5 ms·
I suspect that's about international markets. Everyone knows the fuel distributor, or the window heating icon. Not everyone understands "Fuel". (Or did you want
by viraptor 7y ago
I suspect that's about international markets. Everyone knows the fuel distributor, or the window heating icon. Not everyone understands "Fuel". (Or did you want to say "Gas" ;) )
Also do you want to get into a car rented in Europe and find the texts to read (for example) "Włącz", "Rozmrażanie", "Paliwo"?
- WalterBright 7y ago> Everyone knows the fuel distributor, or the window heating icon. No they don't. I've been in a car with a front window defroster and a rear one. The icons are different, but who knows which is which. > Not everyone understands "Fuel" More than understand an inscrutable icon. Besides, anyone can look up Fuel in a dictionary. How do you look up an icon? > "Włącz", "Rozmrażanie", "Paliwo"? Dictionaries are marvelous tools. translate.google.com works great, too. There are no icon dictionaries, especially when everyone copyrights them so every icon is different. If you don't know what the icon means, you're borked. Hey, I'd settle for the wretched icon if underneath it they're write "Defrost". Besides, I've traveled in Poland. I don't know a word of Polish, but had a wonderful time regardless. Everyone I met was very nice.
- tty2300 7y agoThe front window defrost has always been an option on the air con dial and the rear is a button
- BeetleB 7y ago>The front window defrost has always been an option on the air con dial and the rear is a button This hasn't been the standard for a long time. My 2003 and my 2015 cars both have them both as buttons.
- Angostura 7y agoFront window defrost has as icon that is wider at the top than the bottom. The rear window icon is typically a rectangle.
- qlk1123 7y ago> More than understand an inscrutable icon. Besides, anyone can look up Fuel in a dictionary. How do you look up an icon? This makes sense. But I think that's why the unicode consortium adds common gestures/symbols/icons so actively. The icon-recognizing problem you address here is not impossible to fix with some app combining scanner and translator.
- WalterBright 7y agoI'd fix it by using words. Icons are a solution looking for a problem and causing problems.
- HeWhoLurksLate 7y agoGas is a pretty obvious one, because both fuel pumps and gas cans are relatively commonplace. https://duckduckgo.com/?q=fuel+icon&t=h_&iax=images&ia=images https://duckduckgo.com/?q=fuel+icon&t=h_&iax=images&ia=image... It can be fairly simple, I think.
- WalterBright 7y agoIs it obvious, or are you simply accustomed to it? Or is it watch out for the alien with his wiener in his ear?
- HeWhoLurksLate 7y agoOr are you simply accustomed to it? Got me there, I suppose.
- nine_k 7y agoThe funny thing that in US "gas" may mean liquid fuel and not compressed propane.
- Fnoord 7y agoI appreciated your comments throughout this thread. Symbol language works better in the longer term. When there's consensus about the icon functionality, they work. Look at traffic signs in Europe. They barely contain text. In the USA, they contain text all the time. In a large country where the main language is English this makes sense. In a continent consisting of many languages (and tourism), its important to have consensus on symbols instead. What does suck is converting to symbols from text whilst you're used to text. That's the legacy of backwards compatibility.
- kbenson 7y agoSlowly, over decades, we're developing iconography for common operations. Take power buttons, or menu buttons (the "hamburger" icon). It takes not only time, but some amount of consensus and buy in from a significant portion of the marketplace. In the US at least the fuel level indicator is fairly easily recognized by a gas pump symbol, and the temperature gauge is recognized by a thermometer icon. The problem is, these don't denote those things exactly but fuel and temperature in general, and sometimes they are instead dummy lights indicating a warning about high temperature or low fuel, and not where the guages are.
- BubRoss 7y ago> Slowly, over decades, we're developing iconography for common operations. We did that already and called it written language.
- nine_k 7y agoBut this is how Chinese writing works, not like e.g. European written languages work.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoChinese writing works in exactly the same way European written languages work. It records more semantic information than they tend to do, but the functioning is no different.
- WalterBright 7y ago> It records more semantic information than they tend to do Are you sure? When I was in Japan I compared books printed in English with the same books in Japanese. The Japanese versions always had more pages. It looked like while the Kanji characters conveyed more meaning, they were larger and in the net required more space.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago
- BeetleB 7y ago>No they don't. I've been in a car with a front window defroster and a rear one. The icons are different, but who knows which is which. Umm ... I do? For me this was really a "figure out once" and remember forever. And even if I can't remember which is which, it's trivial to press them and find out. Especially if you have the fan/ac running. Perhaps they should make this as an international standard and part of the driving test? I mean, if we can learn what all the road signs mean, this isn't any harder. Edit: Cannot add more comments so replying here: Looking at your comment above, you seem to believe we're transitioning from words to pictographs in cars. My experience doesn't agree. I've never seen a car without these, going back to the 80's. Looking at old Toyota Corollas, they use the icon. Same for the 80's Corvette. Given how prevalent they are, did you ever ponder why they use icons instead of text? Serious question.
- WalterBright 7y ago> For me this was really a "figure out once" and remember forever. When you drive a car rarely, you don't really remember what all the frackin icons mean. Besides, that's why phonetic written languages were invented - so you don't have to memorize 10,000 pictures. Just 26 of them. Phonetic writing really is a great invention. It's better than pictographic languages. Good luck looking up a pictograph on google. What's next? Back to using Roman numerals?
- FroshKiller 7y agoYou open the owner’s manual, look up the section for the relevant bit of dashboard or console in the table of contents, flip to that page, and read the description of the buttons, gauges, and other labeled elements.
- WalterBright 7y agoDoesn't it strike you as bad UI design to have to consult a manual to find out that [squiggle] means "Defrost"? How does that help our international user who cannot understand "Defrost" to be faced with an English manual?
- HighPlainsDrftr 7y agoI am much better at using CLI's than I am using GUI's - just for this reason. Every time I see an icon, I have to think - what is it the person is trying to tell me. Usually, words work much better for me. I know many people that love architecture diagrams. I much prefer to read the words instead of looking at pictures. To me, a word is worth a thousand pictures.
- FroshKiller 7y agoNo. I am accustomed to reading documentation, especially when something isn’t clear to me. Bad UI design for a car would involve icons totally divorced from the physical function and which closely resemble each other. I wonder why an “international user” has bought a car whose manual isn’t localized and who can’t get a localized manual online.
- viraptor 7y ago> Dictionaries are marvelous tools. 1. If you have one. Google translate may also not be available due to lack of data or lack of mobile reception. 2. It assumes you know how to input/lookup the word. It's easier with Latin script. But try the same in Korea / Russia / Thailand / ... Even if you translate into target language you may not find the same version of the word, or just mix up symbols. (Without knowing they're different, what are the chances you'd mix up シ and ツ ?) > There are no icon dictionaries, especially when everyone copyrights them so every icon is different Is this really a thing? Every rear window heating icon I've seen since the 90s looked the same. I did check and can't find an image online from any brand not using that same symbol.
- WalterBright 7y ago> Google translate may also not be available Google translate for icons is 100% not available > know how to input Just use the English word. No problem. English works well on tiny phone keyboards. Always easier than inputting an icon. > Is this really a thing? Here's Apple suing over their copyrighted icons: https://appleinsider.com/articles/12/08/15/top_samsung_designer_denies_copying_ios_icons_while_patent_expert_says_apple_design_patents_should_be_invalidated https://appleinsider.com/articles/12/08/15/top_samsung_desig... And icons are copyrightable: https://slate.com/human-interest/2016/04/the-history-of-the-apple-trash-icon-in-graphic-design-and-lawsuits.html https://slate.com/human-interest/2016/04/the-history-of-the-... I remember when I worked at Symantec we had to create new icons to avoid copyright problems. Every vendor did this.
- viraptor 7y agoI meant icons in cars. I haven't seen variations or copyrights on those. iOS/Apple is a completely different story - they're purpose designed and unique. Symbols in cars are common everywhere. I addressed entering English words before: "Even if you translate into target language you may not find the same version of the word" For example "gas" may not translate into what you expect.
- Retra 7y agoWhy are you willing to use a dictionary to look up a word, but not willing to use a car manual to look up a symbol? Do you throw out your car manuals and replace them with dictionaries or something?
- kalleboo 7y agoI grew up in Europe where car interiors have always used only icons for as long as I've ridden them, and I've never heard of anyone being confused. Same with road signs. First time I visited the US I was amazed by how much text is on your street signs, where only icons would be used in Europe. I recently bought a domestic car in Japan. I had no problems using any features since they all use the same icons that my parents' domestic Swedish 1991 Volvo had that I learned to drive on. If they used kanji words instead I'd be lost. > There are no icon dictionaries, It’s called “the manual”. You clan usually find it in the glovebox, and it doesn’t require a data connection. But in reality you've learned all these symbols by the time you get your drivers license (just like you've learned all the road signs). > especially when everyone copyrights them so every icon is different. Car interior icons are standardized by the ISO https://www.iso.org/standard/54513.html https://www.iso.org/standard/54513.html
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]