3 ms·
I think it’s the issue of Apple vs. Open in general. Apple’s echo system is closed to the world. I think that for people outside of HN, that's OK. Not everyon
by reaperducer 7y ago
I think it’s the issue of Apple vs. Open in general. Apple’s echo system is closed to the world.
I think that for people outside of HN, that's OK. Not everyone trusts the open source community, or open source organizations.
If something goes wrong with something important, it's normal for people to want something or someone to blame. If that something is Apple, that's useful. If it's some rando on the internet contributing code to a code repository, it's significantly less useful to the ordinary person.
For the average person, entrusting Apple with their logins is a better option than using password1234 or some other coping mechanism. People know Apple. Nobody knows OpenID. It's the same reason people used to trust Microsoft (and many still do!) with their personal information. Microsoft is a known quantity.
It's like having a neighbor watch your pets while you're on vacation, or signing up with some random service on the internet to watch your pets. Those random services get bonded and insured for the peace of mind of the user. There is no such level of assurance from OpenID other than it uses the word "open" in its name, and as a culture we value the word "open" more than "closed."
- andyroid 7y agoBut this is not an issue of Apple vs. OpenID Connect, but one between Apple’s flawed implementation of the OpenID Connect standard vs. the actual OpenID Connect standard. If they would have just gone with some proprietary implementation I very much doubt the OIDC people would have bothered. That happens pretty much daily after all.
- damnyou 7y agoOne of the big cultural problems in society today, and (antitrust) law in particular, is the focus on consumer welfare above all else. The consumer is not the only thing that matters
- hidden_anomaly 7y agoCan you expand on this idea? This is the first time I’ve heard anyone saying that consumer-first is wrong.
- damnyou 7y agoLina Khan is one of the leading proponents of the idea: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/07/technology/monopoly-antitrust-lina-khan-amazon.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/07/technology/monopoly-antit... The consumer uber alles idea is actually pretty new in the history of antitrust law.
- jeremyjh 7y agoApple - like every commercial vendor - is responsible for their products and services whether or not they use open source software and open protocols to implement them. Every service on the internet relies on open standards, it doesn't change their liability.
- AshamedCaptain 7y agoOpenID is not an open source community nor organization.