4 ms·
MicroG talks to Google servers and uses Google's infrastructure while breaking the terms of service (at least in case of FCM). Same goes with NewPipe - you're
by izacus 7y ago
MicroG talks to Google servers and uses Google's infrastructure while breaking the terms of service (at least in case of FCM).
Same goes with NewPipe - you're using YouTube without actually paying for bandwidth, storage costs or the video author.
So you're not actually getting yourself rid of Google or tracking, you're just using their resources without paying the asking price.
Use other alternatives instead.
- JetSpiegel 7y ago> you're using YouTube without actually paying for bandwidth NewPipe actually saves bandwidth when you listen to audio only. As I recall, it parses the HTML and doesn't download the wasteful video stream, if you want just the audio. Google should thank NewPipe users for their responsible use of their free resource.
- commoner 7y agoSimilar arguments have been employed against ad blocking. Users should be aware of the ramifications of their software decisions, but whether someone should download and use Google Play Services vs. MicroG, YouTube vs. NewPipe, etc. is the user's choice. From a privacy perspective, MicroG and NewPipe are much less intrusive than Google Play Service and YouTube, because the open source apps send less user data to Google.
- izacus 7y agoThat would be fine if they'd be clean reimplementations of an API using their own backends. But advertising services which abuse SaaS infrastructure of a company is just not ok, especially in an article that's all about not using anything from Google. I'd feel similarly about having someone advertise a way to crack Slack enterprise features instead of using something like Matternmost.
- bennofs 7y agoBut using FCM is enforced by apps. If they would roll their own, no app would work.
- izacus 7y agoNot on LineageOS or any other ROM you have MicroG installed on.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> But advertising services which abuse SaaS infrastructure of a company is just not ok A nitpick, but somewhat important: they're not services, they're products. Pieces of software. Alternative user agents. Very opinionated web browsers, if you like.
- bubblethink 7y agoNewpipe is literally doing what the browser does, which is fair. The rest of the argument boils down to ad blocking. If you are a stickler, you could use youtube in a browser and get the ads.
- cameronbrown 7y agoBlocking ads is ultimately irrelevant for me. I pay for YouTube Premium, however I get that most don't.
- izacus 7y agoYeah, I don't see the issue if you're paying for YT. But I'm still not a fan of having guides on how to essentially avoid paying for use of SaaS services. It's not unlike piracy.
- autoexec 7y ago> Same goes with NewPipe - you're using YouTube without actually paying for bandwidth, storage costs or the video author. > So you're not actually getting yourself rid of Google or tracking, you're just using their resources without paying the asking price. I love newpipe. I block ads on my desktop, I'm not going to feel bad blocking them on my phone. Google has taken far too much from us, from me, for me to worry about their bandwidth or storage costs. Somehow I think the multinational billionaires will manage. As for video creators (who themselves are regularly screwed over by Google) they should be supported using other channels.
- kbit 7y agoYeah, ads are a terrible and unsustainable business model anyways. I think it's much better (both for the creator and for the business and community in general) to support YouTubers you like through something like Patreon.
- realusername 7y ago> MicroG talks to Google servers and uses Google's infrastructure while breaking the terms of service (at least in case of FCM). Depending the country where you are based it might not matter, it might fall into interoperability legal exceptions.
- yyyk 7y agoNewPipe is technically no different than using a web browser which isn't Google's to browse YouTube, and that's still allowed. If Google wants to turn YouTube into a closed garden, they can go ahead - I can think of no better move to spur competition.
- paulddraper 7y agoIt's not though, according to the terms of service
- yyyk 7y agoWhat ToS has NewPipe been violating? I've read the ToS[0] and it seems that NewPipe is perfectly complaint. It accesses YouTube via "the video playback pages of the Website" so it satisfies 5.1 article C. I don't see any limitation to using browsers there. Indeed, article H strongly implies that it is allowed to use non-browser software to access these pages - otherwise spiders and robots would be banned and there would be no point to the request limit in that article. [0] https://www.youtube.com/static?template=terms https://www.youtube.com/static?template=terms
- paulddraper 7y agoI believe the most relevant section is 4.F. > If you use the Embeddable Player on your website, you may not modify, build upon, or block any portion or functionality of the Embeddable Player, including but not limited to links back to the YouTube website.
- yyyk 7y ago5.1. Article G? NewPipe isn't a website, so this shouldn't apply.
- mindslight 7y ago> So you're not actually getting yourself rid of Google or tracking, you're just using their resources without paying the asking price. Google's asking price includes performing invasive surveillance. So when dodging Google's surveillance, it is impossible to access any content hosted at Google while living up to your standard. Which makes your argument a bit dishonest. Now sure, there is a straightforward argument that the best way to push back against Google is to completely avoid content hosted there, which discourages others from hosting there in the first place. But you did not make this argument, I suspect because it's overly optimistic in an environment of heavy network effects.