4 ms·
Right to repair is just one of the many cases of "security" being used as an excuse to take away freedom, and it's one of the ways the corporations and governme
by userbinator 7y ago
Right to repair is just one of the many cases of "security" being used as an excuse to take away freedom, and it's one of the ways the corporations and governments (nearly the same thing, really) gradually build their dystopian vision of complete control over the population. It's so alluring, because "who doesn't want to be safe and secure?" On the surface it's appealing, but if you think about it, much like "a world without (cyber)crime", the ultimate result of striving for perfect security is dystopia.
Then, much as perfect freedom is unattainable, so is perfect security; and I think it's time we rebelled against this desire to achieve it. Unfortunately, it seems desiring any sort of security is only going to give the companies more leverage to use it against us, so the way to go is to reject completely their notion of (centralised, authoritarian) security, and make freedom the highest priority. Insecurity is freedom, and that is what we should fight for.
That infamous Benjamin Franklin quote has really taken on a deeper meaning recently.
- whatshisface 7y agoSecurity against institutions is just as important as security against individuals, because big institutions aren't any more moral than the average individual. Everyone thinks about security against criminals, but the reason we don't live in a third world dictatorship is our constitutionally enshrined security against the police.
- danShumway 7y ago> Security against institutions is just as important as security against individuals This is very well phrased. It gets across something I was having trouble putting into words -- that security and freedom aren't always just opposite goals that conflict with each other. Freedom isn't an ideal, it's a practical system designed to guard against tangible harms.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Reelin 7y agoI want perfect security, but I don't want perfect "security". Please allow me to explain. I find it particularly frustrating that in conversations about security it's difficult to differentiate between the different uses of the word. There's user security against other users (same system), criminals (remote), criminals (physical access), large entities (ie governments and corporations), and probably a few others. Then there's owner (or admin?) security, for example IT vs employees who do dumb things and other similar scenarios. There's also vendor security against user control of devices. Sometimes this is to protect a walled garden, but other times it's just a cheap way to prevent damage to their brand if clueless users do dumb things and then publicly blame the company for their own negligence. Arguably the first category (user security) is a good thing, but those designing the devices fall almost exclusively into the second two (I would argue mostly bad) categories.
- cameronbrown 7y ago> Then there's owner (or admin?) security, for example IT vs employees who do dumb things and other similar scenarios. I think the best way to balance this vs. security is something analogous to sudo. Design for people who don't know what they're doing by default and don't say you didn't warn them if they break their system with superuser control.
- simion314 7y ago>Then there's owner (or admin?) security, for example IT vs employees who do dumb things and other similar scenarios. I only see this argument made by Apple fans, it is always related with branding, something like "we don't want someone phone or laptop to catch fire and destroy Apples perfect brand" . the ironic thing was that after we had this discussion on HN a few days back we had the news that genuine Apple laptops catch fire anyway. Would Microsoft like not to be able to repair the servers they run on their cloud? not to be able ro run whatever code then want on the server? be forced to run the server hardware manufacturer code so they make sure MS is not running the servers incorrectly and make them explode?
- xfitm3 7y agoChildren are also used in this same disgusting persuasion tactic.