3 ms·
What do you mean there's no competition? This feels like such a weird statement when there's competition in just about every market segment on the web. If you m
by Spivak 7y ago
What do you mean there's no competition? This feels like such a weird statement when there's competition in just about every market segment on the web. If you mean there's no competition where the differentiating feature between competitors is performance then well sure, that's a lot rarer.
For user-facing applications performance only really matters in human time, and is pretty far down on the list of how people choose software over things like features, price, ease of use, etc.. Until performance becomes a big problem because the app/site becomes unusable it's basically no problem.
Hackers might not like it but we're such a weird market to sell to. Not necessarily that performance is a weird preference but that by in large hackers are perfectly fine with woefully inefficient feature-packed apps for their "primary" apps like their IDE but then want super lightweight skeleton-featured experiences for everything secondary.
- jcelerier 7y ago> large hackers are perfectly fine with woefully inefficient feature-packed apps for their "primary" apps like their IDE well, even the most feature-bloated IDE loads faster than GMail on my computer (before anyone asks, I'm on gigabit fiber)
- keymone 7y ago> For user-facing applications performance only really matters in human time, and is pretty far down on the list of how people choose software over things like features, price, ease of use, etc.. There was a study that has shown correlation between revenue drop and milliseconds that page takes to load. It’s not only hackers that respond to performance. As for competition - due to network effects there are very few competitors to things like Facebook, Amazon and other big tech. If these were federated services participating in communication built around some gigantic independent social graph - that would enable more competition in terms of UI performance, features, etc. Not going to happen anytime soon though.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoThe e-commerce revenue example is different from the point of the apps people choose to use in general. Also, HNers always circlejerk over how fast and federated IRC is yet Slack and Discord ate IRC's lunch despite IRC's decades of head start and the bloatedness of the new arrivals. So you don't make a very convincing point that people really do care. Another example is email: gmail.com is super slow, there are a lot of competing email clients, yet I'm sure the vast majority of users don't care and just use gmail.com. I use the web interface.
- Silhouette 7y agoPerformance is crucially important for a lot of applications. It profoundly affects the usability of a site if performance is too slow, and many studies over the years suggest direct losses on the bottom line as a result. It may be a controversial opinion, but I think part of the problem today is that young web developers look to people who work at high-profile places like Facebook and Google as role models and for examples of best practice. And yet, a lot of Google's and Facebook's own web properties are... less than exemplary... in terms of performance, usability, design, and other factors that are important in most situations, and have been getting steadily worse rather than better over time. I humbly submit that the reasons for the runaway success of these giants have really very little to do with the quality of their sites any more, and that up to a point they can get away with things because of their dominant positions and lock-in effects that simply wouldn't be acceptable for most of the rest of us.
- watsocd 7y agoI think a lot of this is technical debt. They built the feature/page/whatever code and it works "good enough". Now a future programmer three years later tells the business manager that they can do this much better now for $x. It will improve nothing as far as the user in concerned. Maybe the page will load faster but the user may not even notice. Maybe they will save some money on hosting and bandwidth costs. In most cases, the business person will most likely tell the programmer to keep working on to new feature z2021 project and leave the old code alone. This is until there is a security problem or the old code effects the z2021 project.
- chrisweekly 7y agoPerformance _is_ a feature. In fact it's the most important feature.
- hedora 7y agoWell, correctness / security are probably more important than performance. (Spoiler alert: If your system is well-enough implemented to be correct, it is well on the way to being secure and performant too)
- nameiscubanpete 7y agoIt's better that "Hello, world" take 5 seconds to print than 1 second to crash and print nothing.