3 ms·
"In my opinion we need Europe and other countries to begin heavily fining companies skirting their responsibilities" Well, the cliche when stuff like this happ
by perl4ever 7y ago
"In my opinion we need Europe and other countries to begin heavily fining companies skirting their responsibilities"
Well, the cliche when stuff like this happens is that the company diverted too much money to stock buybacks, dividends, and so on, leaving their actual business operations starved for resources. So, sounds reasonable, but how then does diverting more money to more external entities cause them to do better? I'm not arguing against it, I just don't understand what the rationale is. I think it's unwise to try to punish an abstract entity without thinking carefully about how it will affect the actual people involved.
- mulmen 7y agoYou don’t think there is a difference between a stock buyback and a fine?
- salawat 7y agoA stock buyback decreases external liability. It may decrease liquidity for the company, but the asset tied up in that Stock is still retained, and remaining stocks increawe in share value accordingly. This can increase liquidity in the long run, by stimulating demand whilst supply dwindles. It all depends on the Market. The fine, to my understanding, extracts liquidity whilst also leaving all existing liabilities intact. It "sets the company back'. As it were. At least, that's how it works to my meager understanding. If that isn't, could you go into detail about what really happens?
- mulmen 7y agoThat is my understanding as well. The GP suggested that fines would be ineffective because resources were “spent” on stock buybacks. I asked for clarification of the GP’s understanding of the difference between buybacks and fines.
- perl4ever 7y agoI do not care to argue the consequences of stock buybacks, because I was just referring to a commonly held opinion, not endorsing it. If you want to dispute how it works, could you please not frame it as a vague argument with me.
- salawat 7y agoWasn't framing it in an argumentative manner. What was written seemed to be phrased in a way that indicated the author had an expectation of the existence of a shared context, not in need of articulation. I offered an articulation of what I've come across through research to be the eventual outcome of a stock buyback, and how it differs from a fine, along with some encouragement to share what knowledge you may have that contradicts it. It's not the first time I missed the bus on some common understanding after all, and I don't mind learning something new.
- perl4ever 7y agoI mean, pretty much everything that you can compare is similar in some respects and different in others. Of course I don't think there is no difference between a stock buyback and a fine; that would be stupid.