3 ms·
The general results I tend to see, with a bit of my theories as to why: New at top + box at top => more, usually less relevant (often worse) comments. Because
by Groxx 16y ago
The general results I tend to see, with a bit of my theories as to why:
New at top + box at top => more, usually less relevant (often worse) comments. Because people are more likely to leave a comment and less likely to read others' first.
New at top + box at bottom => fewer, varying quality. Because people are less likely to comment at all. Where there are few comments, they tend to be pretty good; where there are a lot, nobody reads them all, and you get the same as above. And a bit of annoyance at having to scroll past things to get to the box (is this necessarily bad, though?)
New at bottom + box at bottom => fewer, threadier comments, varying quality. People think more like forums. You're also setting yourself up for "fp!", as those stay at the top forever. Similarly, good comments only rarely get a chance to be read by anyone.
New at bottom + box at top => worst of all worlds. Lots of comments, nobody reads, and people get frustrated because theirs never gets seen, leaving the world to the loud and annoyed and nobody else.
---
All that said: new at bottom + box at bottom anywhere you intend to have communication. Twitter is both-top because it's not a bi-directional communication platform; it's a shoutbox. The newest stuff matters, and yours is the newest. Focus decreases as you scroll down, and as things get older.
Most chat systems are both-bottom, because you can read conversations like a book, and add yours logically close to where it will appear, and where the likely-most-relevant things are (newest in a thread = likely most relevant to your comment). Focus likely increases as you go down, as things get more relevant; a downside to long-running threads if you have to reload the page, but no real problem if it updates in place.
Choice here can have a pretty profound impact on how people approach and use your system. What do you want it to be used as?
- gojomo 16y agoNew at top + box at top => more, usually less relevant (often worse) comments. Indeed, YouTube comments work this way, even though they've tried to dilute the sewage a bit by highlighting a few highly-rated comments at top. I'm still a fan of newest-on-top, but this is a cautionary observation. Perhaps there's some way to have the 'box in middle' – or displaying alongside as soon as you've read enough of the log to avoid the most boneheaded, repetitive comments.
- Groxx 16y agoI personally like in-line comments, where the box appears wherever you want it. It heavily encourages threads, but most people communicate that way anyway. You can then sort the threads however you like, and filter out bad ones (a la Slashdot), and hide when they get too deep, as it's probably just a chat between a couple people then. Hm. Anyone be interested in an extension for an in-line reply box for HN? I could probably add it to Flattehn, though it'll take a while.