6 ms·
the punks were certainly the most health-toxic sub-culture in post-hippy California.. definitely early pain-killer abusers, plus glue or extreme alcohol, etc. n
by mistrial9 7y ago
the punks were certainly the most health-toxic sub-culture in post-hippy California.. definitely early pain-killer abusers, plus glue or extreme alcohol, etc. not uncommon to hear of deaths, treachery or jail.. SF Fab-Mab ruler Dirk was later found to be sexually using adolescents pretty regularly .. lead singer of Fang on America's Most Wanted national TV for killing a girl over heroin, things like that .. freedom has a price ! and if the songs regularly invoke violence and madness, guess what, it actually results in violence and madness.. who would have guessed
- yters 7y agoBut if it is 'rap music' violence, madness, drug use, rape, etc. are fine, because if you say otherwise you are racist. Maybe it is racist to not hold all human beings to the same standard of decency?
- kjeetgill 7y agoThe key difference is that the Punk subculture sprung up around the music, where much of the 'rap music' was reflective (exaggerated and glamorized) of an existing situation and subculture. I think you can still argue that violent rap music incites or inspires crime though. I think you can generally criticize effects, but you skirt the line with racism when you start projecting that too broadly.
- yters 7y agoI don't see the difference. Rap music seems to go hand in hand with the subculture. If it wasn't glamorized, I doubt it'd exist, at least to the degree it does. Same with punk. If the punk lifestyle was not glamorized through the music, then the punk subculture would not exist. My point is that it is racist to not hold all people to the same moral standard, because in effect we are saying those we do not hold accountable are not capable.
- oarabbus_ 7y agoYou are abysmally misinformed on the history of hip hop. >My point is that it is racist to not hold all people to the same moral standard, Ah, in that case you agree that _every_ American slaveowner in the South was a bad, immoral, evil person, right? Same goes for all Germans in WWII.
- yters 7y agoYes...does any sane person today think slave owners and nazis were on the correct side of morality?
- moate 7y agoMinor nit pick: All slaveowners = people who owned slaves = bad ("complicated" at best) All Germans during WWII =/= Nazis. There's plenty of great WWII era Germans who didn't support that Nazis and helped take them down. But yea, fuck Nazis.
- kjeetgill 7y agoNot that I think this is an interesting point to argue (and I'm not sure exactly what you're getting at) but yea every slave owner was bad because we're categorizing them based on the bad act: owning slaves. Not every German was a soldier let a lone a Nazi during WWII. I think there's an Axiom of Choice joke in there somewhere.
- oarabbus_ 7y agoEvery person who buys an iPhone or wears Nikes is immoral and a bad person to a degree, as these products are essentially built upon slave labor.
- yters 7y ago> these products are essentially built upon slave labor. Citation needed. AFAIK, the labor is entirely voluntary and reimbursed. Wages are much lower, but so is cost of living.
- moate 7y agoCool strawman mate. There's plenty of people who call out rap's shortcomings. Some of them are black. You can do it without being called a racist, I swear. I don't know why people are calling you a racist, but I have some theories...
- default-kramer 7y agoDo you also believe that violent video games cause real-world violence? How about movies? Novels?
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoI don't remember punk lyrics focusing on drugs and violence any more than mainstream rock did. (Which, admittedly, was also blamed for those things.) Which bands/songs are you thinking of? I'm assuming you have some in mind, and aren't just parroting stereotypes? Also, are you sure you've got the cause-and-effect right way 'round? Delinquents do seem to like punk, but that doesn't mean that punk made them delinquent.
- jyrkesh 7y agoThe way I read his comment, the music "invokes" the violence via live shows. If you've ever been to a punk show, there's a lot of violence going on in the audience/pit. I don't think it's a crazy leap to say that people who enjoy beating the crap out of each other in a sweaty pit might be disproportionately inclined towards beating people up outside that pit.
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoHuh, you think that's it? They're actually saying "mosh pits make you a violent druggie"? That's...actually even sillier, honestly. I fuckin' loved a good mosh when I was a teen, and I was a kid who never, ever started a fight, and froze up when someone started one with me. I know the pit looks like a brawl, but at every show I went to it was more like a contact sport with no points where everyone wins. If someone fell down, everyone who saw it gathered to help them up and keep folks from tripping until they were back on their feet. One time a flailing dude caught me in the face with an elbow so hard I staggered and saw stars. He immediately stopped, grabbed my shoulders, and yelled, "dude, are you okay?" He waited for me to nod before he smiled and went back to doing his thing. It was all good. I know there's guys out there who jump in the pit throwing fists. I can't speak for every scene, but where I come from those guys got shoved out of the pit until they got the point. It's not about winning.
- mustacheemperor 7y agoI read the post to suggest correlation, not causation. To your other points, a close friend of mine loved to mosh as a younger man too, and at his last warped tour he tripped and fell. Unlike the shows you described, everyone who saw it kept jumping and smashing into each other for minutes while his companions struggled to get him to his feet. His head was beaten into the ground repeatedly by people's feet, fracturing his skull. He's still physically scarred and cognitively not the same and years later it seems like that will linger forever. I wanted to share this counterpoint to your post because I think there is validity to your perspective but it is not fully reflective of reality.
- germanlee 7y agoMore of the neverending pro-censorship authoritarian journalistic nanny-style comments. If what you said was true, violent crime wouldn't be dropping so precipitously. https://www.statista.com/statistics/191219/reported-violent-crime-rate-in-the-usa-since-1990/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/191219/reported-violent-... In the era of violent games, gangsta rap, neverending wars, etc, violent crime is dropping. But you are correct. Freedom has a price. That's what makes freedom so valuable. People have the freedom to make mistakes.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- coding123 7y agoHere is the price - specifically: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_incarceration_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_incarceration_ra...
- noonespecial 7y agoOr maybe they're just violent and mad so they sing about it.
- mistrial9 7y agoyes! I dont think many of these other "outraged" commentators have been sucker-punched or tripped hard at a Black Flag show !! its a complicated thing here, psychological mirror and projection (in the psycho-analytic sense), reinforcement in art, social peer pressures, set and setting, permission by default, enabling behaviors .. many factors. For anyone who lives freedom (and survives it), it is all the more important to see clearly what is happening in the chains of cause-and-effect, dont you think? instead of romanticizing things, clinging to pure outrage or self-righteous statements, attacking a messenger, etc..
- PhasmaFelis 7y ago> yes! I dont think many of these other "outraged" commentators have been sucker-punched or tripped hard at a Black Flag show !! I did ask which songs/bands you were thinking of that promote violence. You haven't answered so far.
- zrobotics 7y agoBlack flag is a band, so your parent already answered your question in the part of the comment you quoted.
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoYeah, I know, but I was hoping for something more substantial than "I got hit a couple times at Black Flag shows."
- stallmanite 7y agoYou might enjoy the positive messages purveyed by bands like Operation Ivy. Edit: Freeze Up and Artificial Life are two tracks from the late 80s containing very prescient and IMO insightful commentary re: man, society, and technology that many on HN could probably appreciate. It was really hard to resist just spamming the lyrics here but hopefully my description will resonate enough that some readers will check it out. They have something to say and get right to the point. It’s the complete opposite of vacuous.
- moate 7y agoI know right? I feel like Greg Graffin, Henry Rollins and some of the other guys from that Era of Cali-Punk made some pretty great points in between all the screaming and yelling.
- peterwwillis 7y agoI was shocked - shocked, I tell you! - to find out that people who wear razor blades on necklaces, get drunk, do front flips onto each other, scream about authority figures, and throw fists while they dance, might have attracted some anti-social people.