4 ms·
> But a balance is needed, so if they had a robot tax as many have raised and mooted in the past, then perhaps that could be used to find education, free recrea
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> But a balance is needed, so if they had a robot tax as many have raised and mooted in the past, then perhaps that could be used to find education, free recreational activities.
If you have a job that pays $20,000/year and you lose it to a robot, the silver lining is that the automation reduces the cost of living by $1000/year and so now you can take a different $19,000/year job with no reduction in quality of life.
A robot tax actually makes this worse. It doesn't inherently prevent the automation -- a $5000 robot that can replace a $20,000/year worker would still do so if a tax made the robot cost $10,000 -- but now to add insult to injury the displaced worker is paying the robot tax in the form of higher prices.
The underlying friction with automation is that it's non-uniform. A widget used to cost $1000, which was $600 manufacturing labor and $400 administrative overhead. Then the manufacturing gets automated and it becomes a $500 widget, but the proportion which is administrative cost has grown from 40% to 80%.
That's what puts the displaced worker in a bad position. If they have to take a job that pays less at the same time as their cost of living declines, everything is fine as long as the cost reduction is at least as much as the wage reduction. But if other costs are keeping prices high despite the higher efficiency from the automation, then there's trouble.
So they key is to make sure the efficiency improvements are largely uniform. And markets are generally pretty good at that -- if they're competitive and don't have their hands tied.
Which leads us to the real problem. Some industries are monopolistic or subject to ossified regulatory systems. So as the cost of everything else goes down, the cost of housing doesn't due to zoning rules, the cost of medicine doesn't due to regulatory requirements, etc.
The things that can't respond well to market forces become a larger proportion of the economy, which is observed as higher prices for those things relative to other things.
The solution has to be to get the cost of those things down as well.
- mantas 7y agoIf millions of people will be fired from their $20k jobs, what's the chance that all of them will find other jobs paying $19k?
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> If millions of people will be fired from their $20k jobs, what's the chance that all of them will find other jobs paying $19k? Pretty good actually. As wages go down, demand for labor goes up. Moreover, if "millions of people" lose their jobs to automation then you would expect that to result in more than a 5% reduction in cost of living.
- pasquinelli 7y agoDoes automation have any effect on cost of living? How something is made doesn't change its market value.
- randomdata 7y agoHow something is made can change the market value if a change in the way something is made allows for an increase in supply. This is heavily dependent on there being a competitive market, however, just as the parent went into great detail over in the comment that came before the one you replied to.
- mantas 7y agoOnly if a given industry was already operating on super thin margins. For example if Apple was able to lower their manufacturing costs by 10%, I'm pretty sure they wouldn't pass that on to customers :)
- randomdata 7y agoApple doesn't really operate in a competitive marketplace with most of their products. If I figure out how to manufacture an iPhone for 10% less than Apple, thanks to various protection schemes afforded by law, I cannot reasonably start to sell an iPhone that costs less than Apple charges to try and gain marketshare. It is true that I can produce a device that has some similarities to the iPhone, but with things like incompatibles that prevent the end user from being able to run their favourite app or integrate with certain cloud services they subscribe to, they are not similar enough for the customer to consider them to be interchangeable. In reality, they would be sold to different markets. On the flip side, if I manufacture standard screws and figure out how to produce them for 10% less than anyone else who manufactures standard screws, there is a lot of incentive for me to increase supply to attract more customers to my product instead of someone else's. A competitive marketplace is necessary for that to take place.
- smackay 7y ago> If you have a job that pays $20,000/year and you lose it to a robot, the silver lining is that the automation reduces the cost of living by $1000/year I think that is a highly unlikely scenario. Automation is being introduced to reduce costs and so increase profits. There should be no expectation that these savings will be passed on to consumers. Even with competition, businesses are loathed to lower prices and instead will offer a better product or service for the same price. As a result the cost of living may not go down unless there is simply no market at that price. When that happens the outcome is not so clear. The company may adapt or simply go out of business.
- fuzz4lyfe 7y agoAll these consumers now with lower incomes, why wouldn't you buy one of these robots yourself and capture this new untapped market? I hope firms will be stupid enough to do as you describe I'd love to be rich someday. The only possible reason why you wouldn't is regulation. If the government makes it difficult or impossible for you to buy the same robot that Walmart buys then I can see a point but that is exactly why there needs to be less regulation and taxes around automation.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Automation is being introduced to reduce costs and so increase profits. You're ignoring the possibility of increasing profits by increasing volume. If you have $9 in costs on a $10 item and automation reduces your costs to $6, you can make a $4 margin on your existing volume, but that isn't as profitable as making a $2 margin on 5X your existing volume by undercutting all of your competitors and taking their customers. So you do, and prices fall from $10 to $8. Until your competitors realize they can get back all their lost business and then some by automating too and then charging $7. The only way this doesn't happen is a lack of effective competition. > Even with competition, businesses are loathed to lower prices and instead will offer a better product or service for the same price. You may want to familiarize yourself with Walmart's business model.
- tzs 7y ago> If you have a job that pays $20,000/year and you lose it to a robot, the silver lining is that the automation reduces the cost of living by $1000/year and so now you can take a different $19,000/year job with no reduction in quality of life. What if your $20k/year job is in a factory making a product that is too expensive for people making $20k/year to afford? The automation lowers the cost of living for those who buy the product, not you.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> What if your $20k/year job is in a factory making a product that is too expensive for people making $20k/year to afford? The automation lowers the cost of living for those who buy the product, not you. The first thing to note is that this typically isn't what happens. The majority of goods are not luxury goods by definition, because most people can't afford luxury goods, so most production is not of luxury goods. And luxury goods also tend to be less subject to automation since scarcity and "craftsmanship" etc. is generally what makes them luxuries. If you can inexpensively mass produce it with a machine then it's no longer something ordinary people can't afford. Moreover, the aggregate is really what matters. If you replace grocery clerks with self-checkout machines and bank tellers with ATMs and both Toyota and Lexus factory workers with assembly robots, the Lexus factory workers may not be able to afford a Lexus, but they can afford a Toyota and also benefit from lower bank fees and grocery prices. Meanwhile the dentist who can afford a Lexus now has more money left over to buy whatever thing the former Lexus worker finds a job doing next.