3 ms·
I think that's an un-generous interpretation of the quote. Yes, I think there is good evidence that if you are in a poverty-stricken family and you don't get v
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
I think that's an un-generous interpretation of the quote.
Yes, I think there is good evidence that if you are in a poverty-stricken family and you don't get very early intervention, that by mid-elementary school it is too late for your average poor kid. The reason being that the rest of your environment of poverty is going to be pretty much pulling against you the rest of your childhood, so intervention while your hopes and goals are not yet formed is your best bet.
And come on, the author wasn't saying if you didn't attend a Caribbean summer program that you're underprivileged. I believe he was just using that to highlight the pretty extreme lengths that middle class and above parents go to provide their children with educational enrichment (including music lessons, sports programs, summer camps, etc.) that put poor kids at a lifelong disadvantage.
- lilsoso 7y agoI largely agree with you. But the following line from the article is devastating, "For a lot of children, when they’re 8 years old, it’s too late." And this mawkish line is published under the banner of Stanford, an arbiter of the truth. I expect better. edit: My comments seem to have sparked a nerve. I simply wanted to point out bad rhetoric that undermines the cause and weakens an institution of trust. The situation is bad, so there's no need to exaggerate or lie to deliver the point. And this isn't a partisan issue. A conservative like Thiel would deliver a similar message. There is, however, a pernicious insinuation in that quote. The notion that if you haven't achieved x by y age you're done. That's a debilitating notion. And we have it in the tech community, if you can't code by z age give up. Or if you haven't achieved some startup success or some corporate title at an early age you're a failure.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoIt is possible for both to be true: For many children, if they have not had early childhood intervention, by 8 years old it is too late, but that for any individual child, they can still improve their lot later in childhood (or even, of course, well into adulthood). As a similar example, it is extremely likely that a child who is overweight or obese by middle school will be overweight or obese their entire life, and many scientists and clinicians believe that it is much easier to prevent childhood obesity than try to correct the weight imbalance later on. That doesn't mean that some people who are overweight kids won't eventually lose the weight and keep it off. Hanging on to the hope that people can change at any point in life does not mean we should ignore the fact that many of our personality and social "guiderails" are laid down pretty early.