3 ms·
New at top + box at top => more, usually less relevant (often worse) comments. Indeed, YouTube comments work this way, even though they've tried to dilute the
by gojomo 16y ago
New at top + box at top => more, usually less relevant (often worse) comments.
Indeed, YouTube comments work this way, even though they've tried to dilute the sewage a bit by highlighting a few highly-rated comments at top.
I'm still a fan of newest-on-top, but this is a cautionary observation. Perhaps there's some way to have the 'box in middle' – or displaying alongside as soon as you've read enough of the log to avoid the most boneheaded, repetitive comments.
- Groxx 16y agoI personally like in-line comments, where the box appears wherever you want it. It heavily encourages threads, but most people communicate that way anyway. You can then sort the threads however you like, and filter out bad ones (a la Slashdot), and hide when they get too deep, as it's probably just a chat between a couple people then. Hm. Anyone be interested in an extension for an in-line reply box for HN? I could probably add it to Flattehn, though it'll take a while.