4 ms·
The article says the scientists estimate the CO2 reduction due to population decline as 7 to 10 ppm. Yet they claim this caused the Little Ice Age. That doesn't
by pdonis 7y ago
The article says the scientists estimate the CO2 reduction due to population decline as 7 to 10 ppm. Yet they claim this caused the Little Ice Age. That doesn't seem justified; that small a CO2 change doesn't have that much of an impact even on the highest estimates of climate sensitivity (and those highest estimates are known to be too high anyway). For comparison, the CO2 change since the start of the industrial revolution is about 130 ppm.
- codesushi42 7y agoAgreed. The indigenous peoples were not burning fossil fuels either. This signal is pretty weak. The same could be claimed about the Black Death that ravaged Europe.
- pdonis 7y ago> The indigenous peoples were not burning fossil fuels either. They were changing the use of the land, though. The hypothesis appears to be that the land that had been cultivated reverted back to forest, which meant more trees and hence more CO2 uptake. (Though even that could be questioned, since crops also take up CO2, and growing new crops every year might well take up more CO2 than a forest of trees that just grow once and then stay there.)
- bryanlarsen 7y agoCrops get eaten and their straw rots, releasing the CO2 they've sequestered. That happens with trees too, but less completely and over a much larger time scale.
- akvadrako 7y agoI agree it doesn't seem justified, but keep in mind CO2 effects are logarithmic, so ppm is a poor measure. 10 ppm at 200 ppm is as significant as 20 ppm at 400 ppm.
- M2Ys4U 7y ago>The article says the scientists estimate the CO2 reduction due to population decline as 7 to 10 ppm. Yet they claim this caused the Little Ice Age. Did you read a different article to me? Both the UCL scientists and an unaffiliated scientist said there were also natural processes at play, but the reduction in CO2 had a large impact.
- pdonis 7y ago> the reduction in CO2 had a large impact Which doesn't make sense because that small a change in CO2 cannot have a "large impact" given what we know about the sensitivity of the climate to changes in CO2.