3 ms·
It makes me sad that "SEO consulting" exists as a thing. I understand the need for it, but it's always just felt so dirty. It's basically someone who is an ex
by jedberg 7y ago
It makes me sad that "SEO consulting" exists as a thing. I understand the need for it, but it's always just felt so dirty. It's basically someone who is an expert at tricking a single business, and it's a constant cat and mouse game.
And Google will even tell you how to get a high ranking, which pretty much boils down to "make content that humans find compelling and Google will too". It's all the other "tricks" that might work for a while until Google gets wise and changes their algorithm and then we all start the dance over.
It was just like the spammers on reddit -- they'd come up with some new trick, we'd block it, they'd find another new trick, and so on, but all along, the stuff that got to the top was for the most part things that people found interesting. Post interesting content was always a good strategy, even if there were a trick or two that might work to boost you on any given week.
I just wish we could all just make good content and not worry about gaming the directory, but a few bad actors make that impossible for the rest of us. :(
- cooperadymas 7y agoThere are plenty of bad actors in the SEO world, and it certainly has an overwhelmingly slimy history. But as is usually the case, the issue is more complex than "SEO bad, good content good." I've been preaching basically what you said as the core tenet of SEO for over a decade. (I would add a "that people are actively looking for" clause to "make content that humans find compelling.") This is much more challenging than one would think, and can really benefit from someone experienced. Whether you call that Search Engine Optimization or Content Marketing or Copywriting or just Writing, done correctly it all boils down to this same principle. That alone often warrants someone to assist a business, as most businesses don't have the internal resources or knowledge to do it entirely themselves. But there's more that falls under the SEO umbrella. 1. The technical aspects of configuring a site to be indexable, accessible, and well-architectured. This might have traditionally fallen under the guise of a webmaster, and for larger sites might fall to more specialized experts, but for the large majority of sites the only people working on these issues are "SEOs". 2. Actually going out and promoting a website in some way. The best content in the world will go unnoticed by man and machine if it's not discoverable from some other source. This has traditionally meant "link building" or (for a long time) "guest posting", and might also include PR or advertising depending on who you ask. 3. Monitoring the results and improving the approach. It's great to say "make content that is compelling" but if you're spending the resources to do this then you need to monitor and analyze the effects it has. This can get incredibly complex, but again, for most websites, is performed by an SEO.
- quickthrower2 7y agoSEO Consulting isn't necessarily a bad thing. If it takes someone from completely bad site for SEO -> reasonable white-hat SEO site then that's great for everyone involved.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y ago> make content that humans find compelling and Google will too I just switched to DDG as my default search because Google's results are so bad now that the first three or more pages are all zero information e-commerce sites. I used to never click beyond page one.
- hnick 7y agoIt's not even that the SEO consulting exists, for me it's that Google's dominance has made the web very samey and bland. For one example "content people like" on YouTube is apparently headshots with exaggerated expressions, large colourful text, and arrows and circles and other "exciting" features. Not to mention the trend towards a generic "YouTube voice" inflection that they all seem to share if they stay on the platform long enough. There's plenty of great stuff, but it doesn't seem to find its way onto my suggestion feed at all.
- dalbasal 7y ago"For the most part" is just not all that relevant. It's much smaller subsets of the whole that drive what happens. Google "recipe for X." Mostly, the first 3 results will be recipe pages preceded by junk text describing recipes in paragraph/narrative form... tailored to the ranking algorithms. Google "online dating sites." The first couple of acreens will be ads (high value ones). Mostly, they'll be "aggregators" which rank the top 5 dating sites that pay affiliate fees. The first few organic results will be similar to the ads, but worse, because these need to cater to search engines, first and worry about getting users to their customers second. Where the value of clicks is high, what happens with search results isn't at all like the "for the most part." For the most part, person people search for "penguins" or "Penelope Cruz." Here, the advertisers and SEO guys aren't involved. It's in specific little, high revenue areas where spam/advertising/SEO outguns everything else. You can feasibily "just write good content" about penguins and rank highly.