24 ms·
>> von Gerkan's, dislike of shopping. No. That was not the problem. The problem was that they did not properly supervise the architect. Architects are artis
by sandworm101 7y ago
>> von Gerkan's, dislike of shopping.
No. That was not the problem. The problem was that they did not properly supervise the architect. Architects are artists. They always have some bias one way or another, some little opinion on how things should look or work. They need to be watched. It was someone's job to ensure that architect's "vision" matched the customer needs. That person should have realized the error and halted proceedings long before breaking ground on anything.
When you don't watch the architect you get things like this: https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/penis-shaped-church https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/penis-shaped-church
- dmix 7y ago> The church staff drafted a blueprint for the replacement, calling for a long, rectangular shape to allow for natural lighting, with a curve in order to preserve an oak tree to the south of the church. Sorry, I don't see how that story is relevant to your position. An architect not delivering on some basic requirements is one thing, not necessarily because they are artists, because art will always only be a part of architecture. Delivering that is completely disconnected from it's use case is simply bad architecture. Making a major change to a plan half way through is a good way to piss off any designer or engineer though. Especially one as massive and all-encompasing as a huge airport, railway, and hotel complex + retail shopping center. I'm curious how much that had to do with them dragging their feet, in a huff, out of ego or whatever. I doubt the architects simply 'hates' shopping, or maybe they do and didn't know that was a requirement before going in deep into a project. But somewhere the communication broke down and relationships deteriorated.
- 7952 7y agoI am a bit surprised that architects would have such a big involvement in such a project. You wouldn't hire an architect to design a factory production line or a freight terminal. An airport has much more common with a complex industrial site than a traditional building. And at this scale everything is an engineering challenge that needs a specialist to do properly.