3 ms·
To paraphrase: > The effect: "An ideologue believes a (wrong) thing. You tell them, no. They double down. Your effort to refute has backfired." This is actuall
by backfired 7y ago
To paraphrase:
> The effect: "An ideologue believes a (wrong) thing. You tell them, no. They double down. Your effort to refute has backfired." This is actually rare.
It doesn't matter, because we've all been there. We've all experienced clashes of opinion, and none of us like being wrong, so we resist adjusting.
Lots of us do it. It's a natural part of childhood. Being afraid of the dark. Believing in ghosts. Santa Clause. The Easter Bunny. The Tooth Fairy. How did you cope?
What about other aspects of belief? Religion? What aspects of religion does one regard as history? How many people remain religious in the face of contrary evidence?
Suddenly, this effect seems less rare.
- username90 7y agoThe backfire effect is obviously not universal, otherwise it would be impossible to teach for example Newtonian physics. So if you present strong enough proof people will change their minds. I think the problem is that people don't really learn what a strong proof is, so when two people who each have a weak understanding of the topic tries to argue both will see that the other is ignorant but not that themselves are ignorant. After the discussion both will have correctly refuted a lot of claims from the other side, thus "strengthening" their own views. If this often happen to you then you are likely not as well informed as you think you are. In short, I believe that "you can't reason someone into a position that you didn't reason yourself into" is true, while the popular "you can't reason someone out of a position that they didn't reason themselves into" is wrong.
- Torgo 7y agoNot necessary. Science advances when entrenched proponents of the old theory die out.