4 ms·
It’s worth noting that even though walking is far more common in Europe, and streets are generally narrower, and in older cities, there aren’t sidewalks, but pe
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
It’s worth noting that even though walking is far more common in Europe, and streets are generally narrower, and in older cities, there aren’t sidewalks, but pedestrians share the roadway with cars. Despite these factors, Europe now has a lower pedestrian death toll per capita than the US.
We walk less, but we die more.
I think it's because of these factors, not despite them. We die more because pedestrian traffic has dropped so low that drivers no longer look for foot traffic.
I have lived without a car more than a decade. Driver's frequently are shocked to notice me. I do all I can to catch their eye and make sure they see me. Otherwise, they just make their turn/ go through the crosswalk like I don't exist.
- linuxftw 7y agoI've had the same experience. I never cross in a crosswalk with a turning car without the driver first acknowledging me. People turning right on red without stopping has almost struck me before as well. You have to be super vigilant in the US when walking or you're going to get killed.
- vkou 7y agoOn my trip to work today, I observed a chap stopping traffic to jaywalk across a street to get in his car. A minute, and half a block down, I saw him honking at a pedestrian, who was crossing an intersection on the walk sign. There's an amazing bit of cognitive dissonance that happens when your run-of-the-mill moron climbs behind the wheel of a vehicle.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoShitty pedestrians make shitty drivers and vise versa. Sounds pretty reasonable and obvious to me.
- itronitron 7y agoI think the primary reason for Europe being safer for pedestrians is that the speed limits are much lower. On roads with sidewalks, the speed limit is typically 30kph to 50kph, which is 18mph to 31mph. So pedestrians have more time to hear cars, and drivers have more time to see pedestrians and stop if needed. Other factors... there is no right turn on red, most cars are manual transmission, drivers have to be more alert in order to not hit oncoming traffic, etc.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI've lived in Europe. There are plenty of differences, so of course you can't blame any one thing. But I also grew up in America and walking was far more common here when I was growing up. When an activity starts to go extinct, myriad forms of seemingly invisible support for it also stop happening, including changes in mental models and assumptions for people whose thought processes impact outcomes. Europe has always been more pedestrian friendly, in part because a lot of it was built before cars existed. There are countless towns where you cannot drive in some sections because it was built hundreds of years ago. You park and walk in. The US has much less of that. You see it on some major college campuses. You mostly don't see it as some historic part of town built before the car even existed. The existence of intractable, highly valued old parts of town like that will inevitably influence life experience, mental models and ongoing design policies, among other things. We just don't have that same psychological anchor for our landscapes and policies.
- xtiansimon 7y agoI was young once, had a car, lived in the burbs and drove like a maniac—listening to your music in your private space/auto-cocoon. Couldn’t get where I was going fast enough. Then I bought a motorcycle. Took the CHP approved two-day driving class. It made me a better driver. But I was still in a rush. Now I live outside of NYC. No car. No motorcycle. I walk or take taxis. In the burbs, people drive just as you describe. No awareness of pedestrians. Most people don’t obey right of way. And 9 out of ten drivers drive in excess of the speed limit—even in residential. It’s interesting to note. On the South Shore of Long Island there are more pedestrian deaths than where I live in the North Shore. The roads are much wider and laid out more on the grid on the South Shore. I guess it gives the careless driver the illusion of safer conditions for their recklessness.