7 ms·
I think you have to balance that against not preventing instability around the world. What would it look like if China, Russia, Iran and many others were unche
by mc32 7y ago
I think you have to balance that against not preventing instability around the world. What would it look like if China, Russia, Iran and many others were unchecked and we let them do whatever they wanted...
Now, the current admin is cutting back on involvement. Some candidates call for more interventionism. That we’re retreating from “our duty” to be international police, essentially. So what is it?
- ssijak 7y agoI think you are living inside a big bubble. When was the last time China showed military aggresion outside its borders, especialy on the other side of the world? US doing the “checking” around the world left countless people dead for nothing, and a lot of countries ruined. Not to mention trillions od dollars spent on financing that. US complain about Russia meddling with US elections (through 150k worth of Facebook ads lol) but then proceeds to overturn number of democratically elected governments around the world. Hipocracry much?
- spoovy 7y agoChina is constantly showing aggression in the South China sea, outside of it's borders. Amazing how people can post with such confidence on something they clearly know literally nothing about.
- griffinkelly 7y agoChina is showing force against Taiwan: https://www.scmp.com/news/china/military/article/3004049/taiwan-blasts-china-reckless-and-provocative-fighter-jet https://www.scmp.com/news/china/military/article/3004049/tai... China is building islands all around the South China Sea: https://www.scmp.com/news/china/diplomacy-defence/article/2133483/china-has-built-seven-new-military-bases-south-china https://www.scmp.com/news/china/diplomacy-defence/article/21... China now has a presence in Africa too: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/africa/pentagon-accuses-chinese-blinding-djibouti-based-u-s-pilots-lasers-n871096 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/africa/pentagon-accuses-chinese...
- saiya-jin 7y agoFirst 2 items are about their borders - not that I agree with the actions, but these are completely understandable. The Africa still isn't a proper comparison - building few bases where you invest tons of money and extract crutial resources isn't the point here, bloody invasions that destroy whole region for generations and kill millions innocent are. And this is something specific to US, even Russia didn't do anything comparable. Anything after WWII, maybe but just maybe including Korea is actively adding evil to this world. But I suspect not many americans are willing to accept truth here
- mc32 7y agoSoviet Russia annexing the Baltics and setting up Eastern Europe and Central Asia as client states as well as destabilization in South East Asia, Africa, Latin America & Caribbean you say is in no way similar? Ok!
- griffinkelly 7y agoAsk anyone in Taiwan, they’d have a strong difference of opinion on Taiwan being apart of any piece of China, or within the borders. As for countries being militarily aggressive, and causing direct conflict since WW2, sure the US, but there have been numerous wars since. A few at the top of mind —-First Afghanistan War ( Russia), Battle of Falkland Islands (Argentina), Iran vs Iraq War
- tim333 7y agoSpring / summer 2019 I'd say: >In March, Hanoi lodged a protest with Beijing after a Vietnamese fishing vessel crashed and sank after it was chased by a Chinese maritime surveillance vessel in disputed waters. https://www.inkstonenews.com/politics/once-bitter-rivals-us-and-vietnam-are-now-united-against-china/article/3015156 https://www.inkstonenews.com/politics/once-bitter-rivals-us-...
- ssijak 7y agoYou are comparing one vessel incident in the disputtes waters close to China to countless wars US initiated? I mean you cant be serious. Or if you want to compare incidents... Let me give you just one because Iran is in the news lately. What did the commander of USS Vincennes that downed civilian plane Iran Air Flight 655 killing 290 people including 66 children in 1988 got as punishment? He got Legion of Merit “for exceptionally meritious conduct in the performance of outstanding service as commanding officer...” and the air-warfare coordinator for that day got Navy Commendation Medal. That is just one out of countless exampless..
- tim333 7y agoNo I wasn't comparing them, just pointing out China is active in military aggression trying to grab areas of Vietnam and the Philippine's territories that it feels it should have.
- djohnston 7y agowalked right into that one huh?
- Retra 7y agoThe vast majority of human behavior is hypocrisy if you discard all context and justification for what people do.
- gravy 7y agoI think a) we may have different definitions of "military aggression" and b) China and the US have different "priorities" when it comes to the military.
- bjourne 7y agoNot true. The Trump administration has increased the military budget. https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/03/10/pentagon-eyes-windfall-as-trump-seeks-750-billion-defense-budget-military/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/03/10/pentagon-eyes-windfall-... No one is asking "you" to be world police. Just paying "your" UN membership fees would be plenty.
- mc32 7y agoAre there more of fewer involvements we’re in? Increasing budget can mean active wars or it can mean preparation (modernizing). The UN is a political org, it doesn’t achieve much. It makes a whole bunch of corrupt officials rich.
- Tepix 7y agoI think you have to balance that with the tendency of military to destabilize the world.
- mc32 7y agoYes, true. But my point is sometimes we think in idealist terms where there are no negative effects to completely pulling out from international involvement. Deterrence is good. Running roughshod like Bush and Obama resigned himself to is not good. But completely shutting it down is worse than even that.
- ethbro 7y agoWar destabilizes the world. Sometimes a military causes war, sometimes it prevents it.
- Tepix 7y agoIf you have a lot of weapons and military around, there are usually people who suggest using them as well. Can't be tempted to start a war without an army to match.
- isostatic 7y agoMuch of the world's instability has been caused by the US being unchecked and doing whatever it wanted
- mc32 7y agoAnd you can’t think of what would happen if we just let things happen out there? Yes we’re made monumental mistakes like Arab spring and gulf war II. But those would pale compared to what would happen if we just let things go. All those repressed military desires by dictators everywhere suddenly given a green light.
- salex89 7y agoBeing on the side "kept in check", believe me, we were better off on ourselves. Dictators fall one way or another, 3rd party military intervention is rarely selective and not a bit subtle with the collaterals.
- mc32 7y agoThat’s a difficult position to be in. It’s lose-lose. Dictators can last generations and drive countries needlessly into the ground (Venezuela, Zimbabwe, Cuba, North Korea, etc.) Interventions are blunt instruments (interestingly some US Democrat candidates put forth the idea of intervening in Honduras... Democrats...)
- luckylion 7y ago> It’s lose-lose. The size of the losses aren't the same, though. Saddam was by no means a benevolent Dictator, and he had plenty of people disappear, tortured and executed. But not nearly anywhere close to the number of people that died because of the Regime Change campaign. And don't forget: a dictator usually keeps order. A civil war, ISIS roaming through the no-mans-land etc is much worse than a cruel strongman.
- isostatic 7y agoCuba and Venezuela are both products of U.S. interference North Korea is Soviet (and later China) interference, but the U.S. was involved Zimbabwes problem dates back to Brtitish interference, and now like the rest of Africa is starting to fall under China's influence. Once you interfere, it can take generations to recover
- brlewis 7y ago>you have to balance that against not preventing instability around the world You are absolutely right. This statement is as true as saying you have to balance eating lavish restaurant meals 7 nights a week against letting your children starve. Completely true. However, if you're currently eating lavish restaurant meals 7 nights a week, the direction you need to go in toward balance is obvious. Would you support reducing U.S. military spending from 2-3x that of China (the 2nd highest spender), to 1.5x? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditures#Total_military_spending https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_...
- mc32 7y agoIf it were me, I think we need to be able to fend off the largest rivals convincingly. If Russia and China were to enter the fold and be good world citizens and share a common vision and cooperate, then yeah. We only need to be as strong as the combined strength of our nearest rivals.
- brlewis 7y ago> We only need to be as strong as the combined strength of our nearest rivals. Ah, so you want to cut the U.S. military budget in half, then? I guess we're on the same page.
- hutzlibu 7y ago" We only need to be as strong as the combined strength of our nearest rivals. " So eternal arms race then?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mc32 7y agoNope, reciprocal disarmament.
- 7y ago
- easymodex 7y agoIn my opinion USA is the one that needs to be kept in check, being the self proclaimed world police has left only destruction in it's wake. Covert operations, intelligence gathering is totally fine, but having several military bases in every country with an oil resource and forcing your will on innocent people thousands of miles away from your country is not. You are the aggressor and don't delude yourself otherwise.
- saiya-jin 7y agoAlthough what you say is true, don't expect any change of mindset from US citizens. There is just too much glorification of the evils of the past and present, be it hollywood, most news or basically any mainstream source of information. For every piece of information telling about horrors of war, PTSD, seeing kids/women blown to pieces / doing it yourself, there is 10 pieces talking about proud veterans, patriots, camaraderie etc. I think this behavior is common among us all, us vs the rest. Its jsut that this is so much more obvious if you see it from outside of the bubble. Look at former colonial powers, many citizens of western europe still consider enslaving and raping whole nations for hundreds of years an enlightened period ("but... we build them rails!" or similar is a phrase I heard more than once on this topic). But since we don't have time machine, its hard to say whether US was/is overall the force of good vs evil. Somebody would have to fill up power vacuum otherwise, and trust me, you wouldn't want the communist USSR earlier chinese to run the whole show.