"You disagree with the author, in short, about whether the result of shooting someone with any particular caliber of handgun is consistent and predictable." No

"You disagree with the author, in short, about whether the result of shooting someone with any particular caliber of handgun is consistent and predictable." No, I merely don't trust that story! It is literally incredible. Human memory is fallible, conflatable, and we often confabulate unconsciously. Were you to provide a citation then I could research it. Perhaps you will remember the author or title after some pondering. Your AP English classes were not wasted - you're a distractingly excellent writer. But please put down the red fish; you are among friends here (I think).