3 ms·
9.2M? 145 people over 3 months? That's 9.2M / (145*90) = 700~ texts per PERSON per DAY. That's insane. Even if each text goes to ever other person and is do
by sandworm101 7y ago
9.2M? 145 people over 3 months? That's 9.2M / (145*90) = 700~ texts per PERSON per DAY. That's insane. Even if each text goes to ever other person and is double counted, that is still 17+ texts per day from each person. Are these teenagers? Do drug dealers really send texts to dozens of people at once? We have to be missing something.
- snikch 7y agoYea I came to ask that same question. All I can assume is that’s badly reported and in fact entire cell tower’s messages were being tapped. Which has huge repercussions for privacy. Another thought could be some sort of forwarding service. Regardless these numbers are massive.
- zaroth 7y agoA halfway determined teenager probably sends over 700 texts an hour. I wouldn’t be surprised to see rates upwards of 1,000 per hour for some users. Average character count per text is probably low. Median character count could be something like 3. That’s all rank speculation on my part. Would be interesting to see actual data on this though!
- dredmorbius 7y ago11 a minute? One every 5 seconds? Sustained? For 24 hours/day, 7 days/wk, 4 weeks/mo, 3 months straight? I somehow doubt that very much.
- r3bl 7y ago> For 24 hours/day, 7 days/wk, 4 weeks/mo, 3 months straight? The comment above reached a figure of 700 per day per person. For my teen self, that's about two or three hours of conversation per day. It's certainly sustainable for months. Hell, I was known as the outlier in my teen circles because I liked to send longer messages (actually combining full sentences into one message) from time to time.
- dredmorbius 7y agoThe comment I'm reading states 700/hr, up to 1000/hr. Not day. That may not be what its author intended, but it's what they wrote. Twice.
- zaroth 7y agor3bl is correct. In the context of incredulity over someone sending 700 texts per day, my point was that I’m sure there are many users who send over 700 texts in a single an hour. Nowhere did I say that rate would be sustained for 24 consecutive hours. It is the ultimate in moving goalposts to take my response to a claim of 700/day being insane, to recast the debate as if it were over sending 17,000 texts per day.
- dredmorbius 7y agoPew's 2012 estimate, the most recent available, is 167 mean, 60 median, texts/day for teens. Fewer than 20% send more than 200 texts/day. Again, the likelihood that "many" exceed 700/day, let alone 700/hr, absent some bulk multicasting method, is unsupported by plausibility or data. https://www.pewinternet.org/2012/03/19/what-teens-do-with-their-phones/ https://www.pewinternet.org/2012/03/19/what-teens-do-with-th...
- zaroth 7y ago2012? Phhffaw. Dude, do you even text? </s> But when did I ever say many?!
- dredmorbius 7y agoRereading your initial comment, that's strongly implied. I think this horse is now dead, and or has come to enjoy the beating.
- dredmorbius 7y agoAnd Zipf distributions would suggest that the most frequent transmitters dominated the transmissions. The numbers stated work out to suspiciously close to a transmission every 30 seconds, which may suggest this is a capture including both routine cell-tower transmissions and texts, with the former dominating the data. I doubt the accuracy of the story as reported, though whether that's a misstatement in the report or a misunderstanding by the reporter isn't clear. The report in question: https://www.uscourts.gov/statistics-reports/wiretap-report-2018 https://www.uscourts.gov/statistics-reports/wiretap-report-2... It states: The federal wiretap with the most intercepts occurred during a narcotics investigation in the Southern District of Texas and resulted in the interception of 9,208,906 messages in 120 days. XLSX tables with underlying data are provided. My read is that intercepts are not limited to user-initiated comms, and include automated telco service messaging
- pergadad 7y agoEven more the other case: 9.1mio/45 people/3 months makes 2250 messages per day per subject So kind of impossible for a mere human? Or were they targeting 45 but actually collecting for vastly larger numbers (eg entire cell towers' throughout) ? Would make sense of the suspects had many phones or kept switching phones.