13 ms·
Oakland’s Pothole Vigilantes address gaping problem, one road crater at a time
- HillaryBriss 7y agonone of the local politicians in this article express any embarrassment or shame over their city's failure to maintain the streets in good working order
- wilg 7y agoWell, they did say that that there is a $100 million road improvement fund and some kind of "pothole blitz". I'd rather hear a plan than an apology I guess.
- jdavis703 7y agoOakland has been a tough place, and one of the things this has meant is we really don’t have a big budget. A lot of people are seeing the SF/SV wealth pouring in, but because a lot of land is still being taxed at levels from 10-40 years ago the city isn’t getting that money. That means we’re getting the government services of several decades ago. This is an issue for a lot of other California cities beside Oakland — and the 2020 split roll ballot initiative will give Californians a chance to better fund our government. Further our new transit department, OakDOT, is doing creative work with a limited budget. They’re taking the MVP approach to rolling out better infrastructure, while also being one of the first DOTs to prioritize equity in terms of who gets access to limited transit funds first.
- SandersAK 7y agoIt's not the funding that is the problem. It's a cultural issue inside of OakDOT and the city gov't. Oakland has $600m ready for transport projects: https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/Oakland-s-plan-to-improve-roads-stuck-in-a-rut-13701540.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/Oakland-s-plan-t... They say they can't hire people, even with those budgets and with residents wanting to help / collaborate.
- gedy 7y agoLikely because they'd have to be unionized and pensioned, which they probably can't afford long term.
- viraptor 7y agoShould they? Doing this work officially has a large overhead. At their level they need to plan for the current + future work and covering whole areas effectively rather than fixing single issues. Taking one-off workers like people from the article do would be a bureaucracy hell. Not defending the bad state of the road. But if they do the best they can with the available budget and get as much of it allocated as they can... should they be ashamed? And ashamed of what - state funding? government? money allocation? Or maybe they're actually bad at their jobs. But from this article is hard to tell.
- stellar678 7y agoThe current crop of local politicians are not to blame - it’s squarely the fault of generations of politicians and voters who severely overbuilt road systems without a plan to fund maintenance. We should tear out 50% of our asphalt and replace it with dense housing - there’s a shocking number of giant, underutilized roads that are large enough to accommodate entire buildings. That’s how you increase density and actually fund your infrastructure.
- sxates 7y agoAre you talking about oakland specifically or American cities generally? I don't really think this applies to oakland, which was built out 50-100 years ago and has almost no new roads in the last several decades. Maintenance was deferred here for way too long, and now it's going to take a long time and a lot of money to get caught up.
- HillaryBriss 7y ago> severely overbuilt road systems without a plan to fund maintenance I've heard this before (in Los Angeles), but what I don't quite get about this explanation is: how did they have enough money to build the roads in the first place, back in the days when Oakland had a smaller population and tax base? Also, does it actually cost more money to maintain the roads then to build them in the first place (really not sure, maybe it does)?
- neonate 7y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20190629020151/https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/Oakland-s-Pothole-Vigilantes-address-gaping-13899311.php https://web.archive.org/web/20190629020151/https://www.sfchr...
- joncrane 7y agoWe need one of these for each borough of the Washington DC area.
- anigbrowl 7y agoYou're probably gonna need a lot more of them soon https://www.apnews.com/2e98f1c80ef9449fa1d4a95ff63258c0 https://www.apnews.com/2e98f1c80ef9449fa1d4a95ff63258c0
- MrMorden 7y agoThe city council needs to be replaced with people who aren't quite as crooked. Fortunately, the FBI is actively working on this problem. One down, seven to go.
- cwkoss 7y agoThe vigilantes should sue Oakland for expenses at the end of the year, would make for a hell of a case, particularly if they can demonstrate safety and quality at lower cost than govt would have spent.
- tantalor 7y agoThat's absurd. They are not owed anything. The city has no contact with them. What they ought to do is pay a bounty per job, and bond the "vigilantes" against injury/damage.
- sneak 7y agoYour first paragraph would make sense if they were not required to pay city taxes.
- AstralStorm 7y agoLiterally, if someone is hurt, the city has the sovereign immunity. You cannot even start a tort here. The only option, besides voting, is to protest or ultimately remove such officials by force. So, where does the repair budget go? Excuses that it's too low are just that, excuses, since people apparently would do it for free.
- fuzz4lyfe 7y agoWhen you pay close to half your income in taxes and recieve few services other than roads I don't think it's fair to say that you aren't owed anything.
- rangeofmotion 7y agoOakland is a disaster. If I recall correctly, someone from the U.N. went to Oakland a year or two ago and declared a humanitarian crisis or something to that effect. I remember the wording was quite strong, saying that it matched conditions in third world countries they've been to which are in crisis. How people can just step right past so many homeless people and so much obvious city disrepair and human brokenness for years on end is beyond me. Yet Oakland and nearby Berkeley are home to a lot of people who are considered "progressive" and "caring" and who supposedly want a better world. If you can't achieve positive results for the people in your immediate vicinity (which the people of Oakland and Berkeley very much have the power to do, especially with things as simple as potholes), then do you get to count yourself as a person who can say they are working towards a better world? Thumbs up for these so-called vigilantes. They talk less and act more. I just hope they don't let the mayor co-opt their efforts by letting her go around saying she's all about it.
- m463 7y agoI remember reading a story by a motorcyclist who had ridden around the world. He had ridden through the most inhospitable places - some because of nature, some because of warfare. I believe he was going through a US city and slept under a tree with his bike parked nearby, and he was woken and told it was too dangerous to do that. I thought it was Oakland, (but I might have misremembered and it was some other dangerous urban area).
- ahelwer 7y agoYeah, well... my parents won't let me walk home after dark in my tiny Canadian home town because it's "too dangerous", while it is objectively two orders of magnitude less dangerous than the large American city in which I now live (and routinely walk around after dark). People exaggerate danger, I've found.
- bacon_waffle 7y agoI've spent many months cycling and walking throughout the US, mainly in the 2000s; it was striking to me to learn how scared some people are of the world around them. I could imagine your story playing out anywhere - someone saying "it's too dangerous to do that here", doesn't actually mean much about the actual danger.
- cameronh90 7y agoAlso see Britain's vigilante pothole superhero, "Wanksy": https://www.telegraph.co.uk/men/the-filter/11570595/Meet-the-man-using-penises-to-fill-potholes.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/men/the-filter/11570595/Meet-the...
- justnotworthit 7y agoThat city council sure hates it when someone makes them look stupid. I like how that guy claims that children will be dramatized by crude drawings of a penis. Does he know that half of those children have a real one and aren't traumatized?
- m463 7y agoWhen Elon Musk got the boring company going, I couldn't help wondering why there weren't entreprenuers in paving. Why don't we have giant computer-controlled machines that go down roads, suck them in and grind them up and spit out new roads behind themselves -- as the defacto paving scenario? I know they do this sometimes. But why not all the time? Instead of pothole fixing, just fix the entire road. Cheap road machines, drive the price down. And put down lane markings and reflectors as part of the process. And do every thing only at night.
- zrobotics 7y agoBecause stubbornly asphalt and concrete take time to pour. Plus, there is a significant amount of work just in repairing the subgrade, otherwise the newly-finished road surface will just heave and buckle. And we do have paving entrepreneurs, they open and operate paving companies.
- m463 7y agoOk, I'll settle for computer-controlled pothole fillers. Like that putter in caddyshack.
- reaperducer 7y agoThis exists, but it's only good for "cold patch," meaning temporary fixes.
- jjoonathan 7y agoDumb question: if you reduce the cost of temporary fixes enough, does that become a good permanent strategy? I'd imagine best practices are currently designed with a large per-issue overhead in mind. Getting men & material to a given location is expensive, so fixes need to last. If you have a robot that doesn't mind finding & resurfacing the same damn pothole every time it rains, would that compete?
- 7y ago
- nathanvanfleet 7y agowhy blame individual residents for the government's disfunction?
- m0llusk 7y agoThe math here says more about America's road addiction than anything else. Oakland has an unusually large mileage of roads which are unusually broad. Additionally many of these roads are on unstable hillsides. The reality is that even if Oakland were hugely wealthy and efficient with its resources then there would still be a problem. Treating road repair like some kind of moral issue clouds the real costs.
- rangeofmotion 7y agoI don't know which roads the vigilantes are focusing on. But my guess is they aren't concerned with the less frequently used roads on the hillsides. They're probably more concerned with the ones that should be obvious to city officials to fix sooner rather than later. The ones that impact people significantly near the higher concentrations of homes and places of business. The road conditions in Oakland have been this way for decades. And whenever you talk about a problem like this in Oakland, it calls forth the general condition of Oakland, which very much is a moral problem (both due to the alleged corruption that keeps it from changing as well as the fact that you can barely enter the city without being confronted by extreme poverty and people with severe mental health problems who are just left behind). The holes in the road have at least one thing in common with the overall state of the city: neglect.
- reaperducer 7y agoIn Chicago they just fill the potholes with pickled peppers and onions. No, really: https://chicago.suntimes.com/2019/4/29/18621740/this-wgn-anchor-filling-a-pothole-with-giardiniera-is-the-most-chicago-thing-ever https://chicago.suntimes.com/2019/4/29/18621740/this-wgn-anc...
- droithomme 7y agoHarry Tuttle is busy.
- dredmorbius 7y agoHere's your receipt, and my receipt for your receipt.
- snarfy 7y ago. “If someone gets hurt on the repair you made, you’re opening yourself to liability.” What if someone gets in a car wreck because of a pothole? Is the city liable?
- justnotworthit 7y agoThe arguments against them were absurd. Essentially: (1) Don't help people if there's a chance the broken justice system hangs you for it. (2) Don't help people unless you can help everyone. (3) Don't help because thinking about how the government is failing at one of its primary jobs makes us feel bad and makes the government look like it's failing at one of its primary jobs.
- MrMember 7y agoI don't know about Oakland but in Minneapolis the city will pay for damage caused by potholes. They are also very quick to patch roads after the spring thaw, normally within a day or two.
- jeffrallen 7y agoGit 'er done!
- dole 7y agoI'm sure other vigilantes have been doing this for longer, but this seems like one of the major initial instigators of the movement: https://www.citylab.com/equity/2017/03/portland-anarchists-want-to-fix-your-streets-potholes/519588/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2017/03/portland-anarchists-w...