31 ms·
I guess (hope?) this is actually as a result of some communication failure or refusal behind the scenes. Otherwise it would look pretty rude. Some sort of acco
by toyg 7y ago
I guess (hope?) this is actually as a result of some communication failure or refusal behind the scenes. Otherwise it would look pretty rude.
Some sort of accompanying commentary from OIDF people, explaining the reasoning behind the letter, would be appreciated.
- iamnotacrook 7y agoIt looks weird either way. "Use the OpenID Connect Self Certification Test Suite to improve the interoperability and security of Sign In with Apple." Give us a bunch of money and maybe we'll let you join our little group and you can have our mark of quality that you are now secure. Wow, really? Thanks. It's a little like a lot of the spam I get as an Android developer from "marketers" and just general weirdos trying to get rich off my hard work.
- iddan 7y agoUnlike “marketers” a certificate of compatibility is mandatory for many development teams to use an external technology
- icebraining 7y ago> my hard work. But it's mostly not their work - Apple's protocol is basically a bad implementation of OpenID Connect.
- reaperducer 7y agoI expect that if Apple said it "forked" OpenID, then the HN community would be OK with it. It's all about the optics.
- eecc 7y agoIt’s been a couple weeks since I’ve seen this “optics” being thrown around in comments here. Why you keep using this term when the more appropriate one would be “perspective”?
- reaperducer 7y agoI don't know that I "keep" using that word. I suspect you've seen someone else also using it. But the reason is because "optics" and "perspective" don't mean the same thing.
- jogux 7y agoThe certification suite is open source software (produced by the OpenID Foundation mostly at their cost) and entirely free to use: https://github.com/openid-certification/oidctest https://github.com/openid-certification/oidctest Apple are absolutely 100% free to run the tool and fix any issues found without any payment to anyone except their own engineer's time. (There is a fee to pay for the 'OpenID Certified' logo and to be listed as certified, but in my opinion just running the free tool and fixing any interoperability issues is a major benefit by itself.)
- will4274 7y agoI dunno. It's also pretty weird to borrow 95% of a spec, miss out on a half dozen important security features, not acknowledge the relationship between your work and the spec, and not contribute back to the community that funded the spec.
- toyg 7y agoIt's very "pirate of Silicon Valley", i.e. very old-school Apple: "so sue me". Regardless, the right answer is to engage privately first, to see why they missed that 5% and if there is any way to find agreement, not to go pedal-to-the-metal with public shaming.
- CydeWeys 7y agoAs someone who's tried to contact Apple before, posting publicly is about the only thing that would ever work. Good luck getting in contact with anyone there who'll speak to you. They're worse than most other companies, and most other companies are already quite bad.
- toyg 7y agoIn that case, a simple line saying "we tried to contact you to no avail" would have avoided looking rude.
- CydeWeys 7y agoI just don't get why you're so stuck on this one point on etiquette. To me, saying "We tried to contact you to no avail" is ruder than omitting the line.
- toyg 7y agoAn open letter is obviously not a communication to the recipient, but to the public. It's a rhetorical exercise you use so that the public will put pressure on the counterpart; hence it has to win the public to your side. In order to have the public on your side, you have to be as clear as possible about your motives and your methods - otherwise you'll get people questioning them, which is exactly what you can see in this thread. That's a fail. A simple paragraph saying "we tried to engage with you but could not because X" would have made the writer more sympathetic to the public, imho, and avoided most of the challenges you see here. If that looks rude to the counterpart, it doesn't really matter; everyone knows any politeness is fundamentally insincere anyway, because if one had not wanted to ruffle their feathers, one wouldn't have published anything in the first place.
- kreetx 7y agoYeah, I think there must be more to it than Apple not knowing about OpenID - it was probably deliberate for some reason, would be interesting to know what it was.
- AndrewKemendo 7y agoA good friend is on one of the product teams at Apple that had a recent release around WWDC. Their new product (realitykit) basically made a couple of well known startups in the space irrelevant overnight. So I asked my friend if he knew about these other companies, again all very well known in the specific market for AR developer tools, and he said he didn't and they don't actively look for companies they might be impacting when making product decisions.
- arendtio 7y agoThe difference is that OpenID is not a 'well known startup' but an industry standard and that Apple obviously implemented the well-known protocol 'OpenID Connect' but added some bugs and didn't want to mention that their technology could be compatible with the existing one. And I don't want to downplay the innovative additions Apple made to the whole thing (browser integration etc.), but it doesn't make an honest impression if you don't mention that your revolutionary product is a based on a well-known standard.
- hobofan 7y ago> and didn't want to mention that their technology could be compatible with the existing one Really curious for the reason behind that. If they would've mentioned it there probably would have been quite a bit less of lock-in criticism for the product. But maybe they are also banking on the devs not realizing that they aren't that locked in and have an easy option to move away.
- cmiles74 7y agoI suspect they didn't mention it because they see the lock-in to their product as a feature. Mentioning OpenID might give the impression that Apple would be interested in interoperability (to some degree).
- merb 7y agothey didn't mention it because if they did, they would need to be a member of the openid foundation and pay the 15k$.