3 ms·
> If you have a job that pays $20,000/year and you lose it to a robot, the silver lining is that the automation reduces the cost of living by $1000/year and so
by tzs 7y ago
> If you have a job that pays $20,000/year and you lose it to a robot, the silver lining is that the automation reduces the cost of living by $1000/year and so now you can take a different $19,000/year job with no reduction in quality of life.
What if your $20k/year job is in a factory making a product that is too expensive for people making $20k/year to afford? The automation lowers the cost of living for those who buy the product, not you.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> What if your $20k/year job is in a factory making a product that is too expensive for people making $20k/year to afford? The automation lowers the cost of living for those who buy the product, not you. The first thing to note is that this typically isn't what happens. The majority of goods are not luxury goods by definition, because most people can't afford luxury goods, so most production is not of luxury goods. And luxury goods also tend to be less subject to automation since scarcity and "craftsmanship" etc. is generally what makes them luxuries. If you can inexpensively mass produce it with a machine then it's no longer something ordinary people can't afford. Moreover, the aggregate is really what matters. If you replace grocery clerks with self-checkout machines and bank tellers with ATMs and both Toyota and Lexus factory workers with assembly robots, the Lexus factory workers may not be able to afford a Lexus, but they can afford a Toyota and also benefit from lower bank fees and grocery prices. Meanwhile the dentist who can afford a Lexus now has more money left over to buy whatever thing the former Lexus worker finds a job doing next.