5 ms·
> This article/researcher makes claims that: a) there is a mental health crisis among teenagers which is not parallel to other comparable generations, and b) th
by naasking 7y ago
> This article/researcher makes claims that: a) there is a mental health crisis among teenagers which is not parallel to other comparable generations, and b) that crisis is linked to mobile phones. I'm not convinced by either claim.
You probably should be, because there are objective markers that don't depend on communication:
https://twitter.com/JonHaidt/status/1083015453151318016 https://twitter.com/JonHaidt/status/1083015453151318016
> The article identifies that today's teenagers: get in less car accidents, have less risky sex, have a lower rate of teenage pregnancy, ingest less risky substances, are generally less violent - and presents this all as bad because it is different than what came before.
If teens are avoiding risk-seeking behaviour due to an increase in underlying anxieties, then yes, it quite literally is a problem and not just because it's different. Maybe you should give the psychologist who wrote the article the benefit of the doubt.
- watwut 7y ago> less car accidents, have less risky sex, have a lower rate of teenage pregnancy, ingest less risky substances, are generally less violent These are positive changes. All of them. These were literally something bad about older generation. All these things have negative consequences on not just risk accepting person, but also to other people around. If you are more anxious but less violent, then it is a good trade off.
- naasking 7y agoMerely repeating something does not make it fact. It's shortsighted to evaluate good and bad purely by outcome. Plenty of psychological and physiological pathologies drive reduced violence, less risk taking, etc. For instance, are you going to suggest people should become more psychopathic because it's correlated with success? Are you going to suggest all men take testosterone suppressants because that would reduce violence, risk taking and teenage pregnancy? If the outcome is all that matters, then why not right?
- watwut 7y agoI would strongly prefer anxious person in the same room over violent one. It is that simple. If what you need is testosterone suppressant to not hit me, yes I strongly prefer you taking it over me being beaten or me doing things I did not wanted to for fear of your aggression. It is better for you too, assuming cops and courts will do the thing they are supposed to - putting you in prison. Fortunately, men generally don't need testosterone suppressant to not be violent. Adult men violence is choice and occasionally mental problem. Teen pregnancy rates are again result largely of sexual education, girls better able to resist pressure to have unprotected sex and boys better knowing it causes problems to them too. There is literally nothing to gain by not using a condom in that situation. All of these are kids making better choices. That absolutely should count for something.
- naasking 7y ago> I would strongly prefer anxious person in the same room over violent one. It is that simple. False equivalency. "More violent" does not mean "violent". Kids rough housing are technically being violent. Are you really worried about that? > All of these are kids making better choices. Or it's kids not having natural impulses that are inherent to all human beings. And that would be a serious problem.
- watwut 7y agoMore anxiety does not mean constantly trembling from fear either. Difference against violence of past generation is NOT kids rough housing. It was real fights, real hits, real injuries. Real robbery, real violence toward (say) partners, real knife or real gun. Nice manipulative technique you used. But you know what? If there are less kids bullying other kids, that is good thing too. Because while "rough housing" between two consenting kids is fine, one kid bullying the other is often called rough housing by those who want to pretend every thing is fine. Keeping control over natural impulse to not use condom, to have random sex, to take heroin, to hit other people is a good thing. We have many natural impulses that are better off to be controlled. All of these harm not just the person who is doing it, but others too.
- 7y ago
- learnstats2 7y agoThanks for referencing Twitter, I hadn't thought to check that as a research source. The graph of suicide rates linked goes back to 1999. Suicide rate often tracks economic cycles - for example, the suicide rate was 50% higher in the 1920s than it is now.
- naasking 7y ago> Suicide rate often tracks economic cycles - for example, the suicide rate was 50% higher in the 1920s than it is now. Certainly among adults, but suicides among adolescents and teens tracking economic cycles? I'm skeptical.