2 ms·
Knowing nothing about Apple's specific case, I have been involved in the decision at major companies to deviate from common standards, which is not done lightly
by jandrewrogers 7y ago
Knowing nothing about Apple's specific case, I have been involved in the decision at major companies to deviate from common standards, which is not done lightly, on many occasions and worked with standards organizations to smooth over the fallout. In my experience, when a company the size of Apple deviates from a standard, there are pragmatic and arguably justifiable reasons behind the scenes.
The typical driver is that the standard is a poor fit for purpose because it was originally designed by companies operating under a more limited set of constraints and use cases. In some of the cases I've been involved in, the deviations required to make it fit for purpose would immediately save millions of dollars per year versus following the strict letter of the standard, so the value of deviating was not academic. The reason you keep any deviation close to the standard instead of designing a new one is to minimize the interoperability gap in practice.
If you are able to articulate why the standard is not fit for purpose to the standards organizations, they may use it as a driver for a new standard. However, this frequently runs into strong political resistance from the existing member base because they rarely benefit from the increased scope -- all downside, no upside. Nonetheless, the standards organizations are invested in maintaining relevance. As a practical matter, unless you go into these discussions with the standards orgs with an existing implementation of an alternative that threatens their existing standard, they are very reluctant to move.
I'm not saying any of this applies to Apple's case but the above happens a lot in my experience. It would be nice if it was easy to work with the standards organizations if you need to make a standard work for other use cases but in practice it is an extremely difficult and political uphill battle.