3 ms·
A large portion of what reduced inequality was the destruction of wealth during World War II and the fact that the U.S. benefited afterward from being the last
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
A large portion of what reduced inequality was the destruction of wealth during World War II and the fact that the U.S. benefited afterward from being the last standing industrial economy.
I seriously doubt that.
We shipped essentially all able-bodied men off to war, so much so that we filled a lot of jobs with women. Birth rates were low because the men were physically absent.
People were encouraged to grow Victory Gardens so farm food could feed soldiers. Tobacco, sugar etc were all rationed. We stopped making cars and converted car factories to keep factories.
A lot of families had two incomes, no children and couldn't spend their money on luxury goods because they simply weren't available. Savings rates during the war were extremely high, above 50 percent some years.
The boys came home, bringing veterans benefits with them. This included help buying a house and going to college.
Unlike with modern lottery winners, this formula did not encourage people to just blow their money frivolously. They began buying houses at such high rates we invented new ways to throw them up quickly, giving rise to the modern suburb.
Celibacy, low birth rates, frugal living, hard work and high savings rates helped reduce inequality. A lot of that could be replicated. We just don't typically have the self discipline to do so individually.
- ahaferburg 7y agoI'm not sure what you mean by that last sentence. Are you saying if only the poor were better with money they'd stop being poor?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'm saying there were large-scale forces at work during WW2 that forced many people into that pattern. It's much harder to do on an individual basis without those forces, but can be done sometimes. Among other things, I paid down debt while homeless. My last student loan payment was made in July 2017. I was back in housing in September the same year. Of course, your framing sounds like I'm being accused of blaming the poor. I'm not. I'm just questioning the assertion of the article because it honestly doesn't fit with what I have read of history. The Baby Boomer generation is the children of the WW2 veterans. It was a very widespread phenomenon. There are factors at play now that are definitely different from then. Most new houses in the 1950s were about 1200 sqft. Now they are nearly 2500 sqft. We desperately need to do something about our housing supply. But most people don't want to.
- zxcmx 7y agoOne aspect I haven’t seen much discussion about is that WWII may have acted as a kind of giant social mixer. I mean this in the sense that people who might hardly meet each today were thrown together often more or less as equals. At least within the (ok, very limited) bounds of the race and gender norms of the day. Today a programmer, middle manager or radiographer say can get to middle age without ever really “meeting” a labourer, truck driver or meat packer. I think that has pretty deep implications for labour solidarity.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoGreat comment and observation.