5 ms·
Thanks guys for your responses. I just wanted to add a couple things: yes, if I was following what everyone else does (and the user kind of expects) then a) my
by EGreg 16y ago
Thanks guys for your responses. I just wanted to add a couple things: yes, if I was following what everyone else does (and the user kind of expects) then
a) my service won't really stand out in this respect, which may be fine, and
b) the box will be at the bottom, which means the human brain will have to look for it in a variable place, causing far less people to use it than if it was in a fixed place on top -- and causing less initial engagement with the site.
If you notice, youtube did whatever they could to get popular in the beginning, and it worked for them. They were one of the first web 2.0 companies to be sold for above a billion dollars.
Anyway, back to my point ... if you read email (not in gmail, but in regular email clients) then you usually have conversations in reverse chronological order. Come to think of it, I always feel I have to remind people to "read from the bottom" when I forward an email thread. So perhaps it doesn't lend itself to the best experience.
This seems to suggest that the best experience is indeed: bar on the bottom, infinite scroll going up (or pagination going backwards).
But now I will have the problem of drawing the user's eye to the bottom of the screen. Most chats will initially be empty, so I will just have a large empty space on the top, and a chat textbox on the bottom. What about that? Fine for IRC but not for a website, I think.
- EGreg 16y agoIndeed, what is causing our preference for the bottom these days, that will continue to be important as physical paper, etc. won't have much bearing on chat layout? I think it is: 1) keyboards on phones are on the bottom, so as not to obscure our view of the screen, and we want that textbox to be in line with the keyboard 2) we read from top to bottom, so it is more natural to continue reading this way inter-message and not just intra-message But there is one BIG ONE that seems to really scream "newest on top" for me: On the web, things start at the top This makes sense, because they are documents. And as such, embedding chat in a document seems to demand a large empty space: most of the important site elements (header, etc.) will be on the top, and to see the input box you have to look all the way DOWN. Maybe I just need to come up with an idea to draw the eye there and make people want to type. But what?