4 ms·
"We allowed China access to our markets, they didnt return the gesture." I would argue that China opened access more than the US did. During the Mao era, it w
by bryanlarsen 7y ago
"We allowed China access to our markets, they didnt return the gesture."
I would argue that China opened access more than the US did. During the Mao era, it was basically impossible for US goods to enter the Chinese market. The converse was not true: Chinese goods could enter the US market. So during liberalization the Chinese opened up more than the US did simply because they had so much further to go.
- arcticfox 7y agoWhile true, that is incredibly irrelevant to any current evaluation of fairness. It seems to reward an unreasonable start state for no reason.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoIf person A is 3 steps away from a goal and person B is 6 steps away and they want to negotiate to get to the goal together, the fair negotiation is that person A takes one step for every 2 steps person B takes. If person A says "I'll walk as fast as you once you catch up to me", person B has no assurance person A is arguing in good faith or ever has any intention of actually taking those steps.
- ThomPete 7y agoNot sure what you mean. The situation defacto is that china and the chinese has free access to our markets while we don't have free access to theirs. The situation is that defacto china is benefitting from their developing nation status outcompeting western companies just on shipping prices. Very few US products enter the chinese market plus those who do are forced to give over their IP.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoAmerican companies have access to the Chinese market. If you go to any major Chinese city, that will be obvious to you pretty quickly. American brands are everywhere. US companies do very well for themselves in the Chinese market. The reason for the trade imbalance is not Chinese protectionism, but rather structural issues in the United States and the Dollar's role as global reserve currency.
- LMYahooTFY 7y ago> American brands are everywhere. Some American brands are everywhere.... Obviously some have been heavily restricted, most prominently internet media companies.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoA lot of American brands are in China. The restrictions are about censorship of information, so they affect Google, Facebook and newspapers. You can still buy Starbucks, Levi jeans, iPhones, Ford automobiles and KFC buckets.
- ThomPete 7y agoI.e the big companies yes those who also have much of their production done in China. Thats not the same as China being open to western companies like the west is to china. And again no IP protection with countless cases of ip theft and forced technology transfer by the mafia run chinese goverment. To claim that the structural problems are US is absurd.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y ago> To claim that the structural problems are US is absurd. The US has a trade deficit with almost all of its trading partners. That is a structural issue. > no IP protection That's a crude caricature. There is IP protection in China. If that weren't the case, American microchip designers would not be making such large licensing fees in China. As far as I understand it, as a non-expert, IP protection in China is actually fairly good for a developing country. > Thats not the same as China being open to western companies like the west is to china. Western brands have much greater penetration in the Chinese market than vice versa. Moreover, much of the American trade deficit with China is actually made up of Western companies doing production in China.
- ThomPete 7y ago>The US has a trade deficit with almost all of its trading partners. That is a structural issue. But has nothing to do with what we are talking about here. It's not a crude caricature. IP protection in china is non existing which anyone who even done a little business in china knows very well. It's litterally one of the biggest criticisms so I am not sure where you are getting your information from, none the less it's incorrect. Chinese don't need their brands to western markets they just need to produce for our markets. The difference is that the west doesn't hinder chinese companies to compete on our markets, china does hinder us competing on theirs.