4 ms·
I get it, and I'm sure that if SO hadn't driven me away from contributing years ago, I might be upset too. But for me this is in the category of "cows realizing
by wpietri 7y ago
I get it, and I'm sure that if SO hadn't driven me away from contributing years ago, I might be upset too. But for me this is in the category of "cows realizing that all that grain wasn't free after all". That these people are expert SO users doesn't make them experts in marketing and revenue maximization.
- lucb1e 7y agoYou're being a little condescending and are not exactly making a good comparison. Stackoverflow was (is?) a really cool company and website, and as far as I knew they were making a reasonable profit. Consider that they allow visitors to post questions and answer, edit other people's questions and answers, and even query the database for any info that's public (e.g. not user passwords, but pretty much anything else), all without having an account. That's unique.The moderation model (that it's based on reputation except for a few elected members) is also also very unique. It's really a site by programmers for programmers, moderated by everyone who spends time there. Having them change the site completely, solely for making more profit, is unexpected. It would be similar to Linux announcing that the kernel will have a license fee from now on - you can be snarky about the cows and the grain, and indeed the kernel project is of huge value so it would make sense from a commercial perspective, but the kernel becoming paid and stackoverflow using annoying UI patterns are both not in line with their previous ways.
- marktangotango 7y agoIt's really a site by programmers for programmers, Indeed, I think many, many people share the same complaint about SO moderation, and this is the best explanation imo. Physician heal thyself!
- dooglius 7y agoIt's worth pointing out that the Linux kernel cannot do this due to the GPL, by design
- klez 7y agoThey can absolutely do this. It would not be useful, but they certainly can. The FSF itself used to sell copies of the GNU operating system for a fee. The problem with the license is just that when it's out there (i.e., one person paid for it) it's out there for everyone else if the paying person decides to release it for free for everybody else.
- lucb1e 7y agoOf course, they can refuse to sell to the person leaking it, denying them access unless there is another mole. I heard this is how GRSecurity works, which makes a hardened Linux kernel. Also, the bulk of StackOverflow's data is creative commons. A similar argument goes here as for the Linux kernel.
- andreareina 7y agoBruce Perens argues[1] (HN comments[2]) that a penalty for exercising the right to redistribute is de facto a restriction on redistribution, which the GPL prohibits. [1] https://perens.com/2017/06/28/warning-grsecurity-potential-contributory-infringement-risk-for-customers/ https://perens.com/2017/06/28/warning-grsecurity-potential-c... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14731955 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14731955
- lucb1e 7y agoInteresting, I did not know that anyone opposed this on legal grounds. Thanks for sharing!
- pmoriarty 7y ago"Consider that they allow visitors to post questions and answer, edit other people's questions and answers, and even query the database for any info that's public (e.g. not user passwords, but pretty much anything else), all without having an account." This is not unique. Wikipedia's Reference desk[1] allows asking/answering any question by anyone -- even unregistered users. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reference_desk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reference_desk
- dwaltrip 7y agoDoes anyone use it? By some combination of skill and luck, stackoverflow was clearly better positioned to fill this role, at least for software related content.
- wpietri 7y ago> It's really a site by programmers for programmers I question your use of "really" here. If it were really that, this wouldn't have happened. As far as I can tell, what it really is is a for-profit business, where the owners are the ones who decide things like what "a reasonable profit" is. I agree, of course, that this is (somewhat) out of line with their previous ways. But almost any for-profit social site is an elaborate bait-and-switch, where it starts free and lovely and gradually moves in the direction of profit maximization. You'll find veterans of almost every social site saying how it just isn't like the good old days. If you don't like that, maybe you shouldn't do a lot of free work for people who are making money from it. Wikipedia, for all its flaws, is much more accountable to its community than any for-profit site will be.
- Hello71 7y agoit's almost like not everything should be about marketing and revenue maximization.
- wpietri 7y agoI agree not everything should be. Which is why people should build more non-profits. And why they shouldn't do a lot of free work for for-profits. But here we are.