9 ms·
Uggh. RedHat has a long history now of replacing working stuff with half baked, regressed-by-design replacements. I’d really like to have a working Unix envir
by hedora 7y ago
Uggh. RedHat has a long history now of replacing working stuff with half baked, regressed-by-design replacements.
I’d really like to have a working Unix environment, and Linux stopped being that for me years ago.
More conservative alternative distros keep bit rotting due to upstream (usually RedHat induced) breakage. (SystemD, Wayland, DBUS, PulseAudio, Gnome 3, kernel API brain damage, etc)
Does anyone know of any alternatives? Is there a distro/foundation that will actually support open source Unix moving forward (BSD, maybe?)
- cyphax 7y agoIf you want the most BSD-like distro, it's probably gotta be Slackware. It changes little between releases (just newer versions of the software it ships with mostly).
- hedora 7y agoI’m worried that, with core dependencies like X11 being abandoned, the writing is on the wall for the hold-out distributions (I run Devuan and OpenBSD mostly). I get that it doesn’t make business sense for RedHat to maintain parts of the open source ecosystem that will never drive consulting or support revenue, but that doesn’t change the fact that I want a computing environment that just works (including software that’s been stable for a decade, and isn’t constantly ported to the new shiny).
- wmf 7y agoYou want it, but you aren't willing to pay what it costs to maintain it.
- derefr 7y agoConsider: what would it mean for an OS to be "stable for a decade" in the face of generational hardware changes? For example: we have 4K monitors now, and 8K monitors soon. OSes before ~2010 didn't really support DPI scaling (with mixed-DPI display layouts, etc.), because we didn't have those monitors; but now we do. OSes had to add DPI scaling support throughout the whole stack to support these monitors in the way people expected. This required a nontrivial rearchitecting of the components of some OSes, because they had been built in a world where you rendered e.g. fonts by caching fixed bitmap tile-handles with the (non-DPI-aware) pixel size of the font as the key. In the case where you have two monitors of differing DPI plugged in, that cache spits out wrong tiles for at least one of your monitors. So, what would you expect this "stable" OS to do when you plug an 8K monitor into it? Or, another example: touchscreen tablet support, implemented by pen and gesture input events becoming the lower-level input-event stream, and pointer events being reimplemented on top of them. What would you expect your stable OS to do if you installed it on a tablet? Sometimes, OSes have to rearchitect things. The reason is not always "FEATURE: now written in a cool new language!"; sometimes it's "BUG: it just doesn't got-dang work to do things this way any more."
- iso-8859-1 7y agogot-dang? Is this atheist slang?
- chousuke 7y agoThis is a bit off-ropic, but I'll answer anyway. Out of curiosity, why would you associate it with atheism? Since many (most?) Christian denominations believe it's forbidden to curse in God's name, it's actually more likely to have theistic origins. I don't think it's a signal either way as to belief or nonbelief, though. It's more likely to just be a part of their vernacular. Finally, as an atheist I can tell you that I have no need to avoid using the word "god". What's it going to do, cause a god to pop into existence if I say the name thrice? :) That would certainly be interesting.
- xeeeeeeeeeeenu 7y agoSlackware's release cycle is way too slow and it gets slower with each release. The current stable version (14.2) was released three years ago and it doesn't support modern hardware. Additionally, due to a bug in the installer, it's impossible to install it on NVMe drives. Also, I don't understand why does it ship with KDE4 instead of Plasma 5. Even in -current it's still the case.
- xorcist 7y agoSlackware-current is very usable as a day-to-day machine. It hasn't been broken in years.
- clarry 7y ago> If you want the most BSD-like distro, it's probably gotta be Slackware. As someone who's used OpenBSD for more than a decade.. no, I do not find Slackware to be BSD-like at all.
- lmm 7y agoFreeBSD works pretty nicely, though of course you're still subject to RedHat-induced breakage of Gnome etc.
- ainar-g 7y agoI've been experimenting with OpenBSD, and it's been pretty nice. The code is beautiful, and a lot of stuff just works. Not sure how it will behave on a laptop though.
- hedora 7y agoI think it would be great on the right laptop. Most of the OpenBSD developers use thinkpads, from what I can tell. It wouldn’t fly at work for me at the moment, and I don’t do much computing at home, so I played around with it a bit on a laptop, but didn’t switch. The results were encouraging, though. My biggest beef with it right now is the upgrade story, but that’s because I need to update my router (through a serial console!) and am afraid of what happens if I brick it.
- ryacko 7y agoOnly reason why hybrid kernels and Linux is popular is the stable driver API, otherwise recompilation is necessary (which was new to me when I discovered it). OpenBSD is suited for simple workstations or as a tablet substitute, but I don't think the OpenBSD desktop will quite take off, unless driver developers will return to releasing obfuscated code.
- muricula 7y agoLinux doesn't have a stable driver ABI: https://github.com/torvalds/linux/blob/master/Documentation/process/stable-api-nonsense.rst https://github.com/torvalds/linux/blob/master/Documentation/...
- CraftThatBlock 7y agoThat is for in kernel drivers, as stated. It something breaks in kernel, it just won't compile with the kernel, but user space drivers have great ABI compatibility as stated in the link you provided. Not an expert though, might be wrong but the text makes it pretty clear
- ryacko 7y agoI said API: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linux_kernel#/media/File:Linux_kernel_interfaces.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linux_kernel#/media/File:Linux...
- MisterTea 7y agoOpenBSD Alpine Linux Void Linux (+ Nix package manager) 9front (militant esoterica) I use OpenBSD on my Thinkpad T410i and Void on an older AMD box. You can use vmm to run alpine images to run docker apps or Linux stuff. My only gripe is firefox runs slowish on OpenBSD though chrome doesn't suffer as such. I use both and only chrome if FF cant handle the site im on. 9front's vmx is mature enough to run an alpine VM and then native x client so the vm runs without an x server and the linux applications run in individual windows giving you a seamless 9front/linux desktop that can run a full browser. This route is only for the truly enlightened ones. Unix philosophy isn't about keeping the cruft around but building useful systems using simple tools. The idea is do not duplicate functionality if it already exists. I see so many programs attempt to sidestep dependency hell by baking in functionality. This is the overall communities fault and the fault of modern software development which somehow lost the art of pragmatism. The simple part has been long lost in a sea of complexity driven by ignorance and fueled by greed.
- jakeogh 7y agoand Gentoo.
- cameronbrown 7y agoWould Gentoo not be subject to the effects of dodgy upstream patches too?
- p_l 7y agoUnless you are trying to run software that explicitly depends on some of the brokenness from upstream (Gnome3) you can just setup a classic system that will behave the same way you're used to and honestly, I didn't encounter problems with software in that configuration
- jakeogh 7y agoGentoo tends to maintain out of tree patches (possibly to remove upstream changes), or complete replacements (like eudev/elogind).
- klohto 7y agoCan you provide an example? I’m guessing you’re skewed by the week old article (where RH replacement is better anyway)
- m463 7y agoYou could sort of double-down and try arch. I enjoy using arch linux.
- folkrav 7y agoHe hates systemd. Arch embraces it fully.
- m463 7y agoStrangely that was not clear to me when I first started using arch. Probably because when I got to setting up networking it gave me the choice of the systemd way, or a variety of other ways. But looking at it in relation to init systems it clearly says systemd was chosen. That said, arch still lets you make decisions, unlike most distributions, where you become a consumer of other people's decisions.
- trasz 7y agoSure, FreeBSD. The whole "braindamage" is still available, of course, but you can use anything else if you wish. Everything is conveniently available as both ports and packages, so you don't need to mess with installing things by hand.
- derekp7 7y agoJust to clarify, these complaints are primarily about Fedora specifically -- at least in my experience RHEL (and CentOS) have been very solid. I just wish that Fedora had a model similar to Ubuntu, where periodic releases are targeted for longer term support (i.e., get patches for 2 - 3 years), and all the potentially breaking items go into the inbetween releases.
- hdfbdtbcdg 7y agoI think that is RHEL and CentOs. Fedora is their experimental playground for beta testing. RHEL is their LTS.
- unilynx 7y agoThe biggest difference is probably that they seem to take a 'older' Fedora, and then stabilize it a bit before blessing it as the new RHEL, where Ubuntu just forks off the LTS from their regular release (and where a lot of people seem to wait for the .1 release of the LTS before actually using it)
- hdfbdtbcdg 7y agoAlso not everything makes it from Fedora into RHEL.
- freedomben 7y agoThis is true, but the vast majority does (if you use EPEL and RPM Fusion). I've also had pretty good luck using Fedora rpms from the same era. Gotta stay on top of CVEs tho so you don't end up running a vulnerable application.
- Asooka 7y ago> I’d really like to have a working Unix environment, and Linux stopped being that for me years ago. That ship sailed very, very long ago. The moment the GNU/Linux community decided to implement their own desktops and not copy the standard Unix desktop - CDE, the die was cast. From then on we lost any possibility of having a unified standard desktop and instead we have two competing GUI toolkits neither of which can truly be called native. I am still optimistic that perhaps Wayland will raise the bar for making and maintaining your own DE so high that due to practical considerations we will end up with just one de-facto desktop API.
- ChuckMcM 7y agoNo. There are the xBSD derivatives which continue to aspire to being "unix" like rather than "windows" like. This is probably controversial but my guess here is this; The bulk of the developer cohort doing most of the work in Linux userland these days cut their teeth on Windows, it is their internal standard of a "good developer OS experience" so when they build new things, they have that model as "good" in their mind. The challenge continues to be software. If you are using the packages in FreeBSD (or other xBSD derivatives) it is not uncommon to see "package xyz does not have an active maintainer so it may break, if you're interested in becoming the maintainer go here ..." Not enough people to cover all the things that are pumped into the Linux ecosystem everyday. And it is a bit too much work to re-create the old Sun Microsystems of old where the kernel and the core UNIX user land tools from BSD were combined with a bespoke window system, compiler suite, and hardware specific system libraries to make a product. Granted it was fewer than 1200 software people all told, when SunOS 4.x came out but they were all working for market salaries on the project full time. That's like 10 - 20 million dollars a year, not something you're going to do "for free in your spare time." I'm not really sure how it resolves over time.
- gorio 7y ago> This is probably controversial but my guess here is this; [...] Not so much controversial as I don't understand what it means. Maybe you could give an example of what that would be?
- voldacar 7y agoSystemd is the obvious example, since it is essentially svchost.exe plus tons of other cruft rolled into a blob that started out as an init system.
- gorio 7y agoI don't see it making much of a difference for developer OS experience though? Unless you are specifically developing for example a Linux distribution.
- 7y ago
- nextos 7y agoTry perhaps GuixSD, which is standard GNU stuff sans Systemd. I agree things are getting way less modular, and lots of the components you mention are becoming hard dependencies, which is not good.
- nsajko 7y agoNit: Systemd is not part of the GNU project.
- imiric 7y agoI applaud the design and ideas in GuixSD, but the lack of support for non-free software is a deal-breaker for me. I wish they'd relax this requirement and added an optional official non-free repository with a limited selection of software. A fork with support for non-free repositories would also be great. So far I've seen individual projects that have done this, but seem abandoned[1] or overwhelming[2] for a Lisp newcomer. [1]: https://github.com/guix-users/guix-nonfree https://github.com/guix-users/guix-nonfree [2]: https://github.com/alezost/guix-config https://github.com/alezost/guix-config
- noctuid 7y agoRecently there is https://gitlab.com/nonguix/nonguix https://gitlab.com/nonguix/nonguix
- timClicks 7y agoThe thing is, it takes a lot of resources to do this well and there is not a lot of financial incentive to invest in this area. Canonical gave it a really good shot with Unity and Mir, and received lots of criticism for doing so. If we're going to criticize anyone who does something differently, then we need to accept that the project sponsored by Red Hat is the one that everyone will end up being used.
- shiftoutbox 7y agoAnd to add to that; the bsd’s tend to aspire to be Unix, not a Unix something . While Linux has been hellbent on being a desktop, Mac/Irix/Solaris work alike . Your next supercomputer, the cloud . I am not saying one is better then the other. We just have different goals. If I win the lottery; make my unicorn millions ; or otherwise find a pile of cash ; I am going to start a BSD Unix company . For the sake of choice.
- daurnimator 7y agoArcan http://arcan-fe.com/ http://arcan-fe.com/ is an alternative. Durden (https://github.com/letoram/durden/ https://github.com/letoram/durden/) is a tiling window manager for it.
- enriquto 7y agoI'm daily using voidlinux, slackware and dragonflybsd and they are wonderful unix systems, in very different ways.