suspect that some of these "oversights" aren't mistakes at all, but rather intentional obfuscation of facts.
Take note of how often you hear/read something like "incomes haven't risen in 30 years, but prices have gone up over 50% over that period". [Almost?] Inevitably, the income will be real income [inflation adjusted] and the prices nominal prices.
- frankbreetz 7y agoDo you have a source for such a comparison, everything I have seen is all real prices. I know rent and college had gone up about 50% in real prices and some things like food and high end electronics have gone down. Honestly, your comment seems like intentional obfuscation of facts.
- harryh 7y agoHousing costs are only going up because people are buying/renting bigger houses (despite the fact that mean houshold size has decreased by almost a full person in 50 years). On a per square foot basis, you don't really see an increase. http://www.aei.org/publication/new-us-homes-today-are-1000-square-feet-larger-than-in-1973-and-living-space-per-person-has-nearly-doubled/ http://www.aei.org/publication/new-us-homes-today-are-1000-s...
- jdavis703 7y agoHow does this explain the price increases in older, urban housing stock? I’ve been renting 500-600 sq. ft. one bedroom apartments for the past seven years. My rent has gone up from $1900 a month to now $2790 month. This is all within the same zip code.
- harryh 7y agoThere are definitely some outliers, particularly in urban centers (primarily due to overly restrictive zoning codes). I was speaking about averages.
- Aloha 7y agoYou also make a good point, in many places zoning would prohibit construction of identical replacements of much of the housing that is located there. One of the commenters on the article you linked makes a good point: "new single family homes are a very small part of the real estate market. most of the big price moves have been in urban areas where single family dwellings uncommon and new homes extremely rare."
- sokoloff 7y agoPay attention over the coming 3 months to articles and headlines on inflation and wages on social and mainstream media. I think you'll find that well over half of them omit stating key assumptions/sources, and appear to be authored so as to lead the audience to the wrong (or at least an exaggerated) conclusion.
- m12k 7y agoTo be fair, pretty much all articles about literally any subject on social and main stream media fail to state key assumptions/sources - don't see why you'd think this topic is special in that regard. If we're going to debate anything in a sensible manner, we need to use actual publications by experts as the basis for those discussions.
- sokoloff 7y agoI’m not worried nor do I believe that economists are confused. I worry that the public / workers / voters / policy makers are being misled/confused/misdirected.
- frankbreetz 7y agoYou sound like a conspiracy theorist if you have no sources, the first couple google searches are not doing this[0],[1]. The public is being misled, by whenever someone complains about stagnant wages the response is "you have smartphones now", but we can't afford houses or healthcare how is this okay? So your argument seems to be that all economists are in on this together to do what? And your thankful your favorite youtube news personality has cracked the case (without publishing any research and has an opportunity to make money from getting views). Good thing he /she is looking out for you. The bottom line is you sound incredibly foolish to me if you can't supply any sources of people trying to do this trick. Even if you do find one or two examples, there are plenty of sound statistics that say people have it harder now finicailly then 50 years ago. [0] https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/101314/what-does-current-cost-living-compare-20-years-ago.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/101314/what-does-cu... [1] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us-workers-real-wages-have-barely-budged-for-decades/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us...
- car12 7y agoYou can't win elections if you actually start talking about most contributing factors. In that case, very soon you'll be discussing immigration as your most important point and start sounding like Trump. Woops!
- strken 7y agoI sympathise with this view, but I'm not sure it's that simple. If you're Chinese or Bangladeshi or from anywhere else that's a poster child of globalisation, you can still compete with the US labour force from your own country. If you're allowed to immigrate, you get access to infrastructure, cultural knowledge, a somewhat functional legal system, and other force multipliers which might allow you to compete with more efficiency... but you'd still be competing even if you were back home.
- car12 7y agoConsider an individual John from Texas with a total population of N. Initially John's chances of getting a job: 1/N Now, with the arrival of new immigrant, John's chances: 1/(N+1) i.e. he's worse off. Sure it turned out better for the new immigrant and he can earn way more than his original country and thus this is better for humanity and the globe but it is of little relief to John who is worse off now. My assumptions in this: - John is a low skilled worker who will not be easily able to switch to another line of work like a software developer - John does not have significant savings to fall back on. Another fun fact: - The will to let the low skilled immigrant in, in today's environment does not stem necessarily from a position of goodwill, rather it is a calculated position to keep the numbers of a voting bloc which consistently votes for a given party, constant. This can be easily explained by seeing where the opposition to limiting immigration comes from. So keeping in mind the above 2 points, it becomes readily apparent that what politics has gotten good at is winning elections and not betterment of people. One of the parties has discovered that one of the easiest "hacks" or "optimizations" is to keep importing poor people and that way you will have a steady stream of voters, otherwise you might actually have to start improving the stock of existing population. This is somewhat analogous to how simply being good at a written test for a position does not necessarily mean you're a good fit for that position but you've simply optimized for the selection process. All of this to say that as far as a hypothetical John is concerned, it is of no merit to him that the world is a bit more efficient because a person from Bangladesh is able to work with a little more efficiency, indeed whatever small gains from that are outright eclipse by an increased competition in the local pool of jobs and resources.