7 ms·
Are they also going to go through all kinds of expressions of art and looking for unacceptable views in their libraries? Movie catalogues, books and destroy th
by mc32 7y ago
Are they also going to go through all kinds of expressions of art and looking for unacceptable views in their libraries?
Movie catalogues, books and destroy them too? We used to make fun of authoritarian regimes and how they were week for trying to stamp out art and thought they didn’t like, but it’s like we’ve become them.
I’m a bit surprised they haven’t revived Gore’s PMRC to ensure music lyrics represent correct orthodoxy.
I mean, I can understand renaming streets. Streets are renamed for various reasons, and some commemorate dubious people, but the street remains. I wonder...
...Will one day all the Mission cities get renamed because they were named by Evangelizing Spanish Missionaries. Is that where we’re headed? We can name them after tribes or chiefs, perhaps. I propose Ohlone for San Francisco.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- throw20102010 7y agoThis is basically the same argument that southern right-wingers use to defend keeping their confederate statues, but oddly enough many internet commenters seem to have no problems with ripping down those pieces of art since they represented something they didn't like. I'm not accusing you (mc32) of being hypocritical since I haven't seen you make any comments saying that we should rip out old confederate statues because they represent slavery. However, (let me reiterate that this isn't an attack on you, mc32), I think we as a collective internet need to rethink how we feel about removing artwork if it represents something bad. It is not okay for us to be okay with ripping out some untasteful art but not others, simply because some bad art is "left" and other bad art is "right." Before you go jumping on me about how slavery is different than communism, remember that communism is responsible for nearly a hundred million deaths, which puts it near the level of slavery in terms of harm it has done to humanity (even if they aren't directly comparable).
- BeeOnRope 7y agoI mean there is the slight difference that the statues intend to glorify the figures they represent, while this mural does the opposite - it's a pointed commentary on slavery and colonialism.
- rjf72 7y agoStatues are inanimate. What glorification happens is by people. When you see a statue of something or someone you find distasteful, do you find yourself glorifying whatever it represents or does the statue instead simply serve as a reminder to you of the past for which you make your own judgements? Do statues impose meaning, or do people find their own meaning in them? Of course the answer is self evident. One reason that purging of the past is so intrinsically tied to authoritarian regimes is because authoritarian regimes do not want people to think for themselves. They want to enforce their views and only their views with no possible ambiguity or counterpoint. This is the danger of flirting with authoritarianism, as I feel we have been doing in trying to purge the past. Once the momentum for 'cultural purification' grows, you may find that where you draw your personal line in the sand is not where the rest of those pursuing such ends choose to.
- magpi3 7y agoHowever poor its implementation has been, the ideology behind communism is based is the idea that people should not be stratified by class. The ideology behind slavery is that some people are subhuman and can be treated like animals. The broad brush you are using to equate the two is inappropriate. The U.S. freedom loving founding fathers participated in not only the legalization of slavery but also the genocide of native americans. Should we lay those sins at the feet of democracy and capitalism as a whole?
- mantas 7y agoInterwebs is not a "collective mind". A lot of individuals participate. Each with his own ideas. Why would it be hypocritical to go be against another user of the tool? Are politicians hypocritical to have opposing ideas?
- davesmith1983 7y agoYes. This has been going on for a while. There were several civil war statues of various generals that have been pulled down because of their politics at the time. They tried to do the same to the Statue of Cecil Roads which I believe is in Oxford University. There is also ideas of "Colonial Science" or "White Science" which reminds me of movement of removing "Jewish" Science and Mathematics in preference to "Aryan Science" before World War II.
- mieseratte 7y ago> There is also ideas of "Colonial Science" or "White Science" which reminds me of movement of removing "Jewish" Science and Mathematics in preference to "Aryan Science" before World War II. The use of "White Privilege" really does remind me of the "Global Jewish Conspiracy." As if there exists a cabal we're all in on.
- 0815test 7y agoEven more directly, "White privilege" is simply a variation of "bourgeois privilege". The whole idea of "bourgeois privilege" however rephrased and antiquated "counterrevolutionary elements" as something that should be purged wholesale from society is something that goes at least as far back as the Cultural Revolution in China; knowing that, it's incredibly scary that anyone in the West is still taking these notions at face value!
- krapp 7y ago>Even more directly, "White privilege" is simply a variation of "bourgeois privilege". The whole idea of "bourgeois privilege" however rephrased and antiquated "counterrevolutionary elements" as something that should be purged wholesale from society is something that goes at least as far back as the Cultural Revolution in China; knowing that, it's incredibly scary that anyone in the West is still taking these notions at face value! Your comment seems to imply that the premise of "white privilege" should carry a connotation of "white genocide," and that anyone who accepts the former likely desires the latter. I certainly hope that was not your intent, if so you are very mistaken. White privilege simply means that white people benefit, however implicitly , from a society which was founded on white supremacist ideals. Or more abstractly, that the descendants of the people who stacked the deck of Western civilization in their favor may enjoy privileges that those against whom the deck was stacked may not. No sinister overtones of purges or mass murder need by applied, except by those with an agenda.
- Digory 7y ago> Mission cities... Last week: "In partnership with the Amah Mutsun Tribal Band, UC Santa Cruz will be removing the mission bell that is located on campus. The bell was originally donated to the campus by a local women’s club many years ago ..." "Mission bells, which were installed across the state to memorialize the California Missions, are viewed by many populations as a symbol of racism and dehumanization of their ancestors." https://news.ucsc.edu/2019/06/mission-bell.html https://news.ucsc.edu/2019/06/mission-bell.html
- ajross 7y ago> Are they also going to go through all kinds of expressions of art These are public murals. They're on giant walls hundreds or thousands of community members must walk by daily (the kids don't even have a choice). I don't think it's too much to demand that public art not be... y'know, wildly racist. It's not like we're outlawing private galleries or burning books here. This stuff really is offensive, and "historical context" only goes so far.
- rjf72 7y agoIt's so easy to forget that authoritarianism is often not brought on against a people, but through their very support. The book burnings of the past were not the product of an unpopular government forcibly purging 'inconveniences'. Burnings were joyous events where people celebrated 'purifying' themselves and their culture by removal of newly unacceptable influences. "No to decadence and moral corruption! Yes to decency and morality in family and state! I consign [these books] to the flames..." That was spoken by Joseph Goebbels to raucous applause in a crowd of tens of thousands as they celebrated the new and improved morality of the German State, in 1933. In America we've started down the exact same path, but people accept it because think they believe that banning and burning flags, destroying statues, banning books (see: e.g. Mark Twain), and now destroying art are part of some grand effort to bring about a new morality and new vision for the nation. Instead we just continue down paths that have been tread many a time before yet ever refusing to consider the parallels because, after all, this time it will be different.
- ajross 7y ago> Are they also going to go through all kinds of expressions of art and looking for unacceptable views in their libraries? Good grief. It's not a library, it's a mural. This isn't an archive of historically important but plausibly controversial artwork being purged for thought crimes, it's a fucking school wall. Kids and staff have to walk by this thing every day. And there's a dead indian on it front and center, and a bunch of slaves working in a field. It's... it's just not appropriate artwork for a public space. And all this hand wringing is completely insincere anyway. If some random school in Arkansas had decided to repaint a mural with similar content, no one would care. But this is San Francisco, so of course Bari Weiss gets to write about it int The Times and pretend it's some kind of liberal disease.
- ng12 7y agoSchool kids have to walk by a mural depecting the sometimes ugly history of their country? So what?
- ajross 7y agoSo... maybe their school district should feel free replace the ugly history with some more acceptable public artwork without a bunch of internet conservatives freaking out about it? I mean, it's not like they don't teach the history of slavery or indigenous peoples in California schools. They don't need to celebrate it on the corridor walls if they don't want to, do they?
- 0815test 7y agoIt's not just any artwork, it's a piece of WPA art by an independently-notable artist. Yes, it's ugly (if only in the way it freely uses stereotypes that are considered at least somewhat offensive today). But so what. The school district can cover it in a non-destructive way if they don't want the schoolkids exposed to it, but destroying the work altogether would be out of question in a sane world.
- neonate 7y agoThe artist was a communist. Do you really think he was celebrating slavery?
- smsm42 7y ago> Are they also going to go through all kinds of expressions of art and looking for unacceptable views in their libraries? I think that's been going on for a while. I remember discussions of some works of American literature, which routinely have been parts of teen curriculum, being declared unsuitable due to the use of certain words that represent racial slurs now. > I’m a bit surprised they haven’t revived Gore’s PMRC to ensure music lyrics represent correct orthodoxy. That's way too little now. Long past are the times where the only thing that needed for a work to not be banned is content of the work itself. Now if the author fails the purity test, all their work, no matter how clean, is automatically treif and must be expunged. So the ideological commission would have a lot of work on their hands. Likely, it can be crowdsourced by twitterati who are only to happy do dig up any utterance, no matter how old, in the service of the noble goal of unpersoning yet another offender. > Will one day all the Mission cities get renamed because they were named by Evangelizing Spanish Missionaries. I wouldn't put it past them. Not only "San" prefix clearly implies religious reference, which triggers atheists and ACLU, I am sure modern sensibilities would not be too kind to Francis of Assisi, which associated with literal crusaders, engaged in various acts of cultural imperialism and so on. And of course there's the question of gender balance - out of all surrounding cities, only Santa Clara - one of the smallest cities, arguably not even a real city at all but merely a district of San Jose agglomeration - is named after a woman. On the other hand, we have San Francisco, San Mateo, San Leandro, San Carlos, San Jose, San Gregorio, San Martin, San Bruno... you get the picture. Cats get the same representation in city names in the Bay as women do. How does it look? I think renaming San Francisco should be on the agenda very soon.